2009MNRAS.397...75G


Query : 2009MNRAS.397...75G

2009MNRAS.397...75G - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 397, 75-89 (2009/July-3)

On the origin of the scatter around the fundamental plane: correlations with stellar population parameters.

GARGIULO A., HAINES C.P., MERLUZZI P., SMITH R.J., LA BARBERA F., BUSARELLO G., LUCEY J.R., MERCURIO A. and CAPACCIOLI M.

Abstract (from CDS):

We present a Fundamental Plane (FP) analysis of 141 early-type galaxies in the Shapley supercluster at z = 0.049 based on spectroscopy from the AAOmega spectrograph at the Anglo-Australian Telescope and photometry from the WFI on the European Southern Observatory/MPI 2.2-m telescope. The key feature of the survey is its coverage of low-mass galaxies down to σ ∼ 50km/s. We obtain a best-fitting FP relation re∝ σ1.06±0.060<I>–0.82±0.02e in the R band. The shallow exponent of σ0 is a result of the extension of our sample to low velocity dispersions. Considering the subsample of σ0> 100km/s galaxies, the FP relation is re∝ σ1.35 <I>–0.81e, consistent with previous studies in the high-luminosity regime. We investigate the origin of the intrinsic FP scatter, using estimates of age, metallicity and α/Fe. We find that the FP residuals anticorrelate (>3σ) with the mean stellar age in agreement with previous work. However, a stronger (>4σ) correlation with α/Fe is also found. These correlations indicate that galaxies with effective radii smaller than those predicted by the FP have stellar populations systematically older and with α overabundances larger than average, for their σ. Including α/Fe as a fourth parameter in the FP, the total scatter decreases from 0.088 to 0.075dex and the estimated intrinsic scatter decreases from 0.068 to 0.049dex. Thus, variations in α/Fe account for ∼30 per cent of the total variance around the FP, and ∼50 per cent of the estimated intrinsic variance. This result indicates that the distribution of galaxies around the FP are tightly related to the enrichment, and hence to the time-scale of star formation. Our results appear to be consistent with the merger hypothesis for the formation of ellipticals which predicts that a significant fraction of the scatter is due to variations in the importance of dissipation in forming merger remnants of a given mass.

Abstract Copyright: © 2009 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2009 RAS

Journal keyword(s): galaxies: abundances - galaxies: ellipticals and lenticular, cD - galaxies: formation - galaxies: fundamental parameters - galaxies: structure

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/MNRAS/397/75): table2.dat>

Simbad objects: 146

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 146
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2024
#notes
1 ACO 1656 ClG 12 59 44.40 +27 54 44.9           ~ 4796 2
2 NAME SHAPLEY-CENTAURUS CL SCG 13 06.0 -33 04           ~ 604 0
3 LEDA 3085045 GiC 13 23 48.2770942416 -31 49 53.210639928   19.06   17.24 16.77 ~ 11 0
4 LEDA 97583 GiC 13 23 55.4949580656 -31 38 46.828031244   19.64   17.84 16.97 ~ 10 0
5 ACO 3556 ClG 13 24 06.2 -31 39 38           ~ 150 0
6 2MASX J13240683-3144488 GiC 13 24 06.837 -31 44 48.85   18.26   16.40 15.96 ~ 12 0
7 2MASX J13242652-3151529 GiC 13 24 26.5445201328 -31 51 53.287849224   17.52   15.67 15.19 ~ 15 0
8 2MASX J13251493-3141539 GiC 13 25 14.9581972224 -31 41 53.849087232   18.26   16.45   ~ 10 0
9 LEDA 97798 GiC 13 25 17.1130525536 -31 43 11.535473352   19.04   17.29 16.78 ~ 11 0
10 2MASX J13252644-3146249 GiC 13 25 26.4365469672 -31 46 24.882954060   18.15   16.35 15.67 ~ 10 0
11 2MASX J13255838-3128380 GiC 13 25 58.4163836496 -31 28 37.802013672       16.131   ~ 6 0
12 LEDA 97991 GiC 13 26 30.1288992864 -31 18 27.582236388   19.48   17.57 17.22 ~ 7 0
13 2MASX J13265599-3124468 GiC 13 26 55.9583603952 -31 24 47.196841500   17.31   15.45 15.01 ~ 18 0
14 2MASX J13265599-3125269 GiC 13 26 56.0199749232 -31 25 27.454517724   17.42   15.58 15.17 ~ 20 0
15 2MASX J13265832-3130299 GiC 13 26 58.2750709344 -31 30 30.207819312   18.68   16.92 16.33 ~ 11 0
16 2MASX J13270435-3120079 GiC 13 27 04.3292960160 -31 20 07.963957464   17.56   15.53 15.13 ~ 16 0
17 2MASX J13270747-3119169 GiC 13 27 07.4597656896 -31 19 17.009351616   17.91   16.00 15.54 ~ 8 0
18 LEDA 88846 GiC 13 27 09.2963652648 -31 32 39.477671556   18.98   17.12 16.66 ~ 8 0
19 2MASX J13272698-3141066 GiC 13 27 27.0247344336 -31 41 06.972463428   17.61   15.67 15.35 ~ 15 0
20 LEDA 98203 GiC 13 27 27.0449628936 -31 35 26.127454704   18.86   17.06 16.64 ~ 8 0
21 LEDA 98207 GiC 13 27 28.484 -31 30 51.91   19.84   18.00 17.33 ~ 7 0
22 2MASX J13272961-3123237 GiC 13 27 29.6320274928 -31 23 24.218517660   15.55   13.69 13.30 ~ 39 0
23 NFP J132730.2-312431 GiC 13 27 30.2198466984 -31 24 30.238916544   19.17   17.36 16.79 ~ 5 0
24 2MASX J13273164-3124407 GiC 13 27 31.6525056504 -31 24 41.045394168   17.88   16.05 15.49 ~ 11 0
25 LEDA 98220 GiC 13 27 32.2294087464 -31 21 32.407580016   19.07   17.27 16.73 ~ 7 0
26 2MASX J13273310-3132577 GiC 13 27 33.1141416720 -31 32 57.204263976   18.90   17.09 16.55 ~ 8 0
27 2MASX J13273351-3125267 GiC 13 27 33.5312973408 -31 25 26.549242212   18.02   16.18 15.85 ~ 18 0
28 2MASX J13273509-3115417 GiC 13 27 35.0595922992 -31 15 41.457155112   16.17   14.57 14.08 ~ 22 0
29 LEDA 98239 GiC 13 27 36.796 -31 29 58.36   19.29   17.43 17.88 ~ 9 0
30 2MASX J13273765-3127487 GiC 13 27 37.6222060176 -31 27 48.771783612   17.96   16.11 15.66 ~ 11 0
31 2MASX J13273786-3143107 GiC 13 27 37.8476824248 -31 43 11.274569364   16.96   15.559 15.43 ~ 9 0
32 2MASX J13273803-3130407 GiC 13 27 38.0549847504 -31 30 41.177272068   18.55   16.74 16.29 ~ 9 0
33 2MASX J13273960-3130097 GiC 13 27 39.5798481792 -31 30 09.966305592   18.54   16.71   ~ 6 0
34 LEDA 98249 GiC 13 27 39.8212911576 -31 36 07.168515804   18.76   17.05 16.63 ~ 8 0
35 2MASX J13274001-3056387 GiC 13 27 39.9825074040 -30 56 39.214227876   16.11   14.886 15.11 ~ 12 0
36 TCG ACO 3558 14 GiC 13 27 42.8460743928 -31 30 34.605024084   18.98   17.18 16.71 ~ 7 0
37 LEDA 98263 GiC 13 27 43.1551886472 -31 48 41.053040460   19.66   17.86 17.31 ~ 9 0
38 2MASX J13274374-3141567 GiC 13 27 43.7218409568 -31 41 56.570773668   18.28   16.49 15.98 ~ 8 0
39 2MASX J13274445-3131417 GiC 13 27 44.4427858056 -31 31 41.415352752   17.44   15.60 15.23 ~ 13 0
40 6dFGS gJ132745.5-314751 GiC 13 27 45.4997947872 -31 47 50.720905860   12.19 12.49 13.83 13.53 ~ 32 0
41 2MASX J13274662-3059237 GiC 13 27 46.6013372424 -30 59 23.935876980       15.852   ~ 6 0
42 2MASX J13274663-3127147 GiC 13 27 46.6259436648 -31 27 15.152808060   16.70   14.84 14.49 ~ 24 0
43 LEDA 98279 GiC 13 27 46.947 -31 40 12.36   19.26   17.41 16.98 ~ 7 0
44 2MASX J13274758-3138287 GiC 13 27 47.5487140224 -31 38 29.116134924   18.37   16.56 16.08 ~ 10 0
45 LEDA 98282 G 13 27 47.5702722000 -31 30 57.343559148   18.85   16.95 16.65 ~ 8 0
46 2MASX J13274780-3124507 GiC 13 27 47.8112557872 -31 24 50.379956316   16.98   15.13 14.73 ~ 19 0
47 NAME NFP J132747.9-311360 GiC 13 27 47.8859730744 -31 13 59.820357504   16.27   14.809 14.62 ~ 23 0
48 2MASX J13274851-3128457 GiC 13 27 48.5280832944 -31 28 45.702524424   17.21   15.19 14.81 ~ 24 0
49 LEDA 98293 GiC 13 27 49.2518946552 -31 37 54.495296832   18.86   17.11 16.55 ~ 7 0
50 LEDA 98292 GiC 13 27 49.3630139616 -31 35 11.020370640   18.92   17.03 16.64 ~ 9 0
51 2MASX J13274945-3128007 GiC 13 27 49.4741020080 -31 28 00.890074056   17.82   15.97 15.57 ~ 10 0
52 LEDA 98297 GiC 13 27 50.4647248440 -31 46 24.744126936   18.34   16.834 16.46 ~ 7 1
53 LEDA 98304 GiC 13 27 51.3692920848 -31 32 41.084502108   18.45 17.32 16.65   ~ 9 0
54 ACO 3558 ClG 13 27 54.8 -31 29 32           ~ 442 2
55 LEDA 98382 G 13 28 06.5809304784 -31 41 45.591372348   18.65   16.79 16.47 ~ 9 0
56 LEDA 98381 G 13 28 06.6863617632 -31 45 20.690406252   18.11   16.08 15.78 ~ 9 0
57 2MASX J13281048-3123098 GiC 13 28 10.4892625968 -31 23 09.809031804   16.93   14.95 14.58 ~ 29 0
58 2MASX J13281109-3129158 GiC 13 28 11.0793199392 -31 29 15.786772728   16.83   15.43 14.95 ~ 11 0
59 LEDA 88862 GiC 13 28 11.3432809656 -31 25 46.148008404   18.57   16.62 16.25 ~ 8 0
60 2MASX J13281297-3126248 GiC 13 28 12.9571709472 -31 26 24.597024684   16.84   15.60 15.15 ~ 17 0
61 LEDA 98431 GiC 13 28 17.736 -31 36 18.64   19.07   17.33 16.90 ~ 8 0
62 2MASX J13281860-3131518 GiC 13 28 18.5622503976 -31 31 52.302811044   17.88   15.97 15.43 ~ 9 0
63 LEDA 98439 GiC 13 28 19.9421057136 -31 37 22.952602668   19.55   17.77 17.29 ~ 8 0
64 2MASX J13282331-3145298 GiC 13 28 23.2969756608 -31 45 30.270461148   18.28   16.45 15.92 ~ 10 0
65 2MASX J13282429-3114388 GiC 13 28 24.2844853800 -31 14 38.507369064   17.28   15.50 15.02 ~ 14 0
66 2MASX J13282579-3130188 GiC 13 28 25.8361465416 -31 30 18.756662220   17.95   16.09 15.60 ~ 9 0
67 2MASX J13282642-3127598 GiC 13 28 26.4117554808 -31 28 00.224413500   17.61   15.74 15.28 ~ 11 0
68 2MASX J13282763-3148188 GiC 13 28 27.5962448328 -31 48 18.355236012   17.75   15.79 15.30 ~ 14 0
69 LEDA 88877 GiC 13 28 28.612 -31 32 04.52   17.48   15.65 15.22 ~ 13 0
70 2MASX J13283143-3103077 GiC 13 28 31.4571532608 -31 03 07.821528588   17.38   15.916 15.55 ~ 6 0
71 LEDA 98497 GiC 13 28 34.3062832368 -31 29 00.909462552   18.98   17.11 16.68 ~ 7 0
72 LEDA 47273 GiC 13 28 38.7140451336 -31 20 49.320836412   16.06   14.28 14.15 ~ 37 0
73 2MASX J13284313-3138398 GiC 13 28 43.1101765584 -31 38 40.156897632   16.77   15.35 14.57 ~ 18 0
74 LEDA 98530 GiC 13 28 43.1528598552 -31 30 19.469978568   18.43   16.63   ~ 5 0
75 2MASX J13284434-3114138 GiC 13 28 44.3114299032 -31 14 13.988794848   16.97   15.15 14.75 ~ 15 0
76 2MASX J13284441-3113238 GiC 13 28 44.3756523048 -31 13 24.258842940   16.72   15.33 14.65 ~ 19 0
77 2MASX J13284816-3105318 GiC 13 28 48.1172594664 -31 05 31.927590312   16.77   15.287 15.21 ~ 10 0
78 LEDA 98545 G 13 28 48.3391684584 -31 39 46.934565264   17.61   15.74 15.27 ~ 11 0
79 LEDA 98548 GiC 13 28 48.673 -31 42 05.34   19.50   17.73 17.18 ~ 7 0
80 LEDA 98566 GiC 13 28 51.6187036752 -31 35 25.261302552   19.03   17.25 16.74 ~ 9 0
81 LEDA 98639 GiC 13 29 09.114 -31 43 02.34   19.18   17.35 16.93 ~ 9 0
82 LEDA 98641 GiC 13 29 09.5366998416 -31 32 23.186603184   18.08   16.18 15.68 ~ 6 0
83 2MASX J13291431-3144448 GiC 13 29 14.3062059552 -31 44 45.361175640   17.38   15.45 15.15 ~ 13 0
84 2MASX J13291456-3139108 GiC 13 29 14.5596759696 -31 39 11.161158840   18.27   16.46 16.07 ~ 10 0
85 2MASX J13291470-3149338 GiC 13 29 14.6928469920 -31 49 34.284438120   18.01   16.18 15.78 ~ 10 0
86 6dFGS gJ132917.0-320234 GiC 13 29 16.9927668072 -32 02 33.963073656   16.36   14.46 14.26 ~ 22 0
87 2MASX J13291949-3127148 GiC 13 29 19.4644057896 -31 27 14.487048720   17.90   15.99 15.51 ~ 12 0
88 2MASX J13292012-3116388 GiC 13 29 20.0892778728 -31 16 38.905382316   17.63   15.68 15.26 ~ 10 0
89 2MASX J13292074-3132248 GiC 13 29 20.7518992800 -31 32 24.923762736   16.48   14.45 14.16 ~ 31 0
90 2MASX J13292145-3116178 GiC 13 29 21.4299209664 -31 16 18.145178904   18.33   16.43 15.97 ~ 9 0
91 2MASX J13292270-3142238 GiC 13 29 22.7332540992 -31 42 23.696615844   18.55   16.77 16.35 ~ 9 0
92 2MASX J13292325-3148318 GiC 13 29 23.2611396096 -31 48 32.176789776   18.06   16.16 15.68 ~ 9 0
93 2MASX J13292324-3124008 GiC 13 29 23.2637791560 -31 24 00.943333920   17.25   15.60 14.92 ~ 15 0
94 2MASX J13292341-3139518 GiC 13 29 23.4279635448 -31 39 51.678053856   16.23   14.678 14.69 ~ 21 0
95 LEDA 98696 GiC 13 29 23.813 -31 41 16.31   19.39   17.67 17.42 ~ 9 0
96 2MASX J13292426-3122388 GiC 13 29 24.2809958328 -31 22 39.103874796   16.91   15.04 14.67 ~ 18 0
97 LEDA 98703 GiC 13 29 26.9683158216 -31 37 58.156517064   18.64   16.86 16.42 ~ 9 0
98 LEDA 98705 GiC 13 29 27.7976610528 -31 48 31.755190104   18.69   16.76 16.38 ~ 8 0
99 LEDA 98712 GiC 13 29 29.778 -31 37 33.13   19.54   17.75 17.11 ~ 8 0
100 LEDA 98715 GiC 13 29 30.5993844144 -31 47 17.209308840   18.71   16.87 16.29 ~ 7 0
101 2MASX J13293071-3148027 GiC 13 29 30.7063221000 -31 48 02.956973184   18.12   16.30 15.83 ~ 7 0
102 2MASX J13294834-3115580 GiC 13 29 48.2949002280 -31 15 58.589901468   16.00   14.539 14.57 ~ 21 0
103 2MASX J13295423-3201001 GiC 13 29 54.1770562728 -32 00 59.594875380   17.13   15.32 15.17 ~ 10 0
104 LEDA 98796 G 13 29 56.7749712336 -31 43 27.589793304   17.57   15.900 15.58 ~ 7 0
105 2MASX J13300393-3105411 GiC 13 30 03.9653025960 -31 05 41.303916312   17.28   15.934 15.65 ~ 8 0
106 LEDA 98839 G 13 30 06.9620982600 -31 38 12.929764272   18.09   16.526 16.08 ~ 8 0
107 2MASX J13301272-3207230 GiC 13 30 12.7252742616 -32 07 22.697525028   17.52   16.18 15.71 ~ 8 0
108 2MASX J13302909-3136509 GiC 13 30 29.0759249592 -31 36 51.020721180   15.08   15.920 15.58 ~ 8 0
109 2MASX J13303105-3140089 GiC 13 30 31.0435898520 -31 40 08.500430604   17.94   16.285 15.93 ~ 8 0
110 2MASX J13303417-3116239 GiC 13 30 34.1716743264 -31 16 23.436874308   17.22   15.739 15.54 ~ 8 0
111 2MASX J13303649-3218359 GiC 13 30 36.4906471272 -32 18 36.205194348   16.83   15.40 14.69 ~ 13 0
112 LEDA 98944 G 13 30 40.5338228232 -31 46 10.987441788   14.57   15.574 15.30 ~ 7 0
113 2MASX J13304486-3151269 GiC 13 30 44.8951014864 -31 51 26.485158960   16.36   14.929 14.86 ~ 10 0
114 2MASX J13304755-3202356 GiC 13 30 47.5804138056 -32 02 35.741919048   17.17   15.76 15.06 ~ 12 0
115 2MASX J13305316-3147406 GiC 13 30 53.1880207224 -31 47 40.728165648   17.46   15.983 16.01 ~ 6 0
116 2MASX J13305647-3136386 GiC 13 30 56.4415385928 -31 36 38.660638140   17.58   16.012 15.68 ~ 8 0
117 2MASX J13310195-3143466 GiC 13 31 01.9324967544 -31 43 46.966858932   16.41   15.12 14.63 ~ 18 0
118 2MASX J13310689-3145476 GiC 13 31 06.9149518920 -31 45 47.922302088   17.13   15.821 15.70 ~ 9 0
119 2MASX J13310890-3121146 GiC 13 31 08.9073093672 -31 21 14.386111884       16.469   ~ 5 0
120 2MASX J13313757-3133061 GiC 13 31 37.5768952704 -31 33 05.856456816   16.14   14.97 13.86 ~ 18 0
121 2MASX J13314031-3145471 GiC 13 31 40.3476305424 -31 45 47.135745900   16.85   15.47 14.86 ~ 9 0
122 2MASX J13314773-3125381 GiC 13 31 47.7658526712 -31 25 38.512862904   16.57   15.11 15.01 ~ 11 0
123 NFP J133222.5-314832 GiC 13 32 22.4874391704 -31 48 31.448412252   18.79   17.01   ~ 4 0
124 2MASX J13322887-3136514 GiC 13 32 28.8816189984 -31 36 51.865439364   17.71   15.82 15.34 ~ 12 0
125 LEDA 99279 GiC 13 32 29.9235414576 -31 28 05.926374876   18.92   17.09 16.72 ~ 6 0
126 2MASX J13323061-3129544 GiC 13 32 30.6095888856 -31 29 54.459793716   17.16   15.12 14.70 ~ 9 0
127 2MASX J13323239-3141245 GiC 13 32 32.3670606528 -31 41 24.118158660   18.70   16.91 16.38 ~ 6 0
128 2MASX J13323301-3142145 GiC 13 32 32.9939648256 -31 42 14.845198392   17.78   15.87 15.35 ~ 9 0
129 LEDA 99344 GiC 13 32 54.6508479312 -31 38 09.131319240   19.40   17.65 17.08 ~ 6 0
130 LEDA 99359 GiC 13 33 01.6997998056 -31 37 46.125978096   19.36   17.61 17.11 ~ 6 0
131 LEDA 99374 GiC 13 33 08.4996805320 -31 29 38.521182660   18.45   16.60 16.12 ~ 8 0
132 2MASX J13330955-3136119 GiC 13 33 09.5464691184 -31 36 12.188671632   17.68   15.96 15.34 ~ 15 0
133 2MASX J13331144-3132109 GiC 13 33 11.4201642072 -31 32 11.127904980   18.48   16.64 16.14 ~ 7 0
134 2MASX J13331174-3140089 GiC 13 33 11.7183862128 -31 40 09.303628728   17.11   15.22 14.78 ~ 17 0
135 2MASX J13331894-3149139 GiC 13 33 18.9967810824 -31 49 14.429542260   18.63   16.80 16.31 ~ 7 0
136 LEDA 99408 GiC 13 33 20.8658368704 -31 48 32.803118532   18.82   16.96 16.55 ~ 6 0
137 LEDA 99423 GiC 13 33 26.7329968848 -31 36 54.720424476       17.509   ~ 5 1
138 ACO 3562 ClG 13 33 31.8 -31 40 23           ~ 314 1
139 LEDA 99442 GiC 13 33 32.9377766688 -31 31 18.046170372   19.15   17.20 16.85 ~ 7 0
140 2MASX J13335165-3147552 GiC 13 33 51.6515131512 -31 47 55.112973000   18.23   16.45 15.89 ~ 6 0
141 2MASX J13335659-3140122 GiC 13 33 56.5988687736 -31 40 12.451874556   18.22   16.41 15.93 ~ 7 0
142 LEDA 99552 GiC 13 34 08.1474237360 -31 47 34.558764396   18.82   16.81 16.36 ~ 9 0
143 2MASX J13340952-3142383 GiC 13 34 09.5724517632 -31 42 38.786247720   18.49   16.53 16.13 ~ 7 0
144 2MASX J13343044-3136494 GiC 13 34 30.4768870512 -31 36 49.344765372   17.74   15.81 15.32 ~ 8 0
145 NFP J133434.7-313001 GiC 13 34 34.6638411096 -31 30 00.580034628   19.00   17.26   ~ 3 0
146 2MASX J13345012-3144476 GiC 13 34 50.1246759816 -31 44 47.650403616   16.61   15.31 14.69 ~ 16 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2009MNRAS.397...75G and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu