2009A&A...494..591C

Query : 2009A&A...494..591C

2009A&A...494..591C - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 494, 591-610 (2009/2-1)

Abundances in the Galactic bulge: results from planetary nebulae and giant stars.

CHIAPPINI C., GORNY S.K., STASINSKA G. and BARBUY B.

Abstract (from CDS):

Our understanding of the chemical evolution (CE) of the Galactic bulge requires the determination of abundances in large samples of giant stars and planetary nebulae (PNe). Studies based on high resolution spectroscopy of giant stars in several fields of the Galactic bulge obtained with very large telescopes have allowed important progress. We discuss PNe abundances in the Galactic bulge and compare these results with those presented in the literature for giant stars. We present the largest, high-quality data-set available for PNe in the direction of the Galactic bulge (inner-disk/bulge). For comparison purposes, we also consider a sample of PNe in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC). We derive the element abundances in a consistent way for all the PNe studied. By comparing the abundances for the bulge, inner-disk, and LMC, we identify elements that have not been modified during the evolution of the PN progenitor and can be used to trace the bulge chemical enrichment history. We then compare the PN abundances with abundances of bulge field giant. At the metallicity of the bulge, we find that the abundances of O and Ne are close to the values for the interstellar medium at the time of the PN progenitor formation, and hence these elements can be used as tracers of the bulge CE, in the same way as S and Ar, which are not expected to be affected by nucleosynthetic processes during the evolution of the PN progenitors. The PN oxygen abundance distribution is shifted to lower values by 0.3 dex with respect to the distribution given by giants. A similar shift appears to occur for Ne and S. We discuss possible reasons for this PNe-giant discrepancy and conclude that this is probably due to systematic errors in the abundance derivations in either giants or PNe (or both). We issue an important warning concerning the use of absolute abundances in CE studies.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): stars: abundances - ISM: planetary nebulae: general - Galaxy: bulge - Galaxy: abundances

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/494/591): table1a.dat table1a.txt table1b.dat table1b.txt table1c.dat table1c.txt>

Simbad objects: 253

Full paper

View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 253

N	Identifier	Otype	ICRS (J2000) RA	ICRS (J2000) DEC	Mag U	Mag B	Mag V	Mag R	Mag I	Sp type	#ref 1850 - 2023	#notes
1	M 31	G	00 42 44.330	+41 16 07.50	4.86	4.36	3.44			~	12157	1
2	NAME SMC	G	00 52 38.0	-72 48 01		2.79	2.2			~	10592	1
3	LMC-MA 6	*	04 45 19.8	-67 34 36		20.784	20.282			~	9	0
4	LHA 120-N 99	BLL	05 06 26.7	-64 38 19						~	14	1
5	NAME LMC	G	05 23 34.6	-69 45 22			0.4			~	16619	1
6	IRAS 05551-6528	El*	05 55 13.6808450040	-65 28 23.221220232	18.011	18.795	18.100		17.921	~	17	0
7	[M94b] 42	PN	05 55 14.6283240216	-66 50 25.083149532	18.64	20.54	19.19		20.132	~	9	0
8	LMC-MA 16	*	05 58 45.8	-64 30 46						~	8	0
9	LMC-MA 10	*	06 09 16.7	-68 43 54						~	7	0
10	LMC-MA 12	*	06 10 08.9	-67 10 18		19.100			16.909	~	7	0
11	LMC-MA 15	*	06 13 40.6	-64 00 46						~	8	0
12	2MASS J06210470-6608008	PN	06 21 04.7093063976	-66 08 00.726299376						~	15	0
13	* mu. Leo	PM*	09 52 45.8165435	+26 00 25.031882	6.50	5.10	3.88	2.97	2.39	K2IIIbCN1Ca1	435	0
14	* alf Boo	RG*	14 15 39.67207	+19 10 56.6730	2.46	1.18	-0.05	-1.03	-1.68	K1.5IIIFe-0.5	2266	0
15	PN SB 25	PN	16 13 38.337	-37 59 58.47						~	10	0
16	Hen 2-178	PN	16 42 33.4932941808	-38 54 40.139817336		15.48	13.95	14.23		~	43	0
17	PN H 1-2	PN	16 48 54.1065182208	-35 47 08.952429948		11.5	13.60			[WC11]	63	0
18	PN H 1-5	PN	16 57 23.7543947808	-41 37 58.216237068			15.00			~	42	0
19	PN M 2-4	PN	17 01 06.2230175160	-34 49 38.610796908			14.40			~	75	0
20	PN M 1-19	PN	17 03 46.8491993472	-33 29 44.433527316		15.02	13.87	14.87	14.16	[WC]	68	0
21	PN M 2-6	PN	17 04 18.32832	-30 53 28.8816				15.650		~	75	0
22	ESO 332-18	PN	17 04 33.7942050162	-37 53 14.835292192						~	35	0
23	PN H 2-1	PN	17 04 36.2535135873	-33 59 18.777826386			13.25			O	141	0
24	PN M 2-7	PN	17 05 13.91	-30 32 19.7			15.50			O	53	0
25	PN M 2-8	PN	17 05 30.70	-32 32 08.1			14.50			[WC2/3]	60	0
26	PN H 1-7	PN	17 10 27.3823210128	-41 52 49.392533604		15.028	13.421	14.078		~	48	0
27	NGC 6309	PN	17 14 04.3074600360	-12 54 37.893271860		11.6				O(He)	306	1
28	PN M 2-10	PN	17 14 07.0266004296	-31 19 42.983628132			15.00			~	80	0
29	PN H 1-8	PN	17 14 42.93	-33 24 47.4			13.6			~	57	0
30	PN Th 3-4	PN	17 18 51.9379704912	-31 39 06.630913620						~	38	0
31	PN M 3-37	PN	17 19 13.386	-25 17 17.55						~	37	0
32	PN M 2-11	PN	17 20 33.27	-29 00 39.1			14.00			~	78	0
33	PN G341.7-06.0	PN	17 21 02.912	-47 35 27.30						~	10	0
34	PN M 3-38	PN	17 21 04.4699050536	-29 02 59.700223716			16.00			~	88	0
35	PN H 1-11	PN	17 21 17.7263264688	-22 18 35.517598344						~	69	0
36	PN H 1-9	PN	17 21 31.9113826563	-30 20 48.608058709		16.034	14.636	14.808		~	76	0
37	PN G342.3-06.0	PN	17 22 52.690	-47 02 48.68						~	10	0
38	PN M 2-12	PN	17 24 01.4751224640	-25 59 23.283283848		13.5	12.5			[WC11]	61	0
39	PN M 3-7	PN	17 24 34.4529856560	-29 24 19.796240052			14.60			[WC]	87	0
40	PN M 3-8	PN	17 24 52.15	-28 05 54.6			15.40			~	83	0
41	PN Th 3-13	PN	17 25 19.3690159560	-30 40 42.079625832						[WC5/6]	52	0
42	PN M 3-41	PN	17 25 59.82	-29 21 50.4			15.40			~	66	0
43	PN M 3-42	PN	17 26 59.85	-29 15 32.1			16.99	14.45		~	54	0
44	PN SaWe 2	PN	17 27 00.197	-27 40 35.11						~	33	0
45	PN G343.9-05.8	PN	17 27 02.2665247236	-45 32 38.831962929						~	14	0
46	PN Th 3-15	PN	17 27 10.6020826176	-27 43 58.817283348						~	33	0
47	PN M 3-10	PN	17 27 20.19	-28 27 51.2			14.40			~	92	0
48	PN H 2-10	PN	17 27 32.86	-28 31 06.9			16.10			~	55	0
49	PN H 1-14	PN	17 28 01.7515982952	-24 25 23.316231684			15.50			~	45	0
50	PN H 1-13	PN	17 28 27.5798073216	-35 07 31.602231048			14			~	60	0
51	PN M 2-13	PN	17 28 34.1923703839	-13 26 20.742891193						~	62	0
52	PN H 1-15	PN	17 28 37.6286372256	-24 51 07.218909000			15.10			~	57	0
53	PN M 4-4	PN	17 28 50.2977512256	-30 07 44.997790224						~	42	0
54	PN M 1-20	PN	17 28 57.6165015264	-19 15 54.033719256						~	124	0
55	PN H 1-16	PN	17 29 23.4288306495	-26 26 05.773990642		16.9	15.63	14.25	15.37	~	52	1
56	PN H 2-11	PN	17 29 25.9611478512	-25 49 07.205229768						~	61	0
57	PN H 1-17	PN	17 29 40.5936293856	-28 40 22.333706616			15.70			~	65	0
58	PN K 5-1	PN	17 29 52.3627254360	-26 11 13.611944904						~	26	1
59	PN H 1-19	PN	17 30 02.57	-27 59 17.5			16.30			~	70	0
60	PN K 5-3	PN	17 30 41.198	-23 45 00.40						[WC4]	24	0
61	PN H 1-20	PN	17 30 43.8092470056	-28 04 06.841201728		17.1	16.0			~	80	0
62	WRAY 16-286	PN	17 33 00.67	-36 43 51.8			15.40			~	43	0
63	PN M 4-5	PN	17 34 54.72	-26 35 57.3			17.50			~	66	0
64	PN M 4-6	PN	17 35 13.99	-29 03 10.6						~	60	0
65	PN G001.5+03.6	PN	17 35 22.074	-25 42 46.48						~	17	0
66	PN G353.8-01.2	PN	17 35 27.36	-34 47 41.5						~	13	0
67	PN K 5-6	PN	17 35 31.28	-23 11 48.8						~	19	0
68	PN Th 3-27	PN	17 35 58.467	-24 25 29.15						~	40	0
69	PN H 1-26	PN	17 36 29.8983692976	-39 21 56.702843496			14.40			[WC4/5]	42	0
70	PN G003.1+04.1	PN	17 37 20.167	-24 03 27.84						~	14	0
71	PN Th 3-34	PN	17 37 44.8898984040	-32 15 29.883143844						~	20	0
72	PN M 1-25	PN	17 38 30.3160501176	-22 08 38.934269052		17.9				[WC6]	143	0
73	PN G354.6-01.7	PN	17 38 54.316	-34 27 39.30						~	10	0
74	PN SaSt 2-15	PN	17 38 57.3713723952	-18 17 35.788016724		13.93	13.66	13.82		~	72	0
75	IRAS 17364-4222	PN	17 40 03.3768674658	-42 24 05.890959107						~	13	0
76	PN H 1-27	PN	17 40 17.9448389544	-22 19 18.212179332						~	66	0
77	PN RPZM 30	PN	17 40 30.5	-33 29 57						~	12	0
78	PN M 2-14	PN	17 41 57.2678295912	-24 11 16.203074712			14.70	15.71	14.50	~	62	0
79	PN G002.3+02.2	PN	17 42 30.10	-25 45 28.7				14.50	16.68	~	20	1
80	PN G353.5-03.3	PN?	17 42 50.65	-36 13 35.2						~	10	0
81	PN H 2-18	PN	17 43 18.3532870822	-21 09 03.245216375						~	74	0
82	Terz N 1580	PN	17 43 39.442	-25 36 42.51						~	25	0
83	PN H 1-29	WV*	17 44 13.8729577601	-34 17 32.824856894			14.90	16.04	14.90	[WC4/6]	68	0
84	PN M 3-14	PN	17 44 20.62	-34 06 40.6			14.90			~	83	0
85	PN PBOZ 11	PN	17 44 32.586	-24 13 28.12						~	18	0
86	PN H 1-30	PN	17 45 06.80	-38 08 49.7			15.70			~	38	0
87	Terz N 1567	PN	17 45 28.311	-25 38 10.41						~	20	0
88	PN M 3-15	PN	17 45 31.7096699160	-20 58 01.493896440						[WC4/6]	124	1
89	PN H 1-31	PN	17 45 31.9673698920	-34 33 54.807699996			14.50			~	65	0
90	PN Pe 1-9	PN	17 45 36.7571084976	-23 02 26.318855004			19.166		17.815	O(H)	46	0
91	NAME Galactic Center	reg	17 45 39.60213	-29 00 22.0000						~	13539	0
92	PN H 1-32	PN	17 46 06.32760	-34 03 46.3356						~	62	0
93	PN Th 4-2	PN	17 46 09.813	-18 39 30.89						~	30	0
94	PN M 1-27	WR?	17 46 45.4755803568	-33 08 35.133711936			13.90			[WC11]?	99	0
95	PN M 2-15	PN	17 46 54.449	-16 17 24.80						~	60	0
96	NAME Sgr B2	MoC	17 47 20.4	-28 23 07						~	2161	1
97	PN PBOZ 16	PN	17 47 31.930	-24 13 07.05						~	15	0
98	PN H 2-22	PN	17 47 33.926	-21 47 23.11						~	28	0
99	IRAS 17445-2412	mul	17 47 34.6	-24 13 23						~	12	0
100	PN G004.2+02.0 a	PN	17 47 38.0	-24 14 27						~	3	1
101	PN M 1-28	PN	17 47 38.3	-22 06 20		18.9				~	58	0
102	PN H 1-33	PN	17 47 49.4162559989	-34 08 05.126681277			15.30			~	61	1
103	PN SB 37	PN	17 47 52.679	-37 48 03.10						~	14	0
104	PN H 1-34	PN	17 48 07.572	-22 46 47.33						~	41	0
105	NGC 6439	PN	17 48 19.820	-16 28 44.42			12.2			~	173	0
106	PN Th 4-3	PN	17 48 37.390	-22 16 48.79						~	33	0
107	PN H 2-23	PN	17 48 57.91	-34 21 54.3			15.40			~	38	0
108	PN H 2-25	PN	17 49 00.481	-23 42 54.59						~	60	0
109	PN H 1-35	PN	17 49 13.9398459192	-34 22 52.812575256			12.90			wels?	111	0
110	Hen 2-289	Sy*	17 49 48.2107694784	-37 01 27.797630520				13.828		M4/5:e	160	0
111	PN G005.1+02.0	PN	17 49 51.282	-23 27 44.27						~	17	0
112	PN G356.8-03.0	PN	17 50 10.734	-33 14 17.97						~	17	0
113	PN M 1-29	PN	17 50 17.9658145641	-30 34 54.987881214			14.00			~	88	1
114	PN G351.2-06.3	PN	17 50 27.700	-39 40 17.40						~	11	0
115	PN Th 4-5	PN	17 50 28.377	-19 03 10.01						~	46	0
116	PN Th 4-6	PN	17 50 57.24	-18 46 48.4						~	32	0
117	PN Hf 2-1	PN	17 51 12.149	-34 55 24.31						~	68	0
118	PN M 3-44	PN	17 51 18.9230505792	-30 23 53.176813980			16.50			[WC11]	78	0
119	PN M 4-7	PN	17 51 44.663	-31 36 00.18						~	42	0
120	PN Al 2-O	PN	17 51 45.291	-32 03 03.90			16.40		14.59	~	32	1
121	PN G358.6-02.4	PN	17 52 00.342	-31 17 49.92						~	18	0
122	PN M 2-17	PN	17 52 04.896	-17 36 05.23						~	48	0
123	PN M 3-45	PN	17 52 05.96	-30 05 14.0			15.60			~	54	0
124	PN SB 34	PN	17 52 09.4188804912	-39 32 14.865843840						[WC2]	16	0
125	PN Th 4-7	PN	17 52 22.569	-21 51 13.43			15.46	14.01		~	37	0
126	PN M 2-16	PN	17 52 34.37	-32 45 51.4			14.80			~	71	0
127	PN M 1-31	PN	17 52 41.4448424016	-22 21 57.159303984						[WC]	100	0
128	PN M 3-16	PN	17 52 46.0471623240	-30 49 35.021065800			17.007		16.122	O(H)4-6III-V	70	0
129	PN M 1-30	PN	17 52 58.95	-34 38 22.6		16.6	16.4			~	102	0
130	PN G351.7-06.6	PN	17 53 02.87	-39 24 08.9						~	15	0
131	PN H 2-29	PN	17 53 16.8231690912	-32 40 38.501200020			19.313		18.308	O(H)	54	0
132	PN H 1-39	PN	17 53 21.0206431968	-33 55 58.445317128			15.20			[WC11]?	62	0
133	PN M 2-18	PN	17 53 37.85	-32 58 47.8			14.90			~	60	0
134	PN M 2-19	PN	17 53 45.6485317560	-29 43 46.975373868			16.976		15.973	O(H)6-8III-V	86	0
135	PN M 2-20	PN	17 54 25.32	-29 36 08.2			16.1			[WC5/6]	72	0
136	PN Cn 2-1	PN	17 54 33.010	-34 22 21.15			12.70	14.47	13.70	~	133	0
137	PN M 3-46	PN	17 55 05.65	-31 12 16.4			18.00			~	39	0
138	IC 4670	PN	17 55 07.031	-21 44 40.04		15.03	13.28	13.88	13.56	~	144	2
139	PN Bl 3-10	PN	17 55 20.537	-29 57 36.13						~	35	1
140	PN H 1-40	PN	17 55 36.0545698680	-30 33 32.359297176			15.50			~	96	0
141	PN Bl 3-13	PN	17 56 02.7875230032	-29 11 16.552199904			16.00			~	59	0
142	PN M 3-17	PN	17 56 25.65	-31 04 17.2			16.50			[WC11]?	60	0
143	PN Th 4-10	PN	17 57 06.599	-18 06 43.43						~	39	0
144	PN H 1-41	PN	17 57 19.1084978568	-34 09 48.784614372						[WC]	86	0
145	PN H 1-42	PN	17 57 25.1720091886	-33 35 43.132190632			12.80			~	75	0
146	PN M 2-21	PN	17 58 09.58	-29 44 20.1						~	82	0
147	PN H 2-33	PN	17 58 12.5489490240	-31 08 06.374622696			17.00			~	47	0
148	PN H 1-43	PN	17 58 14.4398681232	-33 47 37.621641912			15.10			[WC11]	76	0
149	PN M 3-19	PN	17 58 19.36	-30 00 39.3			15.50			~	62	0
150	PN Pe 2-11	PN	17 58 31.27	-27 37 05.8						~	44	0
151	PN M 2-22	PN	17 58 32.58	-33 28 36.8			15.50			~	67	0
152	PN H 1-46	PN	17 59 02.5031407080	-32 21 43.494698556			14.30			~	75	0
153	PN KFL 1	PN	17 59 15.585	-30 02 47.15						~	26	0
154	PN M 3-20	PN	17 59 19.35	-28 13 48.2			14.80			Of	78	0
155	PN G349.7-09.1	PN	17 59 26.9	-42 24 52						~	11	0
156	PN M 3-48	PN	17 59 56.83	-31 54 28.1			16.50			~	47	0
157	PN H 1-47	PN	18 00 37.6202014872	-29 21 50.638625244			15.60			[WC11]?	74	0
158	PN KFL 2	PN	18 00 59.9261534928	-28 16 19.725938760						~	26	0
159	PN Pe 2-12	PN	18 01 10.2665329896	-27 38 19.740417900			14.60			~	56	0
160	PN M 2-23	PN	18 01 42.6413050824	-28 25 44.117293404			13.00			~	116	0
161	PN M 2-24	PN	18 02 02.8945854456	-34 27 47.275175592		15.62	14.60	15.29		~	95	0
162	PN M 3-22	PN	18 02 19.238	-30 14 25.38						~	62	0
163	PN M 3-21	PN	18 02 32.33	-36 39 11.3			12.20			~	105	1
164	PN M 2-25	PN	18 02 46.50	-32 09 29.0			16.50			~	35	0
165	PN KFL 4	PN	18 02 51.67	-27 40 59.6						~	27	0
166	PN KFL 3	PN	18 02 52.931	-31 23 58.49						~	20	0
167	PN M 2-26	PN	18 03 11.92	-26 58 31.2			16.00			~	60	1
168	IC 4673	PN	18 03 18.4585925304	-27 06 22.715564832			13.50			O(H)8	112	0
169	PN G358.7-05.1	PN	18 03 28.532	-32 37 26.46						~	12	0
170	PN SB 38	PN	18 03 29.0292760824	-39 21 26.876251836						~	14	0
171	NAME Baade Window	reg	18 03.5	-30 01						~	588	3
172	PN M 1-35	PN	18 03 39.30	-26 43 33.9			14.50			~	91	0
173	PN M 2-27	PN	18 03 52.5718384152	-31 17 47.161796424			14.40			[WC4]:	100	0
174	PN H 1-50	PN	18 03 53.5082954976	-32 41 42.015068628		10	12.80			~	78	0
175	PN H 2-36	PN	18 04 07.76	-31 39 11.4			17.00			~	30	0
176	PN H 2-37	PN	18 04 28.874	-28 37 34.55						~	51	0
177	PN H 1-51	PN	18 04 29.30	-34 58 01.0			16.00			~	33	0
178	PN M 2-28	PN	18 05 02.73	-30 58 18.0			15.50			~	50	0
179	PN M 1-37	PN	18 05 25.8092901000	-28 22 04.282489956			14.70			[WC11]?	124	0
180	PN SB 42	PN	18 05 52.556	-36 45 37.40						~	13	0
181	PN M 1-38	PN	18 06 05.74	-28 40 30.0			13.90			~	98	0
182	PN G357.3-06.5	PN	18 06 08.301	-34 33 30.72						~	12	0
183	PN KFL 7	PN	18 06 49.957	-27 06 16.09						~	24	0
184	PN M 3-23	PN	18 07 06.16	-30 34 17.8			14.50			~	57	0
185	PN H 1-54	PN	18 07 07.2793260936	-29 13 05.972785284			13.90			~	99	0
186	PN G356.0-07.4 A	PN	18 07 07.953	-36 02 45.64						~	10	0
187	PN H 1-55	PN	18 07 14.5591261848	-29 41 24.652100940			16.30			~	74	0
188	PN M 1-39	PN	18 07 30.7	-13 28 49						~	60	1
189	PN H 1-56	PN	18 07 53.8842030888	-29 44 34.338810768			15.00			O?	80	0
190	PN M 3-24	PN	18 07 53.92	-25 24 02.7			15.00			~	39	0
191	PN KFL 10	PN	18 08 01.312	-26 54 01.52						~	20	0
192	PN H 2-39	PN	18 08 05.759	-28 26 10.50						~	41	0
193	PN M 1-40	PN	18 08 25.989	-22 16 52.93		11				~	114	1
194	PN SB 2	PN	18 08 34.7	-31 06 52						~	13	0
195	PN MaC 1-10	PN	18 09 12.4110798682	-25 04 34.426975990						[WC8]	46	0
196	PN KFL 11	PN	18 10 12.244	-27 16 35.00						~	29	0
197	PN G018.9+04.1	PN	18 10 26.48	-10 29 03.1						~	27	0
198	PN KFL 12	PN	18 10 30.807	-28 19 22.91						~	30	0
199	PN M 1-42	PN	18 11 04.99	-28 58 59.1		13.1	14.00			~	204	0
200	PN H 1-59	PN	18 11 29.263	-27 46 15.69		14.5				~	65	0
201	EM* AS 283	PN	18 11 35.1005488652	-28 22 36.727284875		11	13.70			B0I-III	76	0
202	PN SB 52	PN	18 11 39.900	-34 00 21.99						~	14	0
203	NGC 6565	PN	18 11 52.4858232888	-28 10 42.421241244		12.5	12.2	12.12		PN	224	0
204	PN M 4-8	PN	18 12 09.6056166096	-10 42 58.355591004						~	39	0
205	PN H 2-41	PN	18 12 23.765	-27 52 13.86						~	54	0
206	PN H 1-60	PN	18 12 25.22	-27 29 12.8						[WC]	68	0
207	PN H 1-61	PN	18 12 33.99	-24 50 00.5			16.90			~	46	0
208	PN M 2-30	PN	18 12 34.40	-27 58 10.5		13.5	14.00			~	103	0
209	PN KFL 13	PN	18 12 45.0792799800	-25 44 24.346432464						~	22	0
210	PN M 2-31	PN	18 13 16.0521431976	-25 30 05.320920636		13.3	13.60			[WC4/6]	98	0
211	NGC 6567	PN	18 13 45.1636643352	-19 04 34.071637152			10.9			[WC5/6]	268	1
212	PN SB 4	PN	18 14 14.183	-31 11 09.11						~	13	0
213	PN KFL 15	PN	18 14 19.324	-25 20 51.22						~	23	0
214	PN H 2-45	PN	18 14 28.844	-24 43 38.35						~	33	1
215	PN M 2-33	PN	18 15 06.5634327720	-30 15 33.265211580				14.61	14.03	O5f(H)	102	0
216	PN M 3-25	PN	18 15 16.967	-10 10 09.47						~	51	0
217	PN M 3-26	PN	18 16 11.44	-27 14 58.3			15.00			~	63	0
218	PN H 1-63	PN	18 16 19.3441096560	-30 07 36.067926540				14.232		O?	126	1
219	PN KFL 16	PN	18 16 53.9673785280	-26 23 24.102164832		13.9	14.1			~	20	0
220	PN M 2-34	PN	18 17 15.90	-23 58 53.7			15.00			[WC]	51	0
221	PN Pe 1-12	PN	18 17 42.379	-28 17 13.80						~	43	0
222	PN Pe 2-13	PN	18 18 13.4070276792	-25 38 10.340502684						~	41	0
223	PN H 1-64	PN	18 18 23.8355125416	-23 24 57.483122004			17.30			~	35	0
224	IC 4699	PN	18 18 32.0450169624	-45 59 01.735217988		13.83	12.71	15.51	15.09	O3V((f))	97	0
225	PN G000.1-08.0	PN	18 18 48.798	-32 47 58.03						~	10	0
226	PN M 2-38	PN	18 19 25.19	-26 35 20.2			15.50			~	55	0
227	PN SB 55	PN	18 19 26.331	-33 37 04.86						~	16	0
228	PN H 1-65	PN	18 20 08.8466492016	-24 15 05.268485484		12	14.30			[WC11]	81	0
229	PN M 2-39	PN	18 22 01.1620945464	-24 10 39.916889760			15.00			wels	74	0
230	PN M 2-42	PN	18 22 32.08	-24 09 27.7			13.90			~	76	0
231	NGC 6620	PN	18 22 54.182	-26 49 17.19		12.8	13.30	14.34	14.55	~	137	0
232	PN KFL 19	PN	18 23 08.890	-29 43 25.17			16.3			~	21	0
233	PN H 1-67	PN	18 25 04.976	-22 34 52.64						[WC2/3]	60	0
234	PN Vy 2-1	PN	18 27 59.6260402536	-26 06 48.065269284		12.8	13.20			[WC]	84	0
235	PN Cn 1-5	PN	18 29 11.6500996872	-31 29 59.135208396		15.5	15.2	13.34		[WC5/6]	147	0
236	PN M 1-48	PN	18 29 30.0553819752	-19 05 43.953710820						~	53	1
237	PN SB 15	PN	18 31 14.65	-23 58 05.1						~	15	0
238	NGC 6644	PN	18 32 34.70280	-25 07 44.1588						~	190	0
239	PN M 3-54	PN	18 33 03.745	-13 44 19.95						~	35	0
240	PN Pe 1-13	PN	18 34 51.57	-22 43 18.4						~	44	0
241	PN G011.4-07.3	PN	18 38 43.0449936192	-22 24 14.473249596						~	11	0
242	PN M 3-29	PN	18 39 25.8182649336	-30 40 37.222765752		13.0	14.10			~	77	0
243	PN SB 19	PN	18 39 40.2	-19 14 08						~	20	0
244	V* V348 Sgr	pA*	18 40 19.9290428808	-22 54 29.308207716		12.1				B0/1?I?e	179	0
245	PN M 3-32	PN	18 44 43.03	-25 21 34.8						~	68	0
246	PN M 1-61	PN	18 45 55.12	-14 27 37.9						~	105	0
247	PN H 2-48	PN	18 46 35.1182447568	-23 26 48.261468804			13			OIII-V	86	0
248	PN SB 21	PN	18 48 10.964	-18 29 38.00						~	16	1
249	PN M 3-33	PN	18 48 12.1403633760	-25 28 52.423742352			13.20			~	78	0
250	PN SB 20	PN	18 49 24.3	-19 52 16						O(H)3-4	15	1
251	PN Y-C 2-32	PN	18 55 30.6705727224	-21 49 39.811373832						~	34	0
252	PN Hb 7	PN	18 55 37.8037363176	-32 15 48.553611372		12.58	11.65	13.61		O3	92	0
253	NAME Galactic Bulge	reg	~	~						~	4045	0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2009A&A...494..591C and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu