2010A&A...519L...3M


Query : 2010A&A...519L...3M

2010A&A...519L...3M - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 519, L3-3 (2010/9-1)

The lithium content of ω Centauri. New clues to the cosmological Li problem from old stars in external galaxies.

MONACO L., BONIFACIO P., SBORDONE L., VILLANOVA S. and PANCINO E.

Abstract (from CDS):

A discrepancy has emerged between the cosmic lithium abundance inferred by the WMAP satellite measurement coupled with the prediction of the standard big-bang nucleosynthesis theory, and the constant Li abundance measured in metal-poor halo dwarf stars (the so-called Spite plateau). Several models are being proposed to explain this discrepancy, involving either new physics, in situ depletion, or the efficient depletion of Li in the pristine Galaxy by a generation of massive first stars. The realm of possibilities may be narrowed considerably by observing stellar populations in different galaxies, which have experienced different evolutionary histories. The ω Centauri stellar system is commonly considered as the remnant of a dwarf galaxy accreted by the Milky Way. We investigate the lithium content of a conspicuous sample of unevolved stars in this object. We obtained moderate resolution (R=17000) spectra for 91 main-sequence/early sub-giant branch (MS/SGB) ω Cen stars using the FLAMES-GIRAFFE/VLT spectrograph. Lithium abundances were derived by matching the equivalent width of the Li i resonance doublet at 6708Å to the prediction of synthetic spectra computed with different Li abundances. Synthetic spectra were computed using the SYNTHE code along with ATLAS-9 model atmospheres. The stars effective temperatures are derived by fitting the wings of the Hα line with synthetic profiles. We obtain a mean content of A(Li)=2.19±0.14 dex for ω Centauri MS/SGB stars. This is comparable to what is observed in Galactic halo field stars of similar metallicities and temperatures. The Spite plateau seems to be an ubiquitous feature of old, warm metal-poor stars. It exists also in external galaxies, if we accept the current view about the origin of ω Cen. This implies that the mechanism(s) that causes the ``cosmological lithium problem'' may be the same in the Milky Way and other galaxies.

Abstract Copyright:

Journal keyword(s): nuclear reactions, nucleosynthesis, abundances - stars: abundances - stars: population II - cosmology: observations - globular clusters: individual: ω Cen - galaxies: abundances

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/519/L3): table1.dat table2.dat>

Nomenclature: Tables 1-2: [MBS2010] NNNNNN N=91+10 among (Nos 120117-711606).

Simbad objects: 107

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 107
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2023
#notes
1 NGC 104 GlC 00 24 05.359 -72 04 53.20     4.09     ~ 3842 0
2 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 24141 * 13 25 42.84 -47 36 10.4   18.19 17.64 17.25 16.87 ~ 2 0
3 [MBS2010] 311493 * 13 25 45.7952072208 -47 31 39.983170404           ~ 1 0
4 Cl* NGC 5139 HHB 1083 * 13 25 47.9010055368 -47 36 05.914608192   18.24 17.70 17.31 16.92 ~ 3 0
5 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 24410 * 13 25 52.1850270672 -47 36 07.226842356   18.16 17.58 17.16 16.76 ~ 3 0
6 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 19930 * 13 25 55.4235283104 -47 37 07.614910380   18.14 17.57 17.15 16.76 ~ 3 0
7 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 17389 * 13 25 58.0713268032 -47 37 45.030587628   18.12 17.53 17.10 16.70 ~ 3 0
8 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 15328 * 13 26 01.4885414784 -47 38 18.372058404   18.14 17.57 17.18 16.78 ~ 3 0
9 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 20004 * 13 26 03.2330601048 -47 37 06.640442616   18.22 17.66 17.24 16.85 ~ 3 0
10 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 10012 * 13 26 10.2561840504 -47 39 57.498255144   18.27 17.68 17.26 16.86 ~ 2 0
11 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 16128 * 13 26 11.9290494480 -47 38 05.497271700   18.18 17.63 17.24 16.84 ~ 3 0
12 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 14612 * 13 26 13.1098733976 -47 38 31.496978220   18.09 17.53 17.11 16.74 ~ 3 0
13 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 10822 * 13 26 17.1141194472 -47 39 41.851973268   18.51 17.94 17.55 17.18 ~ 2 0
14 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 7037 * 13 26 18.9450246792 -47 41 07.163439972   18.18 17.58 17.17 16.79 ~ 2 0
15 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 19322 * 13 26 18.9914268977 -47 37 16.444380584   18.28 17.73 17.32 16.96 ~ 3 0
16 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 6766 * 13 26 22.0002011496 -47 30 32.215043268   18.862 18.200   17.374 ~ 3 0
17 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 25722 * 13 26 22.0613590512 -47 26 23.847877932   18.357 17.876   17.184 ~ 2 0
18 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 15948 * 13 26 22.070 -47 38 08.14   18.34 17.78 17.38 17.02 ~ 3 0
19 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 17078 * 13 26 22.650 -47 25 31.92   18.126 17.632   16.925 ~ 2 0
20 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 5654 * 13 26 23.230 -47 32 45.23   18.913 18.171   17.384 ~ 3 0
21 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 15257 * 13 26 23.6435911944 -47 38 19.921580340   18.17 17.62 17.21 16.85 ~ 3 0
22 [MBS2010] 242803 * 13 26 23.680 -47 26 10.98   18.133 17.645   16.957 ~ 1 0
23 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 24135 * 13 26 23.7913683192 -47 26 42.704540952   18.425 17.926   17.226 ~ 2 0
24 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 22095 * 13 26 23.8383061704 -47 31 28.701483348   18.390 17.904   17.206 ~ 2 0
25 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 33252 * 13 26 24.070 -47 28 37.49   18.411 17.922   17.213 ~ 2 0
26 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 12553 * 13 26 24.5996332536 -47 39 08.474750424   18.25 17.67 17.25 16.86 ~ 2 0
27 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 27809 * 13 26 24.610 -47 28 03.58   18.381 17.894   17.202 ~ 2 0
28 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 23991 * 13 26 24.960 -47 24 39.03   18.467 17.960   17.256 ~ 2 0
29 [MBS2010] 215094 * 13 26 25.000 -47 32 29.91   18.108 17.610   16.923 ~ 1 0
30 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 21725 * 13 26 25.510 -47 31 16.60   18.258 17.756   17.070 ~ 2 0
31 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 20315 * 13 26 25.530 -47 29 34.41   18.249 17.740   17.033 ~ 2 0
32 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 17310 * 13 26 25.620 -47 37 46.49   18.27 17.67 17.24 16.88 ~ 3 0
33 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 25271 * 13 26 25.920 -47 26 40.71   18.431 17.924   17.218 ~ 2 0
34 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 21627 * 13 26 26.850 -47 27 58.39   18.246 17.749   17.049 ~ 2 0
35 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 21801 * 13 26 26.890 -47 29 31.87   18.226 17.739   17.056 ~ 2 0
36 Cl* NGC 5139 WFI 216031 * 13 26 27.230 -47 32 17.22   18.473 17.654   16.744 ~ 3 0
37 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 21319 * 13 26 27.770 -47 30 57.94   18.261 17.763   17.065 ~ 2 0
38 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 15472 * 13 26 27.8349066456 -47 38 16.367789112   18.32 17.77 17.36 17.01 ~ 3 0
39 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 24809 * 13 26 28.1397133824 -47 31 41.751896844   18.372 17.879   17.175 ~ 2 0
40 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 23489 * 13 26 28.890 -47 24 33.44   18.464 17.975   17.284 ~ 2 0
41 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 19903 * 13 26 30.080 -47 32 00.75   18.313 17.829   17.125 ~ 2 0
42 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 23548 * 13 26 30.1001323128 -47 30 14.058772416   18.268 17.759   17.068 ~ 2 0
43 Cl* NGC 5139 WFI 215700 * 13 26 30.1348915152 -47 32 22.272290556   18.839 18.109   17.302 ~ 3 0
44 [MBS2010] 220173 * 13 26 31.330 -47 31 21.29   18.459 17.955   17.255 ~ 1 0
45 Cl* NGC 5139 WFI 247798 * 13 26 31.460 -47 25 03.30   18.950 18.237   17.378 ~ 4 0
46 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 24338 * 13 26 31.640 -47 32 26.92   18.463 17.955   17.265 ~ 2 0
47 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 17559 * 13 26 31.7894456064 -47 37 42.894064272   18.20 17.64 17.24 16.86 ~ 3 0
48 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 14716 * 13 26 32.0766590088 -47 38 29.706183600   18.11 17.54 17.10 16.72 ~ 3 0
49 Cl* NGC 5139 WFI 243327 * 13 26 32.840 -47 26 03.91   18.478 17.634   16.710 ~ 3 0
50 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 11471 * 13 26 33.3297792072 -47 39 29.514052980   18.25 17.67 17.26 16.87 ~ 2 0
51 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 16385 * 13 26 35.560 -47 38 01.05   18.25 17.70 17.29 16.95 ~ 3 0
52 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 26288 * 13 26 36.6682011432 -47 25 08.182578792   18.465 17.970   17.262 ~ 2 0
53 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 25395 * 13 26 36.820 -47 35 55.49   18.20 17.61 17.19 16.80 ~ 3 0
54 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 19661 * 13 26 37.6620810816 -47 32 55.429353456   18.209 17.704   17.008 ~ 2 0
55 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 6791 * 13 26 38.020 -47 41 13.32   18.23 17.67 17.28 16.92 ~ 2 0
56 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 23057 * 13 26 38.980 -47 36 24.68   18.20 17.62 17.20 16.82 ~ 3 0
57 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 21408 * 13 26 39.090 -47 32 16.33   18.355 17.848   17.154 ~ 2 0
58 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 24756 * 13 26 39.150 -47 31 17.16   18.400 17.891   17.194 ~ 2 0
59 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 6308 * 13 26 39.1521264288 -47 41 25.933730316   18.30 17.73 17.34 17.00 ~ 2 0
60 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 29760 * 13 26 39.400 -47 31 37.41   18.446 17.944   17.242 ~ 2 0
61 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 12496 * 13 26 39.4330830432 -47 39 09.730104804   18.04 17.46 17.04 16.67 ~ 2 0
62 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 9018 * 13 26 39.480 -47 40 20.13   18.22 17.67 17.28 16.92 ~ 2 0
63 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 20055 * 13 26 40.1412028224 -47 37 06.393251496   18.22 17.67 17.25 16.90 ~ 3 0
64 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 19703 * 13 26 40.2546551592 -47 32 05.347177548   18.168 17.660   16.971 ~ 2 0
65 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 20193 * 13 26 41.050 -47 24 19.16   18.340 17.836   17.132 ~ 2 0
66 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 6493 * 13 26 41.2200758376 -47 41 21.212726244   18.47 17.89 17.48 17.12 ~ 2 0
67 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 22536 * 13 26 41.420 -47 25 47.46   18.275 17.777   17.071 ~ 2 0
68 Cl* NGC 5139 WFI 213295 * 13 26 42.670 -47 32 54.29   18.751 17.983   17.163 ~ 3 0
69 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 18631 * 13 26 43.280 -47 25 16.07   18.127 17.647   16.966 ~ 2 0
70 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 66720 * 13 26 44.650 -47 32 19.14   18.422 17.921   17.224 ~ 2 0
71 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 19366 * 13 26 45.7067532456 -47 32 58.811061588   18.349 17.846   17.137 ~ 2 0
72 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 22810 * 13 26 46.080 -47 32 11.40   18.411 17.920   17.232 ~ 2 0
73 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 29190 * 13 26 46.110 -47 30 25.83   18.472 17.973   17.280 ~ 2 0
74 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 18227 * 13 26 46.690 -47 26 29.98   18.229 17.731   17.022 ~ 2 0
75 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 10328 * 13 26 46.8373229372 -47 39 51.723478512   18.47 17.91 17.46 17.10 ~ 2 0
76 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 20389 * 13 26 47.080 -47 24 28.29   18.333 17.843   17.135 ~ 2 0
77 NGC 5139 GlC 13 26 47.28 -47 28 46.1           ~ 3364 0
78 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 23552 * 13 26 48.180 -47 31 24.39   18.373 17.886   17.192 ~ 2 0
79 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 24441 * 13 26 49.980 -47 24 28.90   18.485 17.978   17.274 ~ 2 0
80 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 27030 * 13 26 50.2013588904 -47 35 35.895394068   18.32 17.74 17.32 16.92 ~ 3 0
81 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 15544 * 13 26 50.270 -47 38 15.14   18.23 17.67 17.28 16.90 ~ 3 0
82 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 23311 * 13 26 51.380 -47 24 54.65   18.453 17.967   17.278 ~ 2 0
83 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 23806 * 13 26 51.790 -47 31 16.01   18.421 17.912   17.223 ~ 2 0
84 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 12382 * 13 26 52.720 -47 39 11.66   18.63 18.03 17.61 17.23 ~ 2 0
85 Cl* NGC 5139 PKD 19573 * 13 26 53.4467909496 -47 37 12.932217372   18.14 17.54 17.13 16.71 ~ 3 0
86 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 21594 * 13 26 54.360 -47 31 51.95   18.328 17.833   17.152 ~ 2 0
87 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 20020 * 13 26 54.850 -47 24 46.72   18.303 17.812   17.105 ~ 2 0
88 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 23841 * 13 26 56.030 -47 31 58.72   18.402 17.906   17.212 ~ 2 0
89 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 19475 * 13 26 56.740 -47 24 44.10   18.283 17.791   17.108 ~ 2 0
90 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 20245 * 13 26 56.940 -47 26 11.44   18.305 17.822   17.127 ~ 2 0
91 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 19057 * 13 26 57.380 -47 25 14.46   18.449 17.957   17.250 ~ 2 0
92 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 66536 * 13 26 58.420 -47 27 04.45   18.441 17.934   17.230 ~ 2 0
93 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 20083 * 13 26 58.900 -47 32 13.07   18.353 17.858   17.152 ~ 2 0
94 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 22398 * 13 26 59.340 -47 25 13.73   18.438 17.949   17.267 ~ 2 0
95 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 16749 * 13 27 01.150 -47 31 09.23   18.151 17.650   16.950 ~ 2 0
96 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 16771 * 13 27 01.290 -47 28 35.98   18.092 17.608   16.924 ~ 2 0
97 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 20007 * 13 27 03.930 -47 27 09.94   18.311 17.824   17.132 ~ 2 0
98 Cl* NGC 5139 WFI 248814 * 13 27 05.200 -47 24 48.71   18.812 18.081   17.280 ~ 3 0
99 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 17189 * 13 27 05.230 -47 30 01.08   18.236 17.740   17.047 ~ 2 0
100 Cl* NGC 5139 WFI 224921 * 13 27 08.470 -47 30 15.98   18.737 17.979   17.120 ~ 3 0
101 [MBS2010] 246815 * 13 27 08.720 -47 25 15.22   18.482 17.993   17.303 ~ 1 0
102 Cl* NGC 5139 SGP 19729 * 13 27 08.780 -47 28 17.85   18.265 17.780   17.089 ~ 2 0
103 [BH2018] J201.813250-47.497806 * 13 27 15.180 -47 29 52.13           ~ 2 0
104 NGC 6397 GlC 17 40 42.09 -53 40 27.6     5.17     ~ 1942 0
105 NAME SDG G 18 55 03.1 -30 28 42   4.5 3.6     ~ 2121 2
106 M 54 GlC 18 55 03.33 -30 28 47.5           ~ 1047 0
107 NGC 6752 GlC 19 10 52.11 -59 59 04.4           ~ 1966 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2010A&A...519L...3M and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu


2023.10.03-09:14:32

© Université de Strasbourg/CNRS

    • Contact