2009ApJ...698..812G

Query : 2009ApJ...698..812G

2009ApJ...698..812G - Astrophys. J., 698, 812-818 (2009/June-2)

The mbh-sigma diagram and the offset nature of barred active galaxies.

GRAHAM A.W. and LI I.-H.

Abstract (from CDS):

From a sample of 50 predominantly inactive galaxies with direct supermassive black hole mass measurements, it has recently been established that barred galaxies tend to reside rightward of the Mbh-σ relation defined by nonbarred galaxies. Either black holes in barred galaxies tend to be anemic or the central velocity dispersions in these galaxies have a tendency to be elevated by the presence of the bar. The latter option is in accord with studies connecting larger velocity dispersions in galaxies with old bars, while the former scenario is at odds with the observation that barred galaxies do not deviate from the Mbh-luminosity relation. Using a sample of 88 galaxies with active galactic nuclei, whose supermassive black hole masses have been estimated from their associated emission lines, we reveal for the first time that they also display this same general behavior in the Mbh-σ diagram depending on the presence of a bar or not. A new symmetrical and nonsymmetrical "barless" Mbh-σ relation is derived using 82 nonbarred galaxies. The barred galaxies are shown to reside on or up to ∼1 dex below this relation. This may explain why narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies appear offset from the "barless" Mbh-σ relation, and has far-reaching implications given that over half of the disk galaxy population are barred.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): black hole physics - galaxies: active - galaxies: nuclei - galaxies: Seyfert - galaxies: structure

Simbad objects: 89

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 89
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA 		ICRS (J2000)
DEC 		Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2024 		#notes
1 2MASX J00080560+1450227 Sy1 00 08 05.6223262608 +14 50 23.372708964   17.94 17.33     ~ 49 0
2 LEDA 2549 Sy1 00 42 36.8630508072 -10 49 22.080489888   17.03 16.58 13.7   ~ 46 0
3 2XMM J010712.0+140844 Sy1 01 07 12.0268679880 +14 08 44.981850408   19.30 18.83     ~ 49 0
4 LEDA 1154714 Sy1 01 17 03.5826317664 +00 00 27.366719364   17.29 16.79     ~ 48 0
5 2MASX J02045922-0808159 Sy1 02 04 59.2503143832 -08 08 16.018759248   18.77 18.10     ~ 15 0
6 Mrk 1018 Sy1 02 06 15.9896281128 -00 17 29.221733688   15.90 15.50 10.3   ~ 344 0
7 2MASX J02101150-0903357 Sy2 02 10 11.4927559824 -09 03 35.446194936   17.35 16.83     ~ 39 0
8 2MASX J02125762+1406105 Sy1 02 12 57.5912277696 +14 06 10.246134888   17.76 17.18     ~ 28 0
9 NGC 863 Sy1 02 14 33.5604714720 -00 46 00.181845336   14.48 13.81 17.9   ~ 689 0
10 2MASX J02491286-0815254 Sy1 02 49 12.8668114100 -08 15 25.566144720   18.85 18.28     ~ 33 0
11 SDSS J032515.58+003408.3 Sy1 03 25 15.5899702776 +00 34 08.447573964   19.61 19.04     ~ 21 0
12 NGC 1346 Sy1 03 30 13.2634890840 -05 32 35.991525660   17.06 16.39 12.58   ~ 57 1
13 Mrk 1506 Sy1 04 33 11.0956735296 +05 21 15.619461552   15.72 15.05 10.08   ~ 2000 2
14 Mrk 1095 Sy1 05 16 11.4092471904 -00 08 59.157166920   14.30 13.92     ~ 890 1
15 Mrk 79 Sy1 07 42 32.8210670808 +49 48 34.783809768   14.74 14.27     ~ 714 1
16 NVSS J075056+353037 Sy1 07 50 57.2647534632 +35 30 37.689900660   18.71 18.14     ~ 26 0
17 2MASS J08024340+3104033 Sy1 08 02 43.4042090112 +31 04 03.373678956   17.34 16.95     ~ 31 0
18 IC 492 Sy1 08 05 38.6668610808 +26 10 05.447415396   17.83 17.19     ~ 42 0
19 2MASX J08090759+4416413 Sy1 08 09 07.5760478112 +44 16 41.424425256   17.78 17.32     ~ 18 0
20 2MASX J08251024+3759202 Sy1 08 25 10.2248814816 +37 59 19.706096076   18.05 17.39     ~ 28 0
21 2XMMi J082912.8+500652 Sy1 08 29 12.6809834208 +50 06 52.350492744   17.81 17.42     ~ 43 0
22 2MASX J08320213+4614257 Sy1 08 32 02.1570077616 +46 14 25.729913256   17.61 17.02     ~ 32 0
23 2MASX J08394965+4847014 Sy1 08 39 49.6528412976 +48 47 01.457432268   17.16 16.70     ~ 36 0
24 LEDA 1177310 Sy1 08 55 54.2744403360 +00 51 10.987345728   18.07 17.49     ~ 32 0
25 MCG+09-16-013 Sy1 09 24 38.8899909384 +56 07 46.870589100   17.61 16.92     ~ 40 0
26 Mrk 110 Sy1 09 25 12.8479065576 +52 17 10.386311208   16.82 16.41     ~ 604 0
27 2MASX J09325962+0405062 Sy1 09 32 59.6038446336 +04 05 06.019364508   18.14 17.55     ~ 20 0
28 2MASX J09381221+0743398 Sy1 09 38 12.2649651984 +07 43 39.952926048   17.16 16.49     ~ 34 0
29 2MASX J09483841+4030436 Sy1 09 48 38.4270615816 +40 30 43.868269404   17.55 17.03     ~ 35 0
30 2SLAQ J101108.40+002908.7 Sy1 10 11 08.4012991584 +00 29 08.714487876   20.24 19.79     ~ 23 0
31 MGC 4526 Sy1 10 16 27.3295706976 -00 07 14.641823640   19.37 18.85     ~ 27 0
32 Mrk 141 Sy1 10 19 12.5653238136 +63 58 02.626090176   16.32 16.00     ~ 153 0
33 2dFGRS TGN425Z279 Sy1 10 20 44.4302256144 +01 30 48.595462992   18.23 17.62 16.303   ~ 15 0
34 NGC 3227 Sy1 10 23 30.5765149296 +19 51 54.282206700   12.61 11.79     ~ 1703 1
35 2MASS J11064018+0519056 Sy1 11 06 40.2012389112 +05 19 05.643361632   18.47 17.95     ~ 15 0
36 NGC 3516 Sy1 11 06 47.4632200800 +72 34 07.298374656   13.12 12.40     ~ 1544 0
37 Mrk 40 Sy1 11 25 36.1539761184 +54 22 57.113791824   17.06 16.47     ~ 275 0
38 MCG+10-17-004 Sy2 11 28 41.0047291104 +57 50 06.487724400   17.33 16.87     ~ 40 0
39 NGC 3783 Sy1 11 39 01.7096819040 -37 44 19.009642992   12.46 13.43 11.33 12.1 ~ 1647 0
40 NAME G 1200-2038 Sy1 12 02 56.93256 -20 56 02.9580           ~ 161 0
41 IC 756 Sy1 12 02 57.8103067416 +04 50 45.154760496   18.06 17.54     ~ 68 0
42 NGC 4051 Sy1 12 03 09.6101337312 +44 31 52.682601288   11.08 12.92 9.94   ~ 2165 1
43 LEDA 2359832 Sy1 12 05 56.0138867424 +49 59 56.249557332   17.62 17.17     ~ 45 0
44 NGC 4151 Sy1 12 10 32.5759813872 +39 24 21.063527532   12.18 11.48     ~ 3691 2
45 Mrk 1469 Sy1 12 16 07.0972137408 +50 49 30.088685496   17.20 16.62     ~ 75 0
46 Mrk 202 Sy1 12 17 54.9746101392 +58 39 35.609855652   16.82 16.39     ~ 91 0
47 Mrk 50 Sy1 12 23 24.1362367968 +02 40 44.449405212   17.25 16.63     ~ 230 0
48 NGC 4395 Sy2 12 25 48.8633109888 +33 32 48.700168152 10.84 10.54 10.11 9.98   ~ 1177 1
49 2MASX J12323743+6624521 Sy1 12 32 37.4927732136 +66 24 52.237723608   17.29 16.71     ~ 24 0
50 2MASS J12403583-0029194 Sy1 12 40 35.8244285352 -00 29 19.524645384   18.13 17.70     ~ 42 0
51 [GH2004] 11 Sy1 12 50 55.2860720304 -01 55 56.752138020   18.64 18.26     ~ 26 0
52 2MASS J13062096+5318232 LIN 13 06 20.9687514336 +53 18 23.221485000   17.60 16.91     ~ 17 0
53 2dFGRS TGN396Z227 Sy1 13 13 05.8102301184 +01 27 55.986809112   17.89 17.22     ~ 35 0
54 LEDA 2816051 Sy1 13 22 49.2007765584 +54 55 28.261413012   16.63 16.24     ~ 42 0
55 LEDA 1118053 Sy1 13 23 40.3136037360 -01 27 49.192506576   17.94 17.49 16.15   ~ 26 0
56 NGC 5252 Sy2 13 38 15.8707724328 +04 32 33.521265600   15.21 14.21     ~ 480 0
57 Z 17-73 Sy1 13 49 52.8409293768 +02 04 45.151553352   16.75 16.23 15.032   ~ 99 0
58 Mrk 279 Sy1 13 53 03.4348964112 +69 18 29.410910460   15.15 14.46     ~ 761 0
59 Z 46-33 Sy2 14 00 18.4262077464 +05 02 42.218881584   17.00 16.41     ~ 38 0
60 LEDA 126151 Sy1 14 05 14.8687808520 -02 59 01.264466616   18.09 17.51     ~ 26 0
61 2MASX J14163083+0137085 Sy1 14 16 30.8178185400 +01 37 08.028187716   17.84 17.26     ~ 33 0
62 NGC 5548 Sy1 14 17 59.5400291832 +25 08 12.603122268   14.35 13.73     ~ 2709 0
63 Z 47-107 Sy1 14 34 50.6282462496 +03 38 42.520770600   15.84 15.28     ~ 55 0
64 NGC 5683 Sy1 14 34 52.4587723488 +48 39 42.730942860   16.46 16.08     ~ 179 0
65 Mrk 817 Sy1 14 36 22.0820611632 +58 47 39.394934844   14.19 13.79     ~ 523 0
66 2MASX J14462995+5001311 Sy1 14 46 29.9911865712 +50 01 30.744546384   18.00 17.40     ~ 17 0
67 NGC 5804 AGN 14 57 06.786 +49 40 08.60   16.52 15.94     ~ 61 0
68 Mrk 836 Sy1 14 59 01.3509434880 +61 13 53.543653608   17.36 16.78     ~ 30 0
69 Mrk 1392 Sy1 15 05 56.5521472536 +03 42 26.339214780   15.80 15.50     ~ 132 0
70 Mrk 845 Sy1 15 07 45.0042214200 +51 27 10.265406048   17.52 16.93     ~ 89 0
71 Mrk 1393 Sy2 15 08 53.9542751376 -00 11 49.004597040   17.11 16.65     ~ 82 0
72 2MASX J15251516+6014091 Sy2 15 25 15.1899546072 +60 14 09.116543076   17.91 17.34     ~ 23 0
73 2MASX J15541741+3238381 Sy1 15 54 17.4344400480 +32 38 37.811847444   17.07 16.61     ~ 36 0
74 LEDA 2408850 Sy1 16 11 56.3148114816 +52 11 16.868679144   17.43 16.85     ~ 31 0
75 2MASX J16195129+4058472 Sy1 16 19 51.3112866864 +40 58 47.331025212   17.81 17.34     ~ 64 0
76 SDSS J170246.09+602818.8 Sy1 17 02 46.0975058544 +60 28 18.899805144   18.34 17.84     ~ 27 0
77 LEDA 59503 Sy1 17 03 28.9510261992 +61 41 09.940891560   17.18 16.84     ~ 32 0
78 2MASX J17155047+5935486 Sy1 17 15 50.5074930288 +59 35 48.834441384   18.65 18.06 15.31 17.34 ~ 30 0
79 1RXS J172759.7+542146 Sy1 17 27 59.1347250216 +54 21 47.056294548   19.79 19.31     ~ 30 0
80 ICRF J184208.9+794617 Sy1 18 42 08.9904975672 +79 46 17.127835104   16.06 15.38     ~ 1316 0
81 LEDA 1145145 Sy1 21 24 01.8955858728 -00 21 58.659471648   17.71 17.19 15.63   ~ 40 0
82 2MASX J21565830+1103429 Sy1 21 56 58.3124563632 +11 03 43.156281060   17.78 17.22     ~ 13 0
83 HE 2222-0026 Sy1 22 24 35.2931386704 -00 11 03.873799608   17.21 16.88     ~ 32 0
84 2MASS J22300036-0946221 Sy1 22 30 00.3790571688 -09 46 22.077240276   18.49 17.87     ~ 12 0
85 NGC 7469 Sy1 23 03 15.6 +08 52 26 12.60 13.00 12.34     ~ 2095 3
86 [GH2004] 18 Sy1 23 21 59.0575 +00 07 38.849   20.51 19.90     ~ 19 0
87 ICRF J232721.9+152437 Sy2 23 27 21.9664282368 +15 24 37.311384420   16.93 16.28 10.09   ~ 91 1
88 2MASS J23383712-0028103 Sy2 23 38 37.0984744560 -00 28 10.486063776   16.83 16.27     ~ 25 0
89 2MASX J23512879+1552590 Sy1 23 51 28.7770765008 +15 52 59.165588280   18.06 17.51     ~ 23 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2009ApJ...698..812G and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu