2014A&A...569A..41R


Query : 2014A&A...569A..41R

2014A&A...569A..41R - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 569A, 41-41 (2014/9-2)

The globular cluster system of NGC 1316. III. Kinematic complexity.

RICHTLER T., HILKER M., KUMAR B., BASSINO L.P., GOMEZ M. and DIRSCH B.

Abstract (from CDS):

The merger remnant NGC 1316 (Fornax A) is one of the most important objects regarding the investigation of and thus an important object to study merger-related processes. A recent photometric study used globular clusters in NGC 1316 to constrain its star formation history, but without the knowledge of individual radial velocities. The kinematical properties of the globular cluster system in comparison with the diffuse stellar light might give more insight into the formation of NGC 1316. Of particular interest is the dark matter content. Planetary nebulae in NGC 1316 indicate a massive dark halo, and globular cluster velocities provide independent evidence. We aim at measuring radial velocities of globular clusters in NGC 1316. We use these kinematical data to investigate the global structure of NGC 1316 and to constrain the dark matter content. We perform multiobject spectroscopy with VLT/FORS2 and MXU. Out of 562 slits, we extract radial velocities for 177 globular clusters. Moreover, we measure radial velocities of the integrated galaxy light, using slits with a sufficiently bright sky. To these data, we add 20 cluster velocities from the literature. In an appendix, we identify new morphological features of NGC 1316 and its companion galaxy NGC 1317. The GC sample based on radial velocities confirms the colour peaks already found in our photometric study. The bright clusters, which probably have their origin in a 2 Gyr old starburst and younger star formation events, avoid the systemic velocity. A Gaussian velocity distribution is found only for clusters fainter than about mR=22 mag. The velocity distribution of clusters shows a pronounced peak at 1600 kms–1. These clusters populate a wide area in the south-western region which we suspect to be a disk population. Globular clusters or subsamples of them do not show a clear rotation signal. This is different from the galaxy light, where rotation along the major axis is discernable out to 3' radius. The kinematic major axis of NGC 1316 is misaligned by about 10° with the photometric major axis, which might indicate a triaxial symmetry. A simple spherical model like that suggested by dynamical analyses of planetary nebulae also reproduces the velocity dispersions of the faint globular clusters. The central dark matter density of the present model resembles a giant elliptical galaxy. This contradicts population properties which indicate spiral galaxies as pre-merger components. Modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND) would provide a solution, but the kinematical complexity of NGC 1316 does not allow a really firm conclusion. However, NGC 1316 might anyway be a problem for a cold dark matter scenario, if the high dark matter density in the inner region is confirmed in future studies.

Abstract Copyright:

Journal keyword(s): galaxies: individual: NGC 1316 - galaxies: kinematics and dynamics - galaxies: star clusters: general

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/569/A41): tableb1.dat tableb2.dat>

Nomenclature: Table B.2: [RHK2014] n1316 gcNNNN N=42 among (Nos 00662-20852).

CDS comments: Appendix A : O1 not in SIMBAD.

