2010A&A...523A..43S


Query : 2010A&A...523A..43S

2010A&A...523A..43S - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 523, A43-43 (2010/11-2)

Testing Newtonian gravity in the low acceleration regime with globular clusters: the case of ω Centauri revisited.

SCARPA R. and FALOMO R.

Abstract (from CDS):

Stellar kinematics in the external regions of globular clusters can be used to probe the validity of Newton's law in the low acceleration regimes without the complication of non-baryonic dark matter. Indeed, in contrast to the case of galaxies, in globular clusters a systematic deviation of the velocity dispersion profile from the expected Keplerian falloff would be indicative of a breakdown of Newtonian dynamics rather than the existence of dark matter. We perform a detailed analysis of the velocity dispersion in the globular cluster ω Centauri to determine whether it decreases monotonically with distance as expected within the framework of Newtonian dynamics, or whether it converges toward a constant value as recent works suggest. We combine measurements from two previous studies to almost double the data available at large radii, to better constrain the velocity dispersion profile in the low acceleration regime. We found the inner region of ω Centauri is clearly rotating, while the rotational velocity tends to vanish, being consistent with no rotation at all in the external regions. The cluster velocity dispersion at large radii from the center is found to clearly deviate from the Newtonian prediction. We conclude that there are strong similarities between globular clusters and elliptical galaxies, for in both classes of objects the velocity dispersion tends to remain constant at large radii. In the case of galaxies, this is ascribed to the existence of a massive halo of dark matter, which is physically unlikely in the case of globular clusters. This similarity, if confirmed, is best explained by a breakdown of Newtonian dynamics below a critical acceleration.

Abstract Copyright:

Journal keyword(s): gravitation - globular clusters: general - globular clusters: individual: ω Centauri

