CDS

2009A&A...505..139C

Query : 2009A&A...505..139C

2009A&A...505..139C - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 505, 139-155 (2009/10-1)

Na-O anticorrelation and HB. VIII. Proton-capture elements and metallicities in 17 globular clusters from UVES spectra.

CARRETTA E., BRAGAGLIA A., GRATTON R. and LUCATELLO S.

Abstract (from CDS):

We present homogeneous abundance determinations for iron and some of the elements involved in the proton-capture reactions (O, Na, Mg, Al, and Si) for 202 red giants in 17 Galactic globular clusters (GCs) from the analysis of high-resolution UVES spectra obtained with the FLAMES facility at the ESO VLT2 telescope. Our programme clusters span almost the whole range of the metallicity distribution of GCs and were selected to sample the widest range of global parameters (horizontal-branch morphology, masses, concentration, etc.). In this paper we focus on the discussion of the Na-O and Mg-Al anticorrelations and related issues. Our study finds clear Na and O star-to-star abundance variations, exceeding those expected from the error in the analysis, in all clusters. Variations in Al are present in all but a few GCs. Finally, a spread in abundances of Mg and Si are also present in a few clusters. Mg is slightly less overabundant and Si slightly more overabundant in the most Al-rich stars. The correlation between Si and Al abundances is a signature of production of 28Si leaking from the Mg-Al cycle in a few clusters. The cross sections required for the proper reactions to take over in the cycle point to temperatures in excess of about 65 million K for the favoured site of production. We used a dilution model to infer the total range of Al abundances starting from the Na and Al abundances in the FLAMES-UVES spectra, and the Na abundance distributions found from analysis of the much larger set of stars for which FLAMES-GIRAFFE spectra were available. We found that the maximum amount of additional Al produced by first-generation polluters contributing to the composition of the second-generation stars in each cluster is closely correlated with the same combination of metallicity and cluster luminosity that reproduced the minimum O-abundances found from GIRAFFE spectra. We then suggest that the high temperatures required for the Mg-Al cycle are only reached in the most massive and most metal-poor polluters.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): stars: abundances - stars: atmospheres - stars: population II - Galaxy: globular clusters: general

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/505/139): table1.dat table3.dat table4.dat table6.dat table8.dat table9.dat>

Nomenclature: Tables 3-4, 9: [CBG2009] NGC NNNN NNNNNNN N=202.

Simbad objects: 225

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 225
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA 		ICRS (J2000)
DEC 		Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2023 		#notes
1 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 2712 RG* 00 22 31.9796476560 -72 06 48.998634336       12.700 11.57 ~ 24 0
2 Cl* NGC 104 TUC 1080 RG* 00 23 20.9773115952 -72 05 18.258221004   14.063 12.801   11.518 ~ 14 0
3 Cl* NGC 104 TUC 1172 RG* 00 23 29.2820780688 -72 04 48.274730184   13.920 12.644     ~ 13 0
4 Cl* NGC 104 TUC 1445 RG* 00 23 55.0186806360 -72 08 23.772071364   13.732 12.433     ~ 12 0
5 [CBG2009] NGC 104 23821 RG* 00 24 01.5683150016 -72 04 59.497910904   14.017 12.832   11.536 ~ 9 0
6 NGC 104 GlC 00 24 05.359 -72 04 53.20     4.09     ~ 3839 0
7 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 8707 RG* 00 24 16.8787747776 -72 11 49.576597800   13.654 12.272     ~ 15 0
8 Cl* NGC 104 TUC 1646 RG* 00 24 17.6160561072 -71 59 30.937462440   13.852 12.585     ~ 14 0
9 Cl* NGC 104 TUC 1789 RG* 00 24 31.4002874304 -72 01 25.301918568       12.382   ~ 14 0
10 2MASS J00250425-7206400 RG* 00 25 04.2758071248 -72 06 39.913693668   13.697 12.252     ~ 9 0
11 Cl* NGC 104 TUC 2222 RG* 00 25 11.5034376840 -72 02 01.548284424   13.781 12.463     ~ 11 0
12 Cl* NGC 104 TUC 2239 RG* 00 25 13.2908733432 -72 07 50.478742236   13.813 12.553     ~ 17 0
13 Cl* NGC 288 ALC 231 RG* 00 52 38.9116074312 -26 35 31.651499580   13.669 14.880   12.479 ~ 8 0
14 2MASS J00524045-2634561 RG* 00 52 40.4616063864 -26 34 56.067997908   14.882 15.870 14.837 13.859 ~ 4 0
15 2MASS J00524054-2638162 RG* 00 52 40.5576652344 -26 38 16.201430808   15.782 14.822     ~ 6 0
16 Cl* NGC 288 ALC 213 RG* 00 52 43.3029782712 -26 36 57.091286484   14.429 12.910     ~ 35 0
17 NGC 288 GlC 00 52 45.24 -26 34 57.4   10 8.13     ~ 1025 0
18 2MASS J00524624-2637260 RG* 00 52 46.2599330400 -26 37 25.927623624   14.400 12.609     ~ 28 0
19 Cl* NGC 288 ALC 297 RG* 00 52 46.2686827392 -26 35 49.330804308   14.774 13.509     ~ 14 0
20 2MASS J00525401-2634411 RG* 00 52 54.0187805808 -26 34 41.021337720   14.474 15.491   13.393 ~ 3 0
21 UCAC4 318-001170 RG* 00 52 56.9308933848 -26 34 51.064273056   15.056 13.995 13.885   ~ 8 0
22 UCAC4 318-001175 RG* 00 52 58.4924381136 -26 30 55.520258508   15.871 14.938 14.807   ~ 10 0
23 UCAC4 317-000995 RG* 00 53 00.8240297016 -26 36 43.951220460   15.035 13.931 13.857   ~ 9 0
24 UCAC4 328-007634 RG* 05 24 02.1828031896 -24 31 17.356640124   15.65 14.69 14.517 13.60 ~ 8 0
25 2MASS J05240439-2431520 RG* 05 24 04.4000273664 -24 31 52.124672784   16.002 15.047   13.969 ~ 4 0
26 2MASS J05240661-2431125 RG* 05 24 06.6134494656 -24 31 12.622308024   15.41 14.38   13.26 ~ 8 0
27 2MASS J05240730-2433590 RG* 05 24 07.3055032440 -24 33 59.088957624   15.73 14.78   13.70 ~ 5 0
28 2MASS J05240938-2432460 RG* 05 24 09.3825638400 -24 32 46.083908760   15.80 14.84 14.593 13.76 ~ 6 0
29 M 79 GlC 05 24 10.59 -24 31 27.3     8.16     ~ 796 0
30 UCAC4 328-007742 RG* 05 24 10.7491775520 -24 35 44.468077704   15.855 15.047 14.680 13.867 ~ 10 0
31 2MASS J05241172-2430038 RG* 05 24 11.7293334792 -24 30 03.906240300   15.341 14.257   13.061 ~ 5 0
32 Cl* NGC 1904 SAW V1 RG* 05 24 13.0056794976 -24 34 44.078020284   15.971 15.012   13.944 ~ 7 0
33 2MASS J05242075-2433266 RG* 05 24 20.7540084192 -24 33 26.733534444   15.936 14.987   13.909 ~ 8 0
34 UCAC4 328-007892 RG* 05 24 26.0585703192 -24 31 47.995073832   15.399 14.296 13.765 13.096 ~ 9 0
35 Cl* NGC 2808 PKD 33918 RG* 09 11 01.6894011672 -64 51 36.042636456   15.784 14.417   12.925 ~ 13 0
36 2MASS J09112752-6451312 RG* 09 11 27.5269876296 -64 51 31.259076084   16.346 15.119     ~ 12 0
37 Cl* NGC 2808 PKD 30763 RG* 09 11 31.6223106456 -64 54 58.008574440   15.946 14.694   13.345 ~ 13 0
38 Cl* NGC 2808 PKD 8739 RG* 09 11 51.2017826880 -64 48 37.535678100   15.721 14.332   12.779 ~ 14 0
39 NGC 2808 GlC 09 12 03.10 -64 51 48.6           ~ 1394 0
40 Cl* NGC 2808 PKD 8603 RG* 09 12 14.0467933080 -64 48 42.899736852   15.847 14.432     ~ 13 0
41 Cl* NGC 2808 PKD 10105 RG* 09 12 21.1451574840 -64 47 13.889998644   15.958 14.717   13.308 ~ 13 0
42 Cl* NGC 2808 PKD 38228 RG* 09 12 30.9730576536 -64 56 08.516146560   16.211 14.981     ~ 12 0
43 Cl* NGC 2808 PKD 7536 RG* 09 12 31.6995250872 -64 49 22.267134228   15.769 14.417   12.911 ~ 13 0
44 Cl* NGC 2808 PKD 49743 RG* 09 12 36.8014065984 -64 51 45.082943280   16.353 15.168     ~ 13 0
45 Cl* NGC 2808 PKD 38660 RG* 09 12 39.8704213728 -64 55 43.079179836   15.672 14.290     ~ 12 0
46 Cl* NGC 2808 PKD 10571 RG* 09 12 41.1212222904 -64 46 25.847795244   15.806 14.376     ~ 13 0
47 Cl* NGC 2808 PKD 44984 RG* 09 12 45.8811905712 -64 53 01.402724040   15.871 14.597   13.168 ~ 13 0
48 Cl* NGC 3201 CWFD 3-124 RG* 10 17 26.4425190552 -46 24 50.496358788   14.209 12.911   11.32 ~ 11 0
49 2MASS J10172697-4625524 RG* 10 17 26.9759756928 -46 25 52.463455608   14.719 13.580   12.13 ~ 9 0
50 Cl* NGC 3201 CWFD 3-196 RG* 10 17 34.1178756096 -46 24 14.870030796   14.261 13.055     ~ 8 0
51 NGC 3201 GlC 10 17 36.82 -46 24 44.9           ~ 853 0
52 Cl* NGC 3201 CWFD 3-227 RG* 10 17 37.3040964792 -46 20 15.489996648   14.775 13.691     ~ 8 0
53 2MASS J10173765-4626128 RG* 10 17 37.6581983928 -46 26 12.833498472   14.671 13.505     ~ 6 0
54 2MASS J10173863-4623256 RG* 10 17 38.6344097496 -46 23 25.636182360   14.478 13.278     ~ 6 0
55 2MASS J10173891-4624023 RG* 10 17 38.9098347864 -46 24 02.311058556   14.219 13.015     ~ 7 0
56 Cl* NGC 3201 CWFD 3-277 RG* 10 17 40.7596542816 -46 24 44.845648560   14.808 13.657   12.18 ~ 12 0
57 Cl* NGC 3201 CWFD 3-279 RG* 10 17 41.0024096592 -46 23 43.744122240   14.565 13.378   11.89 ~ 11 0
58 Cl* NGC 3201 CWFD 3-303 RG* 10 17 42.9293682192 -46 22 48.290307276   14.744 13.601   12.20 ~ 12 0
59 Cl* NGC 3201 CWFD 3-308 RG* 10 17 43.3023331200 -46 24 38.894769504   14.910 13.783   12.37 ~ 11 0
60 Cl* NGC 3201 CWFD 3-322 RG* 10 17 45.4025472528 -46 25 31.765884492   14.861 13.668     ~ 8 0
61 NGC 3201 3414 RG* 10 17 47.4780685512 -46 23 53.806005564   14.256 12.993   11.47 ~ 17 0
62 Cl* NGC 4590 WALK 25 RG* 12 39 07.2181288680 -26 44 33.331947900 15.545 15.283 14.401 13.834 13.303 ~ 9 0
63 Cl* NGC 4590 HAR 2028 RG* 12 39 16.2384971232 -26 47 46.834461888   14.801 13.741     ~ 14 0
64 Cl* NGC 4590 HAR 130 RG* 12 39 17.0048908872 -26 45 38.599156332   15.183 14.231     ~ 14 0
65 Cl* NGC 4590 WALK 79 RG* 12 39 19.7235120936 -26 44 16.388450160   14.848 13.840     ~ 8 0
66 Cl* NGC 4590 WALK 84 RG* 12 39 20.1378471720 -26 43 06.145275792   15.480 14.614     ~ 8 0
67 Cl* NGC 4590 WALK 151 RG* 12 39 24.2209309824 -26 45 17.009309268   15.511 14.629     ~ 8 0
68 M 68 GlC 12 39 27.98 -26 44 38.6     7.96     ~ 973 0
69 Cl* NGC 4590 WALK 363 RG* 12 39 29.737 -26 43 46.80   15.014 14.058     ~ 7 0
70 Cl* NGC 4590 HAR 1258 RG* 12 39 30.0786276864 -26 42 46.615100076   15.246 14.356     ~ 14 0
71 Cl* NGC 4590 WALK 394 RG* 12 39 30.6774857472 -26 41 38.761257732   15.393 14.533     ~ 7 0
72 Cl* NGC 4590 WALK 465 RG* 12 39 32.9526564648 -26 45 13.647918276   15.357 14.454     ~ 8 0
73 Cl* NGC 4590 HAR 1239 RG* 12 39 37.6268792376 -26 45 15.557633604   15.211 14.277     ~ 16 0
74 Cl* NGC 4590 WALK 567 RG* 12 39 44.5680053160 -26 48 58.890244608   15.576 14.679     ~ 9 0
75 2MASS J12400258-2643342 RG* 12 40 02.5770550608 -26 43 34.234925196 15.615 15.388 14.508 13.964 13.422 ~ 6 0
76 NGC 5139 GlC 13 26 47.28 -47 28 46.1           ~ 3361 0
77 M 3 GlC 13 42 11.62 +28 22 38.2     6.39     ~ 2449 0
78 NGC 5904 201 RG* 15 18 04.0763118168 +02 05 55.771732500   14.349 13.195   11.9096 ~ 16 0
79 NGC 5904 242 RG* 15 18 12.6104497008 +02 03 10.338572808   14.7500 13.6950   12.5422 ~ 14 0
80 2MASS J15181299+0205466 RG* 15 18 13.0039144176 +02 05 46.678157772   14.7000 13.6181   12.4541 ~ 8 0
81 2MASS J15181897+0208192 RG* 15 18 18.9724356960 +02 08 19.238172072   14.5400 13.3973   12.1976 ~ 8 0
82 Cl* NGC 5904 ARP 3052 RG* 15 18 24.2872684824 +02 01 09.101751384   15.0100 14.0600   12.9592 ~ 22 0
83 Cl* NGC 5904 SB 2-92 RG* 15 18 29.354 +02 03 49.38   14.6439 13.5656   12.3587 ~ 11 0
84 NGC 5904 469 RG* 15 18 29.3624119968 +02 07 50.039630148   14.8200 13.7679   12.6370 ~ 22 0
85 2MASS J15183263+0202199 RG* 15 18 32.6240393040 +02 02 20.037931800   14.3600 13.1400   11.8955 ~ 7 0
86 M 5 GlC 15 18 33.22 +02 04 51.7     5.95     ~ 1945 0
87 2MASS J15184052+0207337 RG* 15 18 40.5233923296 +02 07 33.780842256   14.4700 13.3300   12.1487 ~ 20 0
88 NGC 5904 829 RG* 15 18 41.8737043104 +02 05 53.808254376   14.9400 13.9200   12.8018 ~ 20 0
89 NGC 5904 852 RG* 15 18 43.4702175552 +02 03 07.466320908   14.6500 13.4928   12.3359 ~ 25 0
90 NGC 5904 860 RG* 15 18 44.4962016312 +02 02 05.423756928   14.4600 13.2300   12.0046 ~ 33 0
91 2MASS J15184645+0206336 RG* 15 18 46.4556039648 +02 06 33.702696036   15.0100 13.9694   12.8765 ~ 10 0
92 2MASS J15185077+0204598 RG* 15 18 50.7770813544 +02 04 59.850127200   15.0500 14.0000   12.8939 ~ 10 0
93 NGC 6121 314 RG* 16 23 04.3810595256 -26 23 43.069565040 14.75 13.303 11.817   10.100 ~ 36 0
94 NGC 6121 474 RG* 16 23 13.9484472072 -26 33 24.539562864 14.89 13.556 12.055   10.286 ~ 30 0
95 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 2422 RG* 16 23 14.5990497360 -26 30 46.990708560 15.05 13.901 12.482   10.813 ~ 19 0
96 NGC 6121 209 RG* 16 23 24.3734062920 -26 32 28.498772292 15.04 13.866 12.437   10.755 ~ 30 0
97 NGC 6121 154 RG* 16 23 26.9462895216 -26 31 31.372012704 15.06 13.898 12.485   10.788 ~ 29 0
98 NGC 6121 6 RG* 16 23 29.5109139504 -26 29 11.711659776 14.88 13.678 12.246   10.565 ~ 31 0
99 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 1619 RG* 16 23 31.4246685816 -26 33 11.109816900 14.67 13.259 11.744   9.982 ~ 18 0
100 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 30598 RG* 16 23 35.1876213168 -26 32 32.502462396 14.72 13.49 11.999   10.208 ~ 12 0
101 M 4 GlC 16 23 35.22 -26 31 32.7           ~ 1817 0
102 NGC 6121 60 RG* 16 23 36.5811712320 -26 30 20.101500180 14.86 13.74 12.322   10.613 ~ 15 0
103 NGC 6121 27 RG* 16 23 39.9822671376 -26 28 49.036544760 14.74 13.304 11.743   9.938 ~ 46 0
104 2MASS J16234010-2631397 RG* 16 23 40.1048966976 -26 31 39.881417484 14.71 13.308 11.804   10.063 ~ 10 0
105 NGC 6121 237 RG* 16 23 46.3293066912 -26 32 27.251725560 14.83 13.586 12.145   10.480 ~ 24 0
106 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 27448 RG* 16 23 48.7977828528 -26 35 09.179191752   13.219 11.691   9.909 ~ 15 0
107 2MASS J16235358-2634151 RG* 16 23 53.5834359408 -26 34 15.161300760 14.93 13.892 12.534   10.908 ~ 25 0
108 2MASS J16320904-1302270 RG* 16 32 09.0451553424 -13 02 27.008819340   17.175 15.823     ~ 11 0
109 2MASS J16322512-1258285 RG* 16 32 25.1201815512 -12 58 28.538944752   16.974 15.689     ~ 7 0
110 M 107 GlC 16 32 31.86 -13 03 13.6           ~ 770 0
111 2MASS J16323529-1307079 RG* 16 32 35.2949187048 -13 07 07.984607160   15.794 14.296     ~ 15 0
112 2MASS J16323534-1301256 RG* 16 32 35.3432521512 -13 01 25.606051788   17.157 15.874     ~ 12 0
113 2MASS J16324155-1302038 RG* 16 32 41.5535130240 -13 02 03.724654308   15.991 14.419     ~ 16 0
114 M 13 GlC 16 41 41.634 +36 27 40.75     5.8     ~ 2168 0
115 NGC 6218 4263 RG* 16 46 52.9676623944 -01 56 33.116729064   14.549 13.422     ~ 8 0
116 2MASS J16470329-0155466 RG* 16 47 03.2982145512 -01 55 46.606242144   13.886 12.533     ~ 5 0
117 NGC 6218 1265 RG* 16 47 03.9791924520 -02 01 32.251929780   14.236 12.995     ~ 13 0
118 Cl* NGC 6218 KUST 76 RG* 16 47 04.4613982584 -01 57 48.713460588   14.324 13.086     ~ 7 0
119 2MASS J16470709-0156030 RG* 16 47 07.1003386152 -01 56 03.032244240   14.753 13.648     ~ 3 0
120 NGC 6218 1148 RG* 16 47 08.7205055280 -01 59 09.634895340   14.694 13.567     ~ 6 0
121 Cl* NGC 6218 KUST 174 RG* 16 47 11.8552335000 -01 59 57.373258560   14.727 13.614     ~ 9 0
122 M 12 GlC 16 47 14.18 -01 56 54.7     6.07     ~ 657 0
123 NGC 6218 3163 RG* 16 47 17.7044416344 -01 59 09.793785840   14.307 13.117     ~ 8 0
124 NGC 6218 2107 RG* 16 47 21.6051199584 -01 56 59.270374500   13.944 12.589 12.335   ~ 10 0
125 NGC 6218 2116 RG* 16 47 26.5580746896 -01 57 19.165388796   14.152 12.857     ~ 8 0
126 NGC 6218 2247 RG* 16 47 27.4153039512 -02 00 24.667284060   13.923 12.577     ~ 15 0
127 2MASS J16563597-0405137 AB* 16 56 35.9791519488 -04 05 13.800376860   14.3469 13.1283   11.7156 ~ 9 0
128 2MASS J16564584-0401260 AB* 16 56 45.8567681304 -04 01 25.986934308   14.3331 13.1335   11.7560 ~ 10 0
129 NGC 6254 2104 RG* 16 56 54.3485891736 -04 05 36.025123020   14.6360 13.4074   11.9914 ~ 9 0
130 NGC 6254 3054 RG* 16 56 54.6631962336 -04 08 55.494218292   14.5742 13.3517   11.9202 ~ 11 0
131 NGC 6254 3028 RG* 16 56 57.5077566120 -04 06 50.290807572   14.5867 13.3532   11.9378 ~ 11 0
132 NGC 6254 3029 RG* 16 57 01.2202078848 -04 06 18.580393764   14.51 13.25   11.750 ~ 6 0
133 NGC 6254 2074 RG* 16 57 02.5104310680 -04 02 41.384372964   15.0082 13.8784   12.5810 ~ 9 0
134 NGC 6254 3073 RG* 16 57 05.5159774176 -04 08 36.448428840   14.2397 12.8859   11.38 ~ 15 0
135 2MASS J16570782-0409370 AB* 16 57 07.8344290440 -04 09 37.009333620   14.3223 13.1245   11.7143 ~ 12 0
136 M 10 GlC 16 57 09.05 -04 06 01.1     4.98     ~ 770 0
137 Cl* NGC 6254 BARN 16 RG* 16 57 11.2925376888 -04 06 33.230335464     13.241   11.781 ~ 5 0
138 Cl* NGC 6254 BARN 19 RG* 16 57 12.2797410528 -04 05 33.284835672   14.2063 12.8685   11.3378 ~ 8 0
139 2MASS J16571278-0403156 AB* 16 57 12.7885811880 -04 03 15.690877092   14.2506 13.0446   11.6224 ~ 21 0
140 NGC 6254 1015 RG* 16 57 14.1704693496 -04 05 32.961544008   14.2438 12.8902   11.3519 ~ 15 0
141 NGC 6254 4086 RG* 16 57 25.8776381640 -04 06 17.577059904   14.4985 13.1904   11.6937 ~ 11 0
142 NGC 6388 GlC 17 36 17.461 -44 44 08.34   7.40       ~ 891 1
143 2MASS J17400552-5339493 RG* 17 40 05.5322018280 -53 39 49.433137452 10.94 12.991 12.078     ~ 8 0
144 2MASS J17403068-5342258 RG* 17 40 30.6930237960 -53 42 25.918487820 10.84 12.971 12.067     ~ 7 0
145 2MASS J17403391-5341212 RG* 17 40 33.9130174080 -53 41 21.365686500   12.953 12.036     ~ 5 0
146 2MASS J17403522-5339428 RG* 17 40 35.2305474600 -53 39 42.990627852   12.677 11.729     ~ 6 0
147 2MASS J17403776-5339572 RG* 17 40 37.7612323368 -53 39 57.404917872   12.382 11.369     ~ 5 0
148 NGC 6397 GlC 17 40 42.09 -53 40 27.6     5.17     ~ 1940 0
149 2MASS J17404221-5341230 RG* 17 40 42.2206486032 -53 41 23.112599208   12.189 11.155     ~ 5 0
150 TYC 8729-925-1 RG* 17 40 44.7678936552 -53 44 05.904028248 10.32 12.77 11.75     ~ 6 0
151 2MASS J17404525-5341049 RG* 17 40 45.2609282904 -53 41 04.762264488   12.805 11.854     ~ 5 0
152 2MASS J17404680-5336326 RG* 17 40 46.8116312808 -53 36 32.626684368 11.37 13.458 12.565     ~ 8 0
153 2MASS J17404885-5341160 RG* 17 40 48.8634535296 -53 41 16.113817140   12.620 11.655     ~ 5 0
154 TYC 8729-1683-1 RG* 17 41 03.4781194896 -53 39 39.931232076 10.18 12.87 11.78     ~ 6 0
155 2MASS J17410896-5337324 RG* 17 41 08.9617053864 -53 37 32.575707444 11.09 13.225 12.324     ~ 6 0
156 NGC 6441 GlC 17 50 13.06 -37 03 05.2           ~ 867 0
157 NGC 6528 GlC 18 04 49.61 -30 03 20.8   12.12 10.65     ~ 512 0
158 NGC 6553 GlC 18 09 15.68 -25 54 27.9   9.08       ~ 591 0
159 [CBG2009] NGC 6752 17557 RG* 19 10 43.7058324624 -59 59 01.296074904   13.181 12.104     ~ 4 0
160 NGC 6752 3 RG* 19 10 43.7198620272 -60 01 03.970293528   13.07 11.97     ~ 15 0
161 2MASS J19104476-5952179 RG* 19 10 44.7572924472 -59 52 17.923861056   13.678 12.696     ~ 8 0
162 2MASS J19104538-5958011 RG* 19 10 45.3755127696 -59 58 01.227713988   13.140 12.049     ~ 7 0
163 [CBG2009] NGC 6752 17301 RG* 19 10 48.8429287464 -59 59 04.618101264   12.959 11.824     ~ 4 0
164 NGC 6752 GlC 19 10 52.11 -59 59 04.4           ~ 1964 0
165 2MASS J19105326-6002037 RG* 19 10 53.2773937224 -60 02 03.672736152   13.06 12.060     ~ 25 0
166 [CBG2009] NGC 6752 16687 RG* 19 10 53.5199538264 -59 59 12.110218044   12.917 11.812     ~ 4 0
167 2MASS J19105400-5959285 RG* 19 10 54.0144910272 -59 59 28.457876184   13.033 11.917     ~ 8 0
168 Cl* NGC 6752 CBG 24880 RG* 19 10 56.7445560960 -59 57 05.346695376   12.945 11.806     ~ 10 0
169 2MASS J19110109-5957226 RG* 19 11 01.1111967360 -59 57 22.632070284   12.88 11.68     ~ 14 0
170 Cl* NGC 6752 CBG 15590 RG* 19 11 03.3124021056 -59 59 27.217653576   13.136 12.031     ~ 11 0
171 NGC 6752 29 RG* 19 11 14.3927402376 -60 00 32.223800196   13.006 11.867     ~ 31 0
172 NGC 6752 30 RG* 19 11 19.4663098272 -60 00 34.729621596   13.27 12.195     ~ 25 0
173 Cl* NGC 6752 CBG 30433 RG* 19 11 23.1820953552 -59 53 17.099323332   13.253 12.286 11.966   ~ 13 0
174 2MASS J19393505-3059366 RG* 19 39 35.0511564744 -30 59 36.682306944   13.958 12.860   11.611 ~ 9 0
175 2MASS J19394647-3057463 RG* 19 39 46.4634007680 -30 57 46.297462644   13.749 12.613   11.334 ~ 8 0
176 2MASS J19395061-3055421 RG* 19 39 50.6150168472 -30 55 42.112300368   13.659 12.498   11.197 ~ 10 0
177 2MASS J19395107-3056275 RG* 19 39 51.0742465224 -30 56 27.468046104   13.733 12.656     ~ 6 0
178 2MASS J19395251-3055028 RG* 19 39 52.5131328456 -30 55 02.829968256   13.978 12.914   11.686 ~ 8 0
179 2MASS J19395471-3059042 RG* 19 39 54.7114669752 -30 59 04.228854900   14.002 12.982     ~ 7 0
180 M 55 GlC 19 39 59.71 -30 57 53.1     6.49     ~ 836 0
181 2MASS J19400181-3058450 RG* 19 40 01.8126362736 -30 58 44.958039600   13.663 12.523   11.235 ~ 9 0
182 Cl* NGC 6809 SVH 414 RG* 19 40 02.3078723448 -30 55 44.348898360   13.828 12.790     ~ 8 0
183 2MASS J19400434-3103459 RG* 19 40 04.3448722416 -31 03 45.964211148   13.694 12.565   11.279 ~ 9 0
184 2MASS J19400570-3056128 RG* 19 40 05.7076925976 -30 56 12.858060264   13.916 12.896     ~ 7 0
185 2MASS J19400733-3057283 RG* 19 40 07.3401830263 -30 57 28.324589184   13.865 12.804     ~ 6 0
186 2MASS J19400980-3053548 RG* 19 40 09.8064184848 -30 53 54.820653972   13.837 12.746     ~ 7 0
187 2MASS J19401265-3100287 AB* 19 40 12.6550896360 -31 00 28.724083344   13.611 12.519   11.262 ~ 9 0
188 2MASS J19401816-3054272 RG* 19 40 18.1643219256 -30 54 27.244585260   13.827 12.719   11.465 ~ 8 0
189 2MASS J19532826+1841584 RG* 19 53 28.2655013016 +18 41 58.454365128   14.528 12.955     ~ 2 0
190 Cl* NGC 6838 AH A9 RG* 19 53 37.4728877088 +18 44 59.689600692   14.51 12.94     ~ 54 0
191 NGC 6838 1077 RG* 19 53 37.5742734744 +18 47 28.603448124   14.447 12.762     ~ 52 0
192 Cl* NGC 6838 AH S RG* 19 53 39.8690554440 +18 43 52.997623356   14.45 12.94     ~ 50 0
193 2MASS J19534120+1840236 RG* 19 53 41.2095809520 +18 40 23.608430004   14.694 13.240     ~ 2 0
194 NGC 6838 1113 RG* 19 53 45.7626197880 +18 47 55.013762796   14.255 12.482     ~ 26 0
195 NGC 6838 1064 RG* 19 53 46.1566912560 +18 47 26.146446540   14.634 13.132   11.616 ~ 38 0
196 M 71 GlC 19 53 46.49 +18 46 45.1           ~ 1107 0
197 2MASS J19534721+1846537 AB* 19 53 47.211 +18 46 53.76   14.610 13.131     ~ 15 0
198 NGC 6838 1045 RG* 19 53 48.2738208408 +18 48 02.321225604   14.080 12.346   10.657 ~ 52 0
199 NGC 6838 1046 RG* 19 53 51.5034366408 +18 48 06.095443860   13.955 12.332 11.804   M0: 34 0
200 NGC 6838 1030 RG* 19 53 53.5174378416 +18 47 03.351043716   14.183 12.393     ~ 24 0
201 Cl* NGC 7078 BRO 6 RG* 21 29 12.3636083256 +12 10 49.865118816   14.746 13.583     ~ 20 0
202 NGC 7078 70 RG* 21 29 43.5967857000 +12 15 47.214095292   15.296 14.290     ~ 32 0
203 NGC 7078 69 RG* 21 29 43.7815533288 +12 08 33.295733628   15.444 14.441     ~ 24 0
204 NGC 7078 89 RG* 21 29 46.0690491744 +12 11 31.491041028   15.433 14.484     ~ 25 0
205 NGC 7078 95 RG* 21 29 46.9335846816 +12 08 26.498205744   15.31 14.57   13.56 ~ 23 0
206 NGC 7078 255 RG* 21 29 53.1138013056 +12 12 31.075871364   14.816 13.766 13.415   ~ 36 0
207 NGC 7078 341 RG* 21 29 54.9258244080 +12 13 22.484816292   13.72 12.54   11.22 ~ 54 0
208 NGC 7078 506 RG* 21 29 57.4220220240 +12 08 21.463973916   15.27 14.42   13.45 ~ 17 0
209 NGC 7078 560 RG* 21 29 58.2809072568 +12 08 09.223978668   15.01 14.19   13.19 ~ 19 0
210 M 15 GlC 21 29 58.33 +12 10 01.2           ~ 3102 0
211 2MASS J21300277+1206557 RG* 21 30 02.7740085432 +12 06 55.714408092   15.055 13.997     ~ 22 0
212 NGC 7078 993 RG* 21 30 07.3932186120 +12 10 32.999266704   15.059 14.024     ~ 26 0
213 NGC 7078 1014 RG* 21 30 08.9457077304 +12 08 49.007460156   15.666 14.716     ~ 19 0
214 NGC 7078 1079 RG* 21 30 15.6564387408 +12 08 22.999502976   15.126 14.089     ~ 37 0
215 2MASS J21400607-2307089 RG* 21 40 06.0807278688 -23 07 09.040293264   15.684 14.843     ~ 5 0
216 Cl* NGC 7099 AL 38 RG* 21 40 19.8223815240 -23 13 50.973546036   14.299 13.301 13.130   ~ 9 0
217 [CBG2009] NGC 7099 1006 RG* 21 40 21.4279924800 -23 10 26.852637828   14.313 13.291     ~ 3 0
218 2MASS J21402178-2311037 RG* 21 40 21.7914415728 -23 11 03.760879380   14.130 13.119     ~ 3 0
219 2MASS J21402180-2310090 RG* 21 40 21.8034119280 -23 10 09.145342956   13.560 12.092     ~ 5 0
220 M 30 GlC 21 40 22.12 -23 10 47.5     7.10     ~ 1024 0
221 [CBG2009] NGC 7099 10831 RG* 21 40 23.3476983768 -23 10 49.451341584   14.425 13.437     ~ 3 0
222 2MASS J21402394-2309360 RG* 21 40 23.9430835920 -23 09 36.041051196   15.526 14.720 14.684   ~ 4 0
223 2MASS J21402433-2309392 RG* 21 40 24.3355830840 -23 09 39.221833284   14.354 13.348     ~ 4 0
224 2MASS J21403107-2310333 RG* 21 40 31.0754626536 -23 10 33.417862464   14.845 13.920 13.756   ~ 10 0
225 2MASS J21403856-2310587 RG* 21 40 38.5608399792 -23 10 58.830435948   14.61 13.60 13.398   ~ 13 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2009A&A...505..139C and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu

2023.09.24-10:12:08

© Université de Strasbourg/CNRS

    • Contact