Simbad objects: 188

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 188
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2024
#notes
1 NGC 720 Sy1 01 53 00.523 -13 44 19.25   12.4   10.36   ~ 522 0
2 [RHK2014] n1316 gc02855 GlC 03 21 58.70 -37 12 50.0           ~ 1 0
3 [RBD2012] 2665 GlC 03 22 01.24 -37 16 01.3       23.16   ~ 1 0
4 [RBD2012] 1061 GlC 03 22 01.52 -37 15 12.1       22.59   ~ 1 0
5 [RBD2012] 1075 GlC 03 22 02.63 -37 13 20.9       23.22   ~ 1 0
6 [RHK2014] n1316 gc02965 GlC 03 22 03.39 -37 14 34.0           ~ 1 0
7 [RHK2014] n1316 gc03030 GlC 03 22 06.46 -37 08 01.0           ~ 1 0
8 [RBD2012] 2736 GlC 03 22 06.73 -37 10 58.5       23.63   ~ 1 0
9 [RBD2012] 1108 GlC 03 22 06.92 -37 12 34.2       21.89   ~ 1 0
10 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20839 GlC 03 22 07.68 -37 05 13.0           ~ 1 0
11 [RBD2012] 1117 GlC 03 22 07.70 -37 15 50.8       22.30   ~ 1 0
12 [RBD2012] 2755 GlC 03 22 08.04 -37 11 37.4       22.02   ~ 1 0
13 [RHK2014] n1316 gc00662 GlC 03 22 08.47 -37 13 56.0           ~ 1 0
14 [RBD2012] 4101 GlC 03 22 09.78 -37 15 17.5       22.52   ~ 1 0
15 [RBD2012] 2786 GlC 03 22 11.11 -37 09 05.6       22.31   ~ 1 0
16 [RBD2012] 2802 GlC 03 22 12.59 -37 13 27.2       22.51   ~ 1 0
17 [RBD2012] 2807 GlC 03 22 13.24 -37 04 47.4       23.13   ~ 1 0
18 [RBD2012] 2812 GlC 03 22 13.46 -37 12 12.8       22.88   ~ 1 0
19 [RBD2012] 250 GlC 03 22 13.72 -37 11 56.4       23.30   ~ 1 0
20 [RBD2012] 2834 GlC 03 22 15.19 -37 03 10.3       23.07   ~ 1 0
21 [RBD2012] 1177 GlC 03 22 15.43 -37 06 08.0       21.68   ~ 1 0
22 [RBD2012] 2840 GlC 03 22 15.51 -37 13 08.8       21.81   ~ 1 0
23 [RBD2012] 1178 GlC 03 22 15.87 -37 02 18.8       21.83   ~ 1 0
24 [RBD2012] 2851 GlC 03 22 17.00 -37 15 37.7       22.32   ~ 1 0
25 [RHK2014] n1316 gc03281 GlC 03 22 17.03 -37 06 04.0           ~ 1 0
26 [RBD2012] 2855 GlC 03 22 17.28 -37 14 59.5       22.43   ~ 1 0
27 [RBD2012] 1193 GlC 03 22 17.90 -37 16 12.4       22.96   ~ 1 0
28 [RBD2012] 2874 GlC 03 22 19.17 -37 14 18.2       21.77   ~ 1 0
29 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20852 GlC 03 22 19.35 -37 08 53.0           ~ 1 0
30 [RBD2012] 2877 GlC 03 22 19.49 -37 02 37.8       21.52   ~ 1 0
31 [RBD2012] 2888 GlC 03 22 20.31 -37 17 04.7       22.59   ~ 1 0
32 [RBD2012] 1214 GlC 03 22 20.36 -37 06 22.1       22.17   ~ 1 0
33 [RBD2012] 2890 GlC 03 22 20.41 -37 10 29.3       22.55   ~ 1 0
34 [RBD2012] 2891 GlC 03 22 20.46 -37 05 37.1       22.17   ~ 1 0
35 [RBD2012] 2910 GlC 03 22 21.78 -37 11 43.6       21.66   ~ 1 0
36 [RBD2012] 1230 GlC 03 22 21.99 -37 09 48.9       22.78   ~ 1 0
37 [RBD2012] 280 GlC 03 22 23.21 -37 08 26.0       22.05   ~ 1 0
38 [RBD2012] 4128 GlC 03 22 24.65 -37 15 40.9       22.45   ~ 1 0
39 [RBD2012] 2950 GlC 03 22 25.55 -37 14 37.5       22.70   ~ 1 0
40 [RBD2012] 4132 GlC 03 22 25.60 -37 10 42.2       22.23   ~ 1 0
41 [RBD2012] 2952 GlC 03 22 25.77 -37 21 07.5       22.46   ~ 1 0
42 [RBD2012] 285 GlC 03 22 25.88 -37 12 02.2       23.50   ~ 1 0
43 [RBD2012] 2954 GlC 03 22 25.94 -37 19 48.8       23.56   ~ 1 0
44 [RBD2012] 286 GlC 03 22 26.03 -37 05 17.1       23.30   ~ 1 0
45 [RBD2012] 4138 GlC 03 22 26.14 -37 17 28.8       22.01   ~ 1 0
46 [RBD2012] 2958 GlC 03 22 26.23 -37 16 17.0       23.12   ~ 1 0
47 [RBD2012] 2962 GlC 03 22 26.54 -37 14 03.9       22.38   ~ 1 0
48 [RBD2012] 2963 GlC 03 22 26.66 -37 10 21.7       22.26   ~ 1 0
49 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20726 GlC 03 22 26.75 -37 08 42.0           ~ 1 0
50 [RBD2012] 1273 GlC 03 22 26.90 -37 11 59.0       22.76   ~ 1 0
51 [RBD2012] 2969 GlC 03 22 27.07 -37 19 27.6       21.89   ~ 1 0
52 [RBD2012] 1278 GlC 03 22 27.24 -37 18 00.3       23.25   ~ 1 0
53 [RHK2014] n1316 gc00834 GlC 03 22 27.27 -37 12 54.0           ~ 1 0
54 [RBD2012] 293 GlC 03 22 27.50 -37 17 54.2       23.34   ~ 1 0
55 [RBD2012] 1282 GlC 03 22 27.52 -37 12 23.1       22.35   ~ 1 0
56 [RBD2012] 2977 GlC 03 22 28.21 -37 17 14.6       22.22   ~ 1 0
57 [RBD2012] 4146 GlC 03 22 28.32 -37 15 25.7       23.19   ~ 1 0
58 [RBD2012] 1293 GlC 03 22 28.81 -37 18 17.1       20.89   ~ 1 0
59 [RHK2014] n1316 gc00848 GlC 03 22 29.06 -37 13 48.0           ~ 1 0
60 [RBD2012] 4149 GlC 03 22 29.08 -37 14 12.0       21.54   ~ 1 0
61 [RBD2012] 2991 GlC 03 22 29.21 -37 08 30.2       22.74   ~ 1 0
62 [RHK2014] n1316 gc10314 GlC 03 22 29.26 -37 16 11.0           ~ 1 0
63 [GMK2001] 204 GlC 03 22 29.43 -37 13 22.3   22.93 22.00 21.14   ~ 2 0
64 [RBD2012] 1304 GlC 03 22 29.57 -37 13 26.9       21.49   ~ 1 0
65 [RBD2012] 3002 GlC 03 22 29.84 -37 11 51.6       22.93   ~ 1 0
66 [RBD2012] 3004 GlC 03 22 29.87 -37 13 54.0       21.58   ~ 1 0
67 [RBD2012] 1315 GlC 03 22 30.71 -37 17 22.5       23.32   ~ 1 0
68 [RBD2012] 4150 GlC 03 22 30.7151632584 -37 14 17.011784184       20.58   ~ 1 0
69 [RBD2012] 3019 GlC 03 22 31.1365768752 -37 13 02.603619732       20.07   ~ 1 0
70 [RBD2012] 3025 GlC 03 22 31.45 -37 18 17.6       23.58   ~ 1 0
71 [RBD2012] 1324 GlC 03 22 31.54 -37 15 26.5       21.25   ~ 1 0
72 [RBD2012] 3027 GlC 03 22 31.60 -37 16 07.7       21.57   ~ 1 0
73 [RBD2012] 3030 GlC 03 22 31.70 -37 12 37.9       20.83   ~ 1 0
74 [RBD2012] 3033 GlC 03 22 31.7599717800 -37 13 41.364027156       20.83   ~ 2 0
75 [RBD2012] 3041 GlC 03 22 32.13 -37 13 10.9       22.40   ~ 1 0
76 [RBD2012] 3044 GlC 03 22 32.39 -37 13 57.1       21.96   ~ 1 0
77 [RBD2012] 4155 GlC 03 22 32.59 -37 16 02.8       21.99   ~ 1 0
78 [RBD2012] 3046 GlC 03 22 32.59 -37 12 48.9       22.14   ~ 1 0
79 [RBD2012] 3047 GlC 03 22 32.7038031888 -37 14 57.938904168       20.75   ~ 1 0
80 [RBD2012] 3055 GlC 03 22 32.95 -37 12 15.3       21.28   ~ 1 0
81 [RBD2012] 3067 GlC 03 22 33.69 -37 15 35.7       23.20   ~ 1 0
82 [RBD2012] 315 GlC 03 22 33.71 -37 18 07.7       22.87   ~ 1 0
83 [RHK2014] n1316 gc11298 GlC 03 22 34.35 -37 20 29.0           ~ 1 0
84 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20470 GlC 03 22 34.62 -37 17 01.0           ~ 1 0
85 [RBD2012] 1350 GlC 03 22 34.74 -37 17 40.9       22.94   ~ 1 0
86 [RBD2012] 3088 GlC 03 22 35.15 -37 19 20.0       21.16   ~ 1 0
87 [RBD2012] 3090 GlC 03 22 35.23 -37 16 02.6       22.12   ~ 1 0
88 [RBD2012] 3096 GlC 03 22 35.36 -37 17 59.0       22.50   ~ 1 0
89 [RBD2012] 319 GlC 03 22 35.58 -37 18 09.3       21.89   ~ 1 0
90 [RBD2012] 3103 GlC 03 22 35.83 -37 20 08.4       22.49   ~ 1 0
91 [RBD2012] 3122 GlC 03 22 37.32 -37 16 05.8       21.88   ~ 1 0
92 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20439 GlC 03 22 37.52 -37 18 58.0           ~ 1 0
93 [RBD2012] 4518 GlC 03 22 37.87 -37 18 03.2       20.94   ~ 1 0
94 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20440 GlC 03 22 38.04 -37 18 46.0           ~ 1 0
95 [RBD2012] 3132 GlC 03 22 38.11 -37 15 35.9       22.19   ~ 1 0
96 [RBD2012] 3133 GlC 03 22 38.14 -37 19 30.9       22.68   ~ 1 0
97 [RBD2012] 3147 GlC 03 22 38.88 -37 19 43.7       22.37   ~ 1 0
98 [RBD2012] 1389 GlC 03 22 39.07 -37 20 15.3       22.59   ~ 1 0
99 [RBD2012] 3151 GlC 03 22 39.07 -37 15 13.3       21.00   ~ 1 0
100 [RBD2012] 328 GlC 03 22 39.09 -37 19 55.7       22.99   ~ 1 0
101 [RBD2012] 3161 GlC 03 22 39.61 -37 15 57.3       21.42   ~ 1 0
102 [RBD2012] 3192 GlC 03 22 41.21 -37 20 51.3       21.41   ~ 1 0
103 [RBD2012] 3199 GlC 03 22 41.52 -37 18 53.9       23.15   ~ 1 0
104 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20552 GlC 03 22 41.54 -37 16 30.0           ~ 1 0
105 NGC 1316 BL? 03 22 41.789 -37 12 29.52 9.81 9.15 8.53 7.66   ~ 1387 1
106 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20426 GlC 03 22 42.42 -37 16 48.0           ~ 1 0
107 [RBD2012] 341 GlC 03 22 42.73 -37 21 33.7       22.41   ~ 1 0
108 NGC 1317 GiP 03 22 44.2823209512 -37 06 13.180903956 12.20 11.78 11.02 10.22   ~ 213 1
109 [RHK2014] n1316 gc04094 GlC 03 22 46.04 -37 10 28.0           ~ 1 0
110 [RBD2012] 1462 GlC 03 22 46.10 -37 09 44.5       21.67   ~ 2 0
111 [RBD2012] 3269 GlC 03 22 46.83 -37 14 11.4       21.70   ~ 1 0
112 [RBD2012] 3280 GlC 03 22 47.53 -37 14 25.1       21.35   ~ 1 0
113 [RHK2014] n1316 gc04140 GlC 03 22 47.56 -37 10 39.0           ~ 1 0
114 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20237 GlC 03 22 48.76 -37 10 53.0           ~ 1 0
115 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20282 GlC 03 22 48.94 -37 14 49.0           ~ 1 0
116 [RBD2012] 4224 GlC 03 22 49.14 -37 09 19.8       22.03   ~ 1 0
117 [RBD2012] 3314 GlC 03 22 49.16 -37 11 57.4       21.48   ~ 1 0
118 [RBD2012] 3318 GlC 03 22 49.4437692384 -37 11 38.367411072   21.95 21.21 20.33   ~ 3 0
119 [RBD2012] 3327 GlC 03 22 49.80 -37 09 06.7       22.53   ~ 1 0
120 [RBD2012] 3332 GlC 03 22 50.14 -37 13 15.3       22.39   ~ 1 0
121 [RBD2012] 1524 GlC 03 22 50.47 -37 13 02.2       22.70   ~ 1 0
122 [RBD2012] 3336 GlC 03 22 50.86 -37 12 25.9   22.65 21.75 20.95   ~ 3 0
123 [RBD2012] 3338 GlC 03 22 51.09 -37 12 31.5       22.24   ~ 1 0
124 [RBD2012] 1530 GlC 03 22 51.16 -37 08 43.5       23.03   ~ 1 0
125 [RBD2012] 3351 GlC 03 22 51.79 -37 11 05.1       21.31   ~ 2 0
126 [RBD2012] 1540 GlC 03 22 52.36 -37 09 13.7       22.91   ~ 1 0
127 [RBD2012] 383 GlC 03 22 52.84 -37 10 26.1       22.68   ~ 1 0
128 [RBD2012] 384 GlC 03 22 52.99 -37 12 48.7       22.94   ~ 1 0
129 [RBD2012] 3374 GlC 03 22 53.24 -37 10 33.0       21.29   ~ 1 0
130 [RBD2012] 4238 GlC 03 22 53.29 -37 10 58.5       21.92   ~ 1 0
131 [RBD2012] 3381 GlC 03 22 53.76 -37 11 14.8       21.76   ~ 1 0
132 [RBD2012] 3384 GlC 03 22 53.8745521128 -37 10 15.400320528   20.77 20.05 19.14   ~ 3 0
133 [RBD2012] 3394 GlC 03 22 54.38 -37 13 40.5       23.28   ~ 1 0
134 [RBD2012] 3397 GlC 03 22 54.59 -37 11 20.3       21.86   ~ 1 0
135 [RBD2012] 3411 GlC 03 22 55.47 -37 09 48.7       22.30   ~ 1 0
136 [RHK2014] n1316 gc08569 GlC 03 22 55.53 -37 12 17.0           ~ 1 0
137 [RBD2012] 3417 GlC 03 22 56.13 -37 11 23.8       21.36   ~ 1 0
138 [RBD2012] 3422 GlC 03 22 56.37 -37 09 22.3       21.48   ~ 1 0
139 [RBD2012] 1586 GlC 03 22 56.57 -37 13 54.1       22.52   ~ 1 0
140 [RBD2012] 3451 GlC 03 22 58.69 -37 14 19.8       21.98   ~ 1 0
141 [RBD2012] 410 GlC 03 22 58.85 -37 08 49.2       22.86   ~ 1 0
142 [RBD2012] 1623 GlC 03 22 59.72 -37 11 26.5       20.91   ~ 1 0
143 [RHK2014] n1316 gc04534 GlC 03 23 00.26 -37 08 58.0           ~ 1 0
144 [RHK2014] n1316 gc08693 GlC 03 23 00.35 -37 06 11.0           ~ 1 0
145 [RBD2012] 420 GlC 03 23 01.41 -37 08 34.3       22.74   ~ 1 0
146 [RBD2012] 3505 GlC 03 23 03.1260175056 -37 08 27.173679648       19.74   ~ 1 0
147 [RBD2012] 1652 GlC 03 23 03.59 -37 11 53.5       23.21   ~ 1 0
148 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20118 GlC 03 23 03.76 -37 04 29.0           ~ 1 0
149 [RHK2014] n1316 gc04633 GlC 03 23 04.61 -37 04 55.0           ~ 1 0
150 [RHK2014] n1316 gc08822 GlC 03 23 04.84 -37 03 49.0           ~ 1 0
151 [RBD2012] 3541 GlC 03 23 06.45 -37 14 44.5       22.88   ~ 1 0
152 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20231 GlC 03 23 06.55 -37 10 43.0           ~ 1 0
153 [RHK2014] n1316 gc08860 GlC 03 23 06.70 -37 14 34.0           ~ 1 0
154 [RHK2014] n1316 gc08863 GlC 03 23 06.75 -37 10 02.0           ~ 1 0
155 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20330 GlC 03 23 07.69 -37 16 53.0           ~ 1 0
156 [RBD2012] 3579 GlC 03 23 08.65 -37 04 48.9       21.16   ~ 1 0
157 [RBD2012] 3580 GlC 03 23 08.69 -37 06 43.5       23.20   ~ 1 0
158 [RHK2014] n1316 gc08918 GlC 03 23 08.98 -37 18 50.0           ~ 1 0
159 [RBD2012] 1695 GlC 03 23 09.22 -37 15 32.6       23.20   ~ 1 0
160 [RHK2014] n1316 gc01232 GlC 03 23 09.96 -37 18 27.0           ~ 1 0
161 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20313 GlC 03 23 11.47 -37 14 50.0           ~ 1 0
162 [RHK2014] n1316 gc08973 GlC 03 23 11.72 -37 17 30.0           ~ 1 0
163 [RHK2014] n1316 gc04772 GlC 03 23 12.22 -37 05 04.0           ~ 1 0
164 [RBD2012] 461 GlC 03 23 12.47 -37 19 04.1       22.85   ~ 1 0
165 [RBD2012] 3632 GlC 03 23 12.99 -37 09 17.6       21.88   ~ 1 0
166 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20340 GlC 03 23 15.02 -37 17 17.0           ~ 1 0
167 [RBD2012] 3667 GlC 03 23 16.60 -37 15 21.5       21.74   ~ 1 0
168 [RBD2012] 1748 GlC 03 23 16.64 -37 21 29.6       22.61   ~ 1 0
169 [RBD2012] 478 GlC 03 23 16.70 -37 20 23.3       22.57   ~ 1 0
170 [RBD2012] 1752 GlC 03 23 16.7085741888 -37 10 50.625012144       20.57   ~ 1 0
171 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20343 GlC 03 23 17.95 -37 17 48.0           ~ 1 0
172 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20151 GlC 03 23 18.46 -37 07 17.0           ~ 1 0
173 [RBD2012] 485 GlC 03 23 18.95 -37 15 04.8       23.03   ~ 1 0
174 [RHK2014] n1316 gc20161 GlC 03 23 20.33 -37 08 31.0           ~ 1 0
175 [RBD2012] 3723 GlC 03 23 21.07 -37 10 06.9       22.46   ~ 1 0
176 [RHK2014] n1316 gc01347 GlC 03 23 21.56 -37 06 38.0           ~ 1 0
177 [RBD2012] 500 GlC 03 23 22.69 -37 14 57.1       22.54   ~ 1 0
178 [RBD2012] 4308 GlC 03 23 23.09 -37 10 26.0       21.00   ~ 1 0
179 NGC 1396 GiG 03 38 06.5677454520 -35 26 23.637846372   14.80       ~ 98 1
180 NGC 1399 BiC 03 38 29.083 -35 27 02.67 11.05 9.74 9.59 8.12   ~ 1569 1
181 ACO S 373 ClG 03 38 29.4 -35 27 08           ~ 1822 0
182 NGC 1521 GiG 04 08 18.9110259504 -21 03 07.337782908   12.31   10.73   ~ 117 0
183 NGC 4636 LIN 12 42 49.8333280080 +02 41 15.951929028   12.62 11.84     ~ 1117 1
184 NGC 6782 Sy2 19 23 57.9062029800 -59 55 20.952769044   12.70 11.84 11.27 11.7 ~ 125 1
185 S80 L1 PoG ~ ~           ~ 4 0
186 S80 L4 PoG ~ ~           ~ 3 0
187 S80 R2 PoG ~ ~           ~ 2 0
188 S80 L2 PoG ~ ~           ~ 4 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2014A&A...569A..41R and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu