2003ApJ...597....9D


Query : 2003ApJ...597....9D

2003ApJ...597....9D - Astrophys. J., 597, 9-20 (2003/November-1)

A model-independent determination of the expansion and acceleration rates of the universe as a function of redshift and constraints on dark energy.

DALY R.A. and DJORGOVSKI S.G.

Abstract (from CDS):

Determination of the expansion and acceleration history of the universe is one of the fundamental goals of cosmology. Detailed measurements of these rates as a function of redshift can provide new physical insights into the nature and evolution of the dark energy, which apparently dominates the global dynamics of the universe at the present epoch. We present here dimensionless coordinate distances y(z) to 20 radio galaxies reaching out to z~1.8, the redshift range currently not covered by supernova standard-candle observations. There is very good agreement between coordinate distances to radio galaxies and supernovae for the redshift range in which these measurements overlap, suggesting that neither is plagued at this level by unknown systematic errors. We develop a simple numerical method for a direct determination of the expansion and acceleration rates, E(z) and q(z), from the data, which makes no assumptions about the underlying cosmological model or the equation of state parameter w. This differential method is in contrast to the traditional cosmological tests, in which particular model equations are integrated and then compared with the observations. The new approach is model independent, but at a cost of being noisier and highly sensitive to the amount and quality of the available data. We illustrate the method by applying it to the currently available supernova data and the data on radio galaxies presented here. We derive the expansion rate of the universe as a function of redshift, E(z), and for the first time we obtain a direct estimate of the acceleration rate of the universe as a function of redshift, q(z), in a way that is independent of assumptions regarding the dark energy and its redshift evolution. The current observations indicate that the universe makes a transition from acceleration to deceleration at a redshift greater than 0.3, with a best-fit estimate of about 0.45; this transition redshift and our determinations of E(z) are broadly in agreement with the currently popular Friedmann-Lemaitre cosmology with Ωm=0.3 and ΩΛ=0.7, even though no model assumptions are made in deriving the fits for E(z) and q(z). With the advent of much better and richer data sets in the future, our direct method can provide a useful complementarity and an independent check on the traditional cosmological tests.

Abstract Copyright:

Journal keyword(s): Cosmology: Cosmological Parameters - Cosmology: Observations - Cosmology: Theory - Cosmology: Dark Matter - Equation of State

Simbad objects: 98

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 98
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2024
#notes
1 SN 1995aq SN* 00 29 04.26 +07 51 20.0       22.60   SNI: 17 1
2 SN 1995ar SN* 01 01 20.41 +04 18 33.8       22.71   SNI: 22 1
3 SN 1995as SN* 01 01 35.30 +04 26 14.8       23.02   SNI: 23 1
4 SN 1995at SN* 01 04 50.94 +04 33 53.0       22.62   SNI: 17 1
5 SN 1992bo SN* 01 21 58.44 -34 12 43.5   15.85 15.76     SNIa 114 1
6 SN 1992br SN* 01 45 44.83 -56 05 57.9   19.34 19.24     SNIa 49 1
7 3C 55.0 rG 01 57 10.7 +28 51 40   20.8       ~ 154 1
8 SN 1995aw SN* 02 24 55.54 +00 53 07.5       21.75   SNI: 20 1
9 SN 1995ax SN* 02 26 25.80 +00 48 44.2       22.53   SNI: 22 1
10 3C 68.2 rG 02 34 23.9 +31 34 17   24       ~ 138 1
11 SN 1994am SN* 02 40 02.06 -01 37 14.9       21.82   SNIa: 16 1
12 SN 1995ak SN* 02 45 48.83 +03 13 50.1   16.23 16.07     SNIa 64 1
13 SN 1995ay SN* 03 01 07.52 +00 21 19.4       22.64   SNI: 22 1
14 SN 1992bc SN* 03 05 16.05 -39 33 34.6   15.15 15.17     SNIa 127 1
15 SN 1994al SN* 03 06 22.45 +17 18 33.7       22.37   SNIa 17 1
16 SN 1992bs SN* 03 29 27.20 -37 16 18.9     18.28     SNIa 55 1
17 SN 1992bp SN* 03 36 37.95 -18 21 13.7   18.53 18.37     SNIa 64 1
18 SN 1995az SN* 04 40 33.59 -05 30 03.6       22.44   SNI: 24 1
19 SN 1995bd SN* 04 45 21.24 +11 04 02.5   17.29       SNIapec 67 1
20 SN 1997F SN* 04 55 14.27 -05 51 44.8       22.90   SNIa 22 1
21 SN 1997G SN* 04 58 30.23 -03 16 04.0       23.56   SNIa 16 1
22 SN 1992bh SN* 04 59 27.55 -58 49 44.2   17.68 17.55     SNIa 64 1
23 SN 1997H SN* 04 59 36.57 -03 09 34.6       22.68   SNIa 21 1
24 SN 1997I SN* 04 59 37.31 -03 09 01.6       20.04   SNIa 19 1
25 SN 1997J SN* 07 41 17.83 +09 33 11.4       23.25   SNIa: 15 1
26 SN 1992bg SN* 07 41 56.55 -62 31 10.0   17.39 16.66     SNIa 57 2
27 SN 1995E SN* 07 51 56.75 +73 00 34.6   16.81 15.9     SNIa 117 1
28 SN 1997K SN* 07 54 55.09 +04 19 01.3       23.73   SNIa 15 1
29 3C 194.0 QSO 08 10 03.3449360136 +42 28 03.220633740   24       ~ 104 1
30 SN 1995ba SN* 08 19 06.46 +07 43 21.2       22.08   SNI: 20 1
31 SN 1997L SN* 08 21 57.14 +03 53 35.7       22.93   SNIa 14 1
32 SN 1997N SN* 08 23 50.03 +03 28 52.8       20.19   SNIa 17 1
33 SN 1997af SN* 08 23 52.67 +04 08 44.0       22.96   SNIa 23 1
34 SN 1997ac SN* 08 24 05.21 +04 11 22.6       21.38   SNIa 20 1
35 SN 1996K SN* 08 24 43.49 -00 21 06.2       23   SNIa 16 1
36 SN 1995D SN* 09 40 54.753 +05 08 26.16   13.42 13.22     SNIa 150 1
37 SN 1993ag SN* 10 03 35.00 -35 27 47.6   18.30 17.78     SNIa 67 1
38 SN 1996E SN* 10 10 20.28 -12 33 09.2       22.2   SNIa 14 1
39 SN 1996J SN* 10 10 33.21 -12 37 05.2       22.5   SNIa 17 1
40 3C 239 rG 10 11 45.6 +46 28 20   22.5       ~ 155 1
41 SN 1994G SN* 10 19 26.68 +50 52 19.4       21.52   SNIa 20 1
42 3C 244.1 QSO 10 33 33.9860997312 +58 14 35.611906344   19.0 19.0     ~ 186 1
43 SN 1993B SN* 10 34 51.38 -34 26 30.0   18.81 18.39     SNIa 54 1
44 SN 1999O SN* 10 42 05.22 -00 29 00.2       24.1   SNII 4 1
45 SN 1996cf SN* 10 48 50.96 +00 03 30.4       22.70   SNIa 21 1
46 SN 1997ai SN* 10 48 57.61 +00 31 50.0       22.25   SNIa 22 1
47 SN 1995K SN* 10 50 46.95 -09 15 06.6       22.5   SNIa: 32 1
48 SN 1997aj SN* 10 55 52.98 -03 59 02.3       22.55   SNIa 21 1
49 SN 1997P SN* 10 55 55.93 -03 56 48.2       22.52   SNIa 18 1
50 SN 1997Q SN* 10 56 51.48 -03 58 36.9       22.01   SNIa 16 1
51 SN 1996cl SN* 10 56 59.13 -03 37 36.4       23.53   SNIa: 24 1
52 SN 1997R SN* 10 57 19.23 -03 54 51.7       23.28   SNIa 18 1
53 SN 1997am SN* 10 57 31.52 -03 13 48.3       21.97   SNIa 21 1
54 SN 1997S SN* 10 57 51.59 -03 45 46.9       23.03   SNIa 14 1
55 3C 247 QSO 10 58 58.8 +43 01 23   21.5       ~ 160 1
56 3C 265.0 Sy1 11 45 29.0 +31 33 50   20.0       ~ 247 0
57 3C 267 rG 11 49 56.5 +12 47 19   22.5       ~ 155 2
58 SN 1994F SN* 11 49 59.53 +10 42 57.8       22.08   SNIa 18 1
59 SN 1996U SN* 11 50 33.51 +10 26 45.4       22.2   SNIa 15 1
60 3C 268.1 rG 12 00 23.2 +73 00 48   22       ~ 147 1
61 SN 1996I SN* 12 00 39.43 -00 16 02.4       23.0   SNIa 17 1
62 SN 1996H SN* 12 28 52.78 -00 05 41.0       22.8   SNIa 15 1
63 SN 1994M SN* 12 31 08.61 +00 36 19.6   16.31 16.24     SNIa 93 1
64 SN 1994S SN* 12 31 21.85 +29 08 04.0   14.80 14.77     SNIa 109 1
65 SN 1997ff SN* 12 36 44.10 +62 12 44.7         26.77 SNIa 66 1
66 SN 1997cj SN* 12 37 04.27 +62 26 24.9         22.8 SNIa 19 1
67 SN 1992P SN* 12 42 48.93 +10 21 36.2   16.14 16.09     SNIa 74 1
68 SN 1996ck SN* 12 48 35.19 -00 46 03.0       23.08   SNIa: 15 1
69 2C 1066 SyG 12 56 57.5 +47 20 20   22.0       ~ 281 0
70 SN 1994T SN* 13 21 30.73 -02 08 56.5   17.31 17.15     SNIa 51 1
71 SN 1992ag SN* 13 24 09.85 -23 52 43.7   16.64 16.15     SNIa 63 1
72 SN 1993O SN* 13 31 07.87 -33 12 50.5   17.79 17.96     SNIa 68 1
73 3C 289 QSO 13 45 26.699 +49 46 31.39   23       ~ 161 1
74 SN 1996ci SN* 13 45 56.16 +02 26 53.7       22.19   SNIa 21 1
75 SN 1997ap SN* 13 47 09.90 +02 23 57.5       23.20   SNIa 26 1
76 SN 1996C SN* 13 50 48.60 +49 19 07.1   16.53 16.48     SNIa 77 1
77 SN 1993H SN* 13 52 50.34 -30 42 23.3   16.99       SNIa 88 1
78 SN 1996ab SN* 15 21 08.35 +27 55 36.8   19.47 19.55     SNIa 34 1
79 SN 1996cm SN* 15 30 11.25 +05 55 27.0       22.66   SNIa 20 1
80 4C 55.31 rG 15 35 01.2 +55 36 49   23       ~ 124 1
81 3C 324.0 Sy1 15 49 49.2 +21 25 39   21.5       ~ 309 0
82 7C 154914.09+625020.00 QSO 15 49 59.2 +62 41 18   21.92 20.70     ~ 143 2
83 NAME 3C 330G2 Sy2 16 09 36.6 +65 56 43   20.33       ~ 275 1
84 SN 1992bi SN* 16 10 12.79 +39 47 12.5       22.12   SNIa 30 1
85 3C 337 QSO 16 28 53.9 +44 19 03   20.0       ~ 148 1
86 SN 1997ck SN* 16 53 00.27 +35 03 46.4         24 ~ 21 1
87 SN 1997ce SN* 17 07 48.26 +44 01 26.2         23.3 SNIa 17 1
88 3C 356 QSO 17 24 20.2 +50 57 14   21.5 21.5     ~ 224 1
89 NAME Cyg A Sy2 19 59 28.35656837 +40 44 02.0972325   16.22 15.10     ~ 2367 2
90 SN 1992al SN* 20 45 56.49 -51 23 39.9   14.59 14.54     SNIa 84 2
91 3C 427.1 rG 21 04 07.5 +76 33 10   23.3 21.1     ~ 156 1
92 SN 1992ae SN* 21 28 17.94 -61 33 01.4   18.64 18.45     SNIa 65 2
93 SN 1990af SN* 21 34 58.12 -62 44 07.4   17.91 17.75     SNIa 80 1
94 3C 437 rG 21 47 25.1 +15 20 38   23       ~ 128 2
95 SN 1994an SN* 22 44 18.87 +00 06 48.7       22.14   SNIa 16 1
96 SN 1995ac SN* 22 45 34.14 -08 45 04.7   17.23 17.10     SNIapec 79 2
97 SN 1992aq SN* 23 04 34.76 -37 20 42.1   19.39 19.33     SNIa 55 1
98 SN 1992bl SN* 23 15 13.09 -44 44 35.7   17.34 17.33     SNIa 62 1

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2003ApJ...597....9D and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu