2007ApJ...655..179W


Query : 2007ApJ...655..179W

2007ApJ...655..179W - Astrophys. J., 655, 179-211 (2007/January-3)

Ages and metallicities of extragalactic globular clusters from spectral and photometric fits of stellar population synthesis models.

WOLF M.J., DRORY N., GEBHARDT K. and HILL G.J.

Abstract (from CDS):

Spectra of galaxies contain an enormous amount of information about the relative mixture of ages and metallicities of constituent stars. We present a comprehensive study designed to extract the maximum information from spectra of data quality typical in large galaxy surveys. These techniques are not intended for detailed stellar population studies that use high-quality spectra. We test techniques on a sample of globular clusters, which should consist of single stellar populations and provide good test cases, using the Bruzual-Charlot high-resolution stellar population synthesis models to simultaneously estimate the ages and metallicities of 101 globular clusters in M31 and the Magellanic Clouds. The clusters cover a wide range of ages and metallicities, 4 Myr<tage<20 Gyr and -1.6<[Fe/H]<+0.3, estimated by other methods in the literature. We compare results from model fits to both the spectra and photometry and find that fits to continuum-normalized spectra over the entire range available, typically 3500 Å to 1 µm for this sample, provide the best results. For clusters older than 1 Gyr we agree with literature ages to 0.16 dex (35%) and [Fe/H] to 0.12 dex. For younger clusters we agree with literature ages to 0.3 dex (63%) but cannot constrain the metallicity. It is particularly important to use the entire continuum-normalized spectrum to avoid problems with model continua for young objects and to break age-metallicity degeneracies of broadband photometry. Our required S/N is 15-30 Å–1 for 20% age uncertainties and 30-55 Å–1 for 10% uncertainties over spectral resolutions of Δλ=5-25 Å. This technique should work well for the age-metallicity parameter space expected for early-type galaxies at z∼1, although individual galaxy spectral S/N may require the co-addition of a few like objects.

Abstract Copyright:

Journal keyword(s): Galaxies: Evolution - Galaxies: Fundamental Parameters - Galaxies: Individual: Messier Number: M31 - Galaxies: Star Clusters - Galaxies: Stellar Content - Galaxies: Magellanic Clouds

Simbad objects: 109

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 109
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2024
#notes
1 NGC 104 GlC 00 24 05.359 -72 04 53.20     4.09     ~ 3917 0
2 NGC 121 GlC 00 26 49.0 -71 32 10   11.2 11.24     ~ 311 0
3 NAME Mayall II GlC 00 32 46.5323801712 +39 34 40.504803060   14.564 13.807 13.208 12.684 ~ 389 1
4 Bol 23 GlC 00 41 01.151 +41 13 45.41 16.040 15.400 14.17 13.560 12.570 ~ 91 0
5 Bol 96 GlC 00 42 26.080 +41 19 14.79 18.796 17.863 16.635 15.857 15.188 ~ 67 0
6 Bol 103 GlC 00 42 29.7326748504 +41 17 57.540046020 16.76 16.161 15.166 14.548 13.95 ~ 54 0
7 Bol 104 GlC 00 42 29.9287305024 +41 17 25.652296608 18.67 18.285 17.456 16.957 16.551 ~ 31 0
8 Bol 106 GlC 00 42 31.0374692880 +41 12 18.277656552 17.556 17.086 16.137 15.539 14.770 ~ 43 0
9 Bol 107 GlC 00 42 31.2490262592 +41 19 38.842862160 17.00 16.725 15.764 15.171 14.681 ~ 73 0
10 Bol 109 GlC 00 42 32.1641123352 +41 10 27.918059844 18.080 17.377 16.371 15.640 15.38 ~ 55 0
11 Bol 112 GlC 00 42 33.2479026840 +41 17 42.339523488 18.56 17.506 16.450 15.795 15.220 ~ 54 0
12 Bol 114 GlC 00 42 34.2950873832 +41 12 44.863394760 17.954 17.840 17.085 16.567 16.16 ~ 42 0
13 Bol 115 GlC 00 42 34.4029603032 +41 14 01.942644156 17.844 17.058 16.042 15.408 14.81 ~ 64 0
14 2MASS J00423454+4115084 * 00 42 34.5486551040 +41 15 08.525754036 17.974 17.630 16.823 16.378   ~ 19 1
15 Bol D64 GlC 00 42 35.5314236304 +41 14 34.207402308 17.472 17.201 16.349 15.828 15.51 ~ 28 2
16 Bol 119 GlC 00 42 36.10 +41 17 35.6 18.86 18.351 17.408 16.812 16.267 ~ 37 0
17 Bol 124 GlC 00 42 41.43 +41 15 23.9 16.153 15.589 14.73 14.060 13.74 ~ 66 0
18 Bol 126 GlC 00 42 43.6897180488 +41 12 42.775928028 18.059 17.924 17.149 16.662 16.23 ~ 59 0
19 M 31 AGN 00 42 44.330 +41 16 07.50 4.86 4.36 3.44     ~ 12650 1
20 Bol 127 GlC 00 42 44.52 +41 14 41.5 15.80 15.200 14.42 13.800 13.29 ~ 61 0
21 Bol 134 GlC 00 42 51.6426613536 +41 14 03.617692692 17.73 17.582 16.699 16.161 15.736 ~ 51 0
22 Bol 171 GlC 00 43 25.6003962624 +41 15 37.095704604 16.795 16.192 15.217 14.635 14.07 ~ 73 0
23 NAME SMC G 00 52 38.0 -72 48 01   2.79 2.2     ~ 11149 1
24 NGC 299 Cl* 00 53 24.74 -72 11 47.6 11.71 12.05 11.73   10.67 ~ 41 0
25 NGC 330 Cl* 00 56 18.55 -72 27 45.1 9.37 9.76 9.55   8.89 ~ 410 0
26 NGC 419 OpC 01 08 17.26 -72 53 01.8 11.41 11.16 10.50   9.34 ~ 272 0
27 NGC 1466 GlC 03 44 32.71 -71 40 18.0   11.6 11.59     ~ 162 0
28 IC 2105 HII 04 49 26 -69 12.0   12.68 12.78     ~ 17 2
29 NGC 1711 Cl* 04 50 37.320 -69 59 01.72   11.22 11.10     ~ 113 0
30 BRHT 1b Cl* 04 51 51 -69 23.6           ~ 34 1
31 NGC 1714 EmO 04 52 08.4 -66 55 23   11.51 11.61     ~ 84 2
32 NGC 1736 EmO 04 53 03.7239890448 -68 03 05.101346628   15.5       ~ 18 0
33 NGC 1731 As* 04 53 15 -66 55.6           ~ 40 0
34 NGC 1743 Cl* 04 54 03 -69 12.1     11.26     ~ 38 2
35 NGC 1735 Cl* 04 54 20.530 -67 05 58.29   10.88 10.76     ~ 20 0
36 NGC 1755 Cl* 04 55 16.390 -68 12 23.12   10.00 9.85     ~ 77 0
37 NGC 1767 Cl* 04 56 29.280 -69 24 14.34           ~ 37 2
38 HD 32228 WR* 04 56 34.666 -66 28 26.34   10.685 10.830     WC4+O9.5II: 93 0
39 NGC 1761 As* 04 56 39 -66 29.0     9.94     ~ 99 0
40 NGC 1772 Cl* 04 56 54.480 -69 33 25.36   11.22 10.97     ~ 19 0
41 IRAS 04571-6627 mul 04 57 15.5 -66 23 14           ~ 52 1
42 HD 32340 Em* 04 57 16.253 -66 23 20.94   13.11 12.45 14.00   O3-O6V 77 0
43 NGC 1782 Cl* 04 57 51.490 -69 23 32.92   10.75 10.50     ~ 23 0
44 NGC 1774 Cl* 04 58 06.120 -67 14 27.40   10.96 10.76     ~ 36 0
45 NGC 1783 GlC 04 59 08.590 -65 59 15.84   10.9 10.93     ~ 253 0
46 KMHK 387 Cl* 04 59 20.450 -66 19 12.85   12.26 12.03     ~ 11 0
47 HD 268850 AB* 05 02 21.4730341272 -66 06 38.294439372   11.83 11.55 12.43   ~ 89 0
48 NGC 1805 GlC 05 02 21.690 -66 06 39.43           ~ 111 0
49 NGC 1818 GlC 05 04 13.300 -66 26 05.47           ~ 261 0
50 NGC 1831 GlC 05 06 16.12 -64 55 06.9   11.52 11.18     ~ 164 0
51 NGC 1847 Cl* 05 07 08.200 -68 58 15.49   12.508 12.469     ~ 89 0
52 NGC 1850 Cl* 05 08 50.190 -68 45 35.65   8.84 8.96     ~ 273 1
53 NGC 1855 Cl* 05 09 21.180 -68 50 39.56   10.18 10.39     ~ 78 0
54 NGC 1856 Cl* 05 09 30.290 -69 07 45.08   10.40 10.06     ~ 153 0
55 NGC 1872 Cl* 05 13 10.040 -69 18 44.95   11.39 11.04     ~ 38 0
56 NGC 1866 GlC 05 13 38.920 -65 27 52.75           ~ 421 0
57 NGC 1868 GlC 05 14 36.60 -63 57 25.7   12.02 11.57     ~ 121 0
58 NGC 1895 Cl* 05 16 53.4 -67 19 51     12.93     ~ 27 0
59 NGC 1903 Cl* 05 17 22.700 -69 20 08.17           ~ 66 1
60 NAME S Dor Cluster Cl* 05 18 16 -69 15.1   15.0       ~ 16 0
61 NGC 1921 ? 05 19 20 -69 47.3           ~ 7 0
62 CD-68 294 As* 05 21 58 -67 57.3           ~ 110 0
63 IC 2127 EmO 05 22 12.532 -67 58 31.92     11.60     ~ 98 1
64 NAME LMC G 05 23 34.6 -69 45 22     0.4     ~ 17434 0
65 NGC 1949 Cl* 05 24 58.2 -68 28 41     12.39     ~ 30 1
66 NGC 1951 Cl* 05 26 06.766752 -66 35 47.80500           ~ 33 0
67 NGC 1967 Cl* 05 26 43.320 -69 05 51.98   10.80 10.81     ~ 24 0
68 NGC 1970 ISM 05 26 49 -68 49.7   10.45 10.28     ~ 17 0
69 NGC 1984 Cl* 05 27 40 -69 08.1   10.00 9.99     ~ 78 0
70 NGC 1983 Cl* 05 27 44 -68 59.1           ~ 53 0
71 TYC 9162-671-1 s*y 05 27 45.309 -68 59 07.58   11.38 13.162 10.92 10.41 F9Iab 8 0
72 NGC 1994 Cl* 05 28 22.7 -69 08 32           ~ 47 0
73 NGC 1978 GlC 05 28 45.330 -66 14 12.04   10.7 10.70     ~ 309 0
74 NGC 2002 Cl* 05 30 21.000 -66 53 06.20           ~ 63 0
75 NGC 2004 Cl* 05 30 41.340 -67 17 21.83   9.6       ~ 275 0
76 NGC 2003 Cl* 05 30 55.040 -66 27 57.97           ~ 21 0
77 NGC 2009 Cl* 05 30 59 -69 11.1   11.29 11.02     ~ 17 0
78 NGC 2006 Cl* 05 31 19 -66 58.4   11.00 10.88     ~ 35 0
79 [SL63] 538 Cl* 05 31 19.600 -66 57 50.69   9.9 11.30     ~ 35 0
80 NGC 2011 Cl* 05 32 19 -67 31.3   10.62 10.58     ~ 71 0
81 NGC 2025 Cl* 05 32 33.170 -71 43 03.19   11.18 10.94     ~ 22 0
82 NGC 2021 As* 05 33 30.170 -67 27 18.31     12.06     ~ 26 0
83 KMHK 1074 Cl* 05 33 58.590 -67 00 34.74     12.61     ~ 8 0
84 NGC 2033 As* 05 34 43 -69 44.2   11.53 11.63     ~ 28 0
85 ESO 86-12 Cl* 05 34 43.360 -66 57 46.43     11.17     ~ 10 0
86 NGC 2032 HII 05 35 23.5 -67 34 56           ~ 74 1
87 NGC 2035 ISM 05 35 32 -67 35.1     10.99     ~ 11 0
88 BAT99 77 WR* 05 35 58.889 -69 11 47.88           WN7 72 0
89 HD 269828 EB* 05 35 58.91 -69 11 47.3     13.031   12.837 WN7+O3 72 0
90 NGC 2042 Cl* 05 36 09.980 -68 54 53.78   9.82 9.58     ~ 30 0
91 NGC 2041 Cl* 05 36 28.090 -66 59 29.73   10.58 10.36     ~ 38 0
92 NGC 2058 Cl* 05 36 58.560 -70 09 44.75   12.09 11.85     ~ 42 0
93 NGC 2070 Cl* 05 38 42 -69 06.0     7.25     ~ 378 1
94 [SL63] 639 As* 05 39 39 -69 12.1   12.13 11.53     ~ 28 0
95 NGC 2091 Cl* 05 40 59.410 -69 26 13.79   12.39 12.07     ~ 17 0
96 NGC 2092 Cl* 05 41 22.600 -69 13 31.29           ~ 14 0
97 NGC 2100 Cl* 05 42 07.200 -69 12 26.99   9.6       ~ 189 0
98 NGC 2096 Cl* 05 42 16.460 -68 27 34.93   11.82 11.31     ~ 15 0
99 NGC 2102 Cl* 05 42 25.090 -69 29 29.54     11.44     ~ 18 0
100 NGC 2098 Cl* 05 42 29.630 -68 16 26.35   10.89 10.73     ~ 37 0
101 NGC 2134 Cl* 05 51 55.950 -71 05 53.57   11.05       ~ 72 0
102 NGC 2136 Cl* 05 53 01.800 -69 29 24.24   10.99 10.70     ~ 118 1
103 NGC 2147 Cl* 05 55 46.300 -68 12 07.51   13.20 12.94     ~ 13 0
104 NGC 2157 Cl* 05 57 35.430 -69 11 48.67   10.35 10.16     ~ 120 0
105 NGC 2156 GlC 05 57 45 -68 27.6   11.50 11.38     ~ 52 0
106 NGC 2159 GlC 05 57 57 -68 37.4   11.66 11.38     ~ 46 0
107 NGC 2164 OpC 05 58 55.900 -68 30 58.09   10.44 10.34     ~ 123 0
108 NGC 2214 OpC 06 12 57 -68 15.6   11.04 10.93     ~ 119 0
109 NAME GOODS-N Field reg 12 36 55.0 +62 14 15           ~ 1156 1

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2007ApJ...655..179W and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu