2014MNRAS.437..316K

The inner radius of the accretion disc around a black hole in the low/hard state can be measured in one of two ways. First, via the extent of broadening of the iron emission line, and secondly, from the luminosity and temperature of the weak soft component seen in this state, assuming it is the disc. We use both of these methods on all the low/hard state spectra taken in timing mode of XMM-Newton's EPIC-pn. We find that the two methods are not consistent with each other, and the difference is not always in a single direction. The two methods are neither model independent, nor are they independent of current calibration issues. We find that the remaining small residuals in the EPIC-pn timing mode response at the ≤ 3 percent level can have a dramatic effect on the fit parameters for the reflected spectrum. There is also a mismatch in cross-calibration with RXTE, which makes it difficult to use simultaneous data to extend the bandpass of the spectral fits. Nonetheless, it is clear from the data that the iron line is noticeably broader and stronger at higher L/LEdd, which is consistent with the truncated disc models. We also show that it is likely that the soft component changes character, from a stable component consistent with a truncated disc at high L/LEdd, to a variable one with much smaller radius at low L/LEdd. This adds to growing evidence for a complex soft component in the low/hard state, possibly resulting from clumps torn from the edge of the truncated disc.