Simbad objects: 77

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 77
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2023
#notes
1 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 16003 * 13 24 03.53 -47 16 48.0           ~ 1 0
2 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 19005 * 13 24 12.87 -47 17 53.0           ~ 1 0
3 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 78004 * 13 24 14.3657679792 -47 45 00.893876292   16.430 15.351   14.66 ~ 4 0
4 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 8003 * 13 24 16.1889997800 -47 13 11.334268416   15.950 15.137     ~ 3 0
5 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 8004 RG* 13 24 17.0408077248 -47 13 15.251355480   15.390 14.505     ~ 8 0
6 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 22007 RG* 13 24 20.4213451440 -47 19 35.318414496   14.800 13.636     ~ 6 0
7 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 51005 RG* 13 24 22.0276054416 -47 32 22.360259508           ~ 6 0
8 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 45011 RG* 13 24 26.2293395496 -47 29 38.325253200   16.210 15.348     ~ 8 0
9 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 42009 * 13 24 26.6384387112 -47 28 19.595848008   14.980 14.853     ~ 3 0
10 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 48009 * 13 24 28.8577837824 -47 31 06.772793628   16.504 15.616     ~ 2 0
11 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 33006 RG* 13 24 30.7454698416 -47 24 26.546555808   13.060 11.401     ~ 15 0
12 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 31006 * 13 24 30.8746168368 -47 23 35.609747676   14.940 14.711     ~ 3 0
13 NGC 5139 3631 Pe* 13 24 31.0355129688 -47 30 09.438208560   15.71 14.87     ~ 7 0
14 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 13006 * 13 24 32.0722671024 -47 15 32.027467248   16.440 15.663     ~ 4 0
15 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 28009 * 13 24 32.9190643296 -47 21 54.318342888   15.690 14.782     ~ 6 0
16 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 43002 * 13 24 34.0795864056 -47 28 45.308384328           ~ 4 0
17 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 20006 * 13 24 34.1472972168 -47 18 31.097451240   15.020 14.838     ~ 3 0
18 NGC 5139 3633 Pe* 13 24 37.4696791368 -47 30 00.815721768   15.890 15.062     ~ 7 0
19 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 61009 RG* 13 24 38.4508115952 -47 36 58.629261996   14.490 13.498     ~ 9 0
20 NGC 5139 4402 * 13 24 38.51 -47 26 19.8   14.99 14.79     ~ 3 0
21 NGC 5139 484 RG* 13 24 38.5610978544 -47 27 03.521571876   13.950 12.755     ~ 16 0
22 NGC 5139 3072 RG* 13 24 38.9374099320 -47 31 38.111622456   15.660 14.690     ~ 9 0
23 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 14002 * 13 24 38.9571722592 -47 15 53.263828152   15.700 14.857     ~ 6 0
24 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 10006 Pe* 13 24 39.1248396624 -47 14 01.148078760   14.510 13.710     ~ 10 0
25 NGC 5139 5752 RG* 13 24 39.5918221176 -47 21 48.070838556   15.32 14.35     ~ 9 0
26 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 75005 * 13 24 39.8479569096 -47 43 21.941921892   14.950 14.482     ~ 2 0
27 NGC 5139 3875 RG* 13 24 41.8265389248 -47 28 29.842860036   14.470 13.407     ~ 9 0
28 NGC 5139 1853 * 13 24 44.1036663816 -47 38 22.008003756   15.52 15.51     ~ 5 0
29 NGC 5139 2383 RG* 13 24 44.5123475880 -47 35 07.179282708   15.910 15.050     ~ 8 0
30 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 25004 RG* 13 24 44.8444595376 -47 20 46.191916968   15.050 14.066     ~ 8 0
31 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 85007 * 13 24 46.3098629088 -47 48 02.585167344     15.75   14.72 ~ 4 0
32 NGC 5139 434 RG* 13 24 46.7673824832 -47 24 48.656005776   13.95 12.70     ~ 19 0
33 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 26009 * 13 24 47.1327525648 -47 21 15.235143984           ~ 3 0
34 NGC 5139 5938 * 13 24 50.7963312840 -47 20 10.044540132   14.93 14.75     ~ 3 0
35 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 78008 * 13 24 52.5550118376 -47 44 48.659481060   16.090 15.003     ~ 6 0
36 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 86007 * 13 24 53.9506923480 -47 48 16.231288788           ~ 2 0
37 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 90008 * 13 24 54.0090802944 -47 50 23.542762920           ~ 2 0
38 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 77010 RG* 13 24 56.4904641960 -47 44 28.744355220   14.990 13.639     ~ 7 0
39 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 10009 RG* 13 24 58.6714224600 -47 14 02.901212772   13.810 12.576     ~ 8 0
40 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 22008 * 13 24 59.8065947592 -47 19 16.565788488   15.240 15.063     ~ 2 0
41 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 72007 * 13 25 02.53 -47 41 51.0           ~ 1 0
42 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 79008 * 13 25 03.4670927568 -47 45 27.765571644   15.110 14.721     ~ 2 0
43 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 6 RG* 13 25 05.9860247544 -47 09 21.917797020   16.330 15.534   14.57 ~ 8 0
44 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 15007 * 13 25 06.3596052816 -47 16 22.384217604   15.690 15.629     ~ 2 0
45 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 94011 * 13 25 14.3274107208 -47 51 53.548357068   15.220 14.154     ~ 4 0
46 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 1008 * 13 25 14.8633258920 -47 09 51.534665676   15.120 14.995     ~ 2 0
47 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 86010 Pe* 13 25 14.8916222952 -47 48 28.731549888   15.590 14.553     ~ 7 0
48 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 2005 * 13 25 15.0962453088 -47 10 18.389738028   15.460 15.382     ~ 2 0
49 NGC 5139 6595 * 13 25 20.2802392464 -47 14 00.324119688   15.09 13.96     ~ 8 0
50 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 91010 * 13 25 20.9447983920 -47 50 34.410933960   14.770 14.297     ~ 2 0
51 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 76015 RG* 13 25 21.1867086480 -47 44 03.936310080   15.600 14.602     ~ 8 0
52 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 98012 Pe* 13 25 25.2923238960 -47 53 45.838144284     13.623     ~ 5 0
53 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 85014 * 13 25 30.5083900152 -47 48 05.109754932   15.400 14.347     ~ 6 0
54 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 6009 * 13 25 35.4455062344 -47 12 01.299841524   14.740 14.556     ~ 2 0
55 2MASS J13253639-4745318 RG* 13 25 36.4027982256 -47 45 31.881304800   15.315 14.414     ~ 7 0
56 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 5007 * 13 25 37.8936739608 -47 11 29.622184620   15.270 15.187     ~ 2 0
57 NGC 5139 1158 * 13 25 39.4462771632 -47 45 50.108334264   15.04 14.84     ~ 3 0
58 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 5008 * 13 25 40.9166249856 -47 11 40.816283316   15.330 15.214     ~ 2 0
59 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 82012 RG* 13 25 46.03 -47 46 45.4   16.090 15.294     ~ 6 0
60 NGC 5139 6912 * 13 25 49.6607926584 -47 09 49.376215476   15.29 15.22     ~ 3 0
61 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 95013 * 13 25 58.6885766928 -47 52 26.635454256   14.810 14.560     ~ 2 0
62 2MASS J13260553-4752555 AB* 13 26 05.5362212016 -47 52 55.519387500   13.950 12.971     ~ 9 0
63 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 97012 * 13 26 06.66 -47 53 12.7   14.960 14.754     ~ 2 0
64 NGC 5139 1031 RG* 13 26 09.4903975512 -47 48 07.258421880   15.746 14.813     ~ 9 0
65 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 95015 RG* 13 26 11.7517660152 -47 52 23.134392876   16.120 15.262     ~ 6 0
66 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 86017 RG* 13 26 14.87 -47 48 27.6   16.290 15.453     ~ 6 0
67 NGC 5139 403 RG* 13 26 16.9366345704 -47 49 58.697551956   13.780 12.654     ~ 13 0
68 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 88022 * 13 26 17.89 -47 49 27.6   14.940 14.740     ~ 2 0
69 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 88023 RG* 13 26 20.4231847896 -47 49 13.259417664   16.420 15.547   14.55 ~ 8 0
70 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 87009 RG* 13 26 28.0779177456 -47 48 58.941118440   16.080 15.198     ~ 6 0
71 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 90019 Pe* 13 26 30.0414692592 -47 50 17.912797404     13.509     ~ 6 0
72 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 94014 * 13 26 31.35 -47 51 55.0           ~ 1 0
73 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 90020 * 13 26 34.4419611168 -47 50 17.539432692   16.310 15.568     ~ 5 0
74 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 93016 RG* 13 26 36.1124418408 -47 51 43.822304136   15.340 14.477     ~ 6 0
75 Cl* NGC 5139 LEID 89014 RG* 13 26 39.6798882648 -47 49 52.195779048   14.610 13.605     ~ 9 0
76 NGC 5139 GlC 13 26 47.28 -47 28 46.1           ~ 3364 0
77 NAME Galactic Center reg 17 45 39.60213 -29 00 22.0000           ~ 13909 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2010A&A...523A..43S and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu


2023.10.03-10:17:51

© Université de Strasbourg/CNRS

    • Contact