2013ApJ...769...21S


Query : 2013ApJ...769...21S

2013ApJ...769...21S - Astrophys. J., 769, 21 (2013/May-3)

Measuring protoplanetary disk accretion with H I pfund β.

SALYK C., HERCZEG G.J., BROWN J.M., BLAKE G.A., PONTOPPIDAN K.M. and VAN DISHOECK E.F.

Abstract (from CDS):

In this work, we introduce the use of H I Pfund β (Pfβ; 4.6538 µm) as a tracer of mass accretion from protoplanetary disks onto young stars. Pfβ was serendipitously observed in NIRSPEC and CRIRES surveys of CO fundamental emission, amounting to a sample size of 120 young stars with detected Pfβ emission. Using a subsample of disks with previously measured accretion luminosities, we show that Pfβ line luminosity is well correlated with accretion luminosity over a range of at least three orders of magnitude. We use this correlation to derive accretion luminosities for all 120 targets, 65 of which are previously unreported in the literature. The conversion from accretion luminosity to accretion rate is limited by the availability of stellar mass and radius measurements; nevertheless, we also report accretion rates for 67 targets, 16 previously unmeasured. Our large sample size and our ability to probe high extinction values allow for relatively unbiased comparisons between different types of disks. We find that the transitional disks in our sample have lower than average Pfβ line luminosities, and thus accretion luminosities, at a marginally significant level. We also show that high Pfβ equivalent width is a signature of transitional disks with high inner disk gas/dust ratios. In contrast, we find that disks with signatures of slow disk winds have Pfβ luminosities comparable to those of other disks in our sample. Finally, we investigate accretion rates for stage I disks, including significantly embedded targets. We find that stage I and stage II disks have statistically indistinguishable Pfβ line luminosities, implying similar accretion rates, and that the accretion rates of stage I disks are too low to be consistent with quiescent accretion. Our results are instead consistent with both observational and theoretical evidence that stage I objects experience episodic, rather than quiescent, accretion.

Abstract Copyright:

Journal keyword(s): accretion, accretion disks - protoplanetary disks - stars: formation - stars: pre-main sequence

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/ApJ/769/21): table1.dat table2.dat table3.dat table4.dat table5.dat refs.dat>

Simbad objects: 140

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 140
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2024
#notes
1 EM* LkHA 198 Ae* 00 11 25.8495450336 +58 49 28.713961920   14.65 13.79 14.03   B9e 223 0
2 V* V512 Per Or* 03 29 03.7578170808 +31 16 03.947525688           M3.5 386 0
3 EM* LkHA 271 Or* 03 29 21.8747728752 +31 15 36.242125668   14.0 14.3     K4.0 68 0
4 EM* LkHA 326 Y*O 03 30 44.0132509711 +30 32 46.808287930     16     G 41 0
5 IRAS 03301+3111 Y*O 03 33 12.8440487256 +31 21 24.139522188           M1.8 65 0
6 EM* LkHA 327 ** 03 33 30.414576 +31 10 50.48508   16.67 14.72 14.26   K2 62 0
7 AP J03410913+3144378 cor 03 41 09.1372476624 +31 44 37.906318320           ~ 24 0
8 RNO 19 ISM 03 42.9 +31 58           ~ 3 0
9 EM* LkHA 330 TT* 03 45 48.2805122064 +32 24 11.850978276   12.30 10.97     F7 142 0
10 IRAS 03445+3242 Y*O 03 47 41.603 +32 51 43.79           ~ 201 0
11 V* FN Tau TT* 04 14 14.5945463760 +28 27 58.067731188     14.70 13.68   M5e 162 0
12 V* CW Tau TT* 04 14 17.0042670144 +28 10 57.766508508 13.92 13.64 12.36 12.86   K0Ve 355 0
13 V* RY Tau Or* 04 21 57.4092550080 +28 26 35.555316612 10.82 10.34 9.30 9.67 8.87 K1IV/Ve 704 1
14 V* T Tau TT* 04 21 59.4319873992 +19 32 06.432393336   11.22 10.12 9.80   K0IV/Ve 1404 1
15 V* FT Tau Or* 04 23 39.1888788312 +24 56 14.250818940   16.15 14.93 14.70   M2.8 143 0
16 V* IP Tau Or* 04 24 57.0824018640 +27 11 56.539953888   14.50   12.46   M0:Ve 232 0
17 IRAS 04239+2436 Y*O 04 26 56.29704 +24 43 35.3280           ~ 155 0
18 V* DF Tau TT* 04 27 02.7932020080 +25 42 22.453341516 11.97 12.25 11.42 10.31 9.14 M3Ve 500 1
19 V* DG Tau Or* 04 27 04.6921275888 +26 06 16.060169268 13.57 13.97 10.50 12.28   K6Ve 1023 1
20 V* GV Tau B * 04 29 23.7603742259 +24 32 59.248875580           ~ 31 0
21 V* HL Tau Or* 04 31 38.5107609312 +18 13 57.859747968   15.89 14.49 14.39   K5 1422 0
22 IRAS 04287+1807 mul 04 31 38.8 +18 13 57           ~ 796 0
23 V* HK Tau TT* 04 31 50.5715875272 +24 24 17.775307548 16.81 16.689 15.292     M0.5 340 1
24 Haro 6-13 Or* 04 32 15.4174258632 +24 28 59.577717108 19.22   17.7     M0 214 1
25 V* FZ Tau Or* 04 32 31.7627107344 +24 20 03.056011548 16.15     15.04   M0 148 0
26 V* DL Tau Or* 04 33 39.0767679288 +25 20 38.101382952 14.04 14.59 13.40 11.85 10.89 K7Ve 335 0
27 V* DM Tau Or* 04 33 48.7336763736 +18 10 09.973460280 14.30 14.82 14.00     M2Ve 633 0
28 V* CI Tau Or* 04 33 52.0143963264 +22 50 30.094090908 14.97 15.09 13.80     K4IVe 349 1
29 V* AA Tau Or* 04 34 55.4201902392 +24 28 53.033624580 13.14 13.34 12.20 12.03   K5Ve 723 0
30 V* HQ Tau Or* 04 35 47.3357318616 +22 50 21.686966484 15.01 14.15 12.02 11.18   K0 110 0
31 V* DO Tau Or* 04 38 28.5880527336 +26 10 49.467596196 12.78 13.44 12.30 13.01   M1Ve 375 1
32 NAME Taurus Complex SFR 04 41.0 +25 52           ~ 4412 0
33 Haro 6-33 TT* 04 41 38.8257958224 +25 56 26.741499648     18.40     M0.5 124 2
34 V* V1000 Tau Or* 04 42 07.3303627320 +25 23 02.932953612 19.09 16.1 15.01     M2.5 82 0
35 V* DP Tau Or* 04 42 37.6989071232 +25 15 36.983641716 15.84 15.2 13.70 14.42   M0.8 172 1
36 V* DR Tau Or* 04 47 06.2151561264 +16 58 42.813872580 12.03 11.86 10.50 12.19   K5Ve 534 0
37 V* DS Tau Or* 04 47 48.5954691000 +29 25 11.191621512 13.11 13.16 12.30 12.37 10.80 K4Ve 258 0
38 V* UY Aur Or* 04 51 47.3890167432 +30 47 13.551561492 12.82 12.96 11.90 10.59 9.52 M0e+M2.5e 359 0
39 V* GM Aur Or* 04 55 10.9815576936 +30 21 59.373771876 14.59 13.351 12.242 11.798   K3Ve 688 0
40 V* AB Aur Ae* 04 55 45.8458932216 +30 33 04.292077032 7.20 7.16 7.05 6.96 6.70 A0Ve 1067 2
41 V* SU Aur Or* 04 55 59.3866872552 +30 34 01.499608092   10.33 9.30 9.17   G2IIIne 591 0
42 HD 31648 Ae* 04 58 46.2655706952 +29 50 36.987625680 7.84 7.78 7.62 7.76 7.43 A5Vep 518 0
43 * iot Tau ** 05 03 05.7465241272 +21 35 23.860305924   4.797 4.615     A7V 172 0
44 V* UX Ori Ae* 05 04 29.9878898040 -03 47 14.286732072 10.25 10.93 8.70 9.62 9.43 A4IVe 363 1
45 HD 35187 Y*O 05 24 01.17261 +24 57 37.5791   8.79 8.71 8.72   A2e+A7 107 0
46 HD 36112 Ae* 05 30 27.5285630040 +25 19 57.076288752   8.57 8.27     A8Ve 468 0
47 HD 244604 Or* 05 31 57.2511172320 +11 17 41.368840404   9.61 9.43     A0Vesh 75 0
48 HD 36917 Or* 05 34 46.9822530528 -05 34 14.583314568   8.13 8.03     B9III/IV 153 0
49 HD 37258 Ae* 05 36 59.2496063912 -06 09 16.331028249   9.72 9.61 9.56   A3Ve 135 0
50 V* BF Ori Ae* 05 37 13.2623828280 -06 35 00.568242528 10.37 10.00 9.69 10.06 9.31 A7III 293 0
51 HD 37357 Ae* 05 37 47.0794735560 -06 42 30.209473224   8.96 8.85     A1V 109 0
52 HD 37411 Or* 05 38 14.5072831944 -05 25 13.301118588 10.03 9.91 9.79 9.60 9.45 hA3VakA0mA0(eb)_lB 90 0
53 V* RR Tau Ae* 05 39 30.5115918672 +26 22 26.967444996 11.64 12.09 11.28 10.58 10.17 A0:IVe 225 0
54 HD 37806 Be* 05 41 02.2930798296 -02 43 00.731764812 7.67 7.93 7.90     B9/9.5II/III 160 0
55 HD 38120 Be* 05 43 11.8932782280 -04 59 49.889995692 9.08 9.10 9.1     B9Vnne 90 0
56 HD 45677 Be* 06 28 17.4219710352 -13 03 11.128860972 7.86 8.52 8.50 8.11 8.01 B2IV/V[e] 330 0
57 HD 259431 Ae* 06 33 05.1906369144 +10 19 19.982565336 8.39 8.95 8.72     B6ep 286 1
58 EM* LkHA 25 Ae* 06 40 44.6376365304 +09 48 02.151653868 12.745 13.03 18.85 12.545 12.386 B4Ve 144 0
59 HD 50138 Ae* 06 51 33.3989823840 -06 57 59.450772852 6.28 6.68 6.67     A1Ib/II 219 0
60 EM* LkHA 220 Ae* 07 04 06.7000977696 -11 26 08.505214800   11.62 11.60     B8e 58 0
61 HD 58647 Em* 07 25 56.0985504216 -14 10 43.548632256 6.81 6.92 6.85 6.73 6.73 B9IV 96 0
62 IRAS 08211-4158 IR 08 22 52.08 -42 07 53.7           ~ 25 0
63 NAME Vela XYZ Rad 08 34.0 -45 50           ~ 1229 2
64 IRAS 08448-4343 cor 08 46 33.8 -43 54 33           ~ 66 1
65 HD 79210 SB* 09 14 22.7748624830 +52 41 11.791503353   9.388   6.8   K7V 307 0
66 V* CE Ant TT* 10 42 30.1018928760 -33 40 16.229805204   12.21 10.91   9.10 M2Ve 207 1
67 V* TW Hya TT* 11 01 51.9053285064 -34 42 17.033218380   11.94 10.50 10.626 9.18 K6Ve 1891 1
68 V* VW Cha Or* 11 08 01.502064 -77 42 28.87524 13.91 14.165 12.761 12.653 10.69 K7+M0 187 0
69 V* VZ Cha Or* 11 09 23.7739008528 -76 23 20.857480836   13.82 12.94   12.14 K7e 140 0
70 TWA 3 ** 11 10 27.894072 -37 31 51.96612   13.53 12.05 11.61 9.29 M4Ve+M4Ve 211 0
71 V* CV Cha Or* 11 12 27.7055693328 -76 44 22.302807396   12.02 10.98 10.51 9.76 G9Ve 194 1
72 HD 98800 TT* 11 22 05.28975 -24 46 39.7571   10.20 9.28 9.26 7.386 K5V(e) 375 0
73 CD-26 8623 TT* 11 32 41.2658824800 -26 51 55.961893800   13.69 12.23 11.14 9.637 M3Ve 105 0
74 NAME Chamaeleon Region SFR 11 55 -78.0           ~ 806 0
75 CPD-36 6759 Y*O 15 15 48.4460065200 -37 09 16.024369824   9.21 8.708     F8V 462 1
76 CD-33 10685 Or* 15 45 12.8678037432 -34 17 30.644403036 12.47 11.56 10.224 9.60 8.685 K3Ve 272 1
77 V* GQ Lup Or* 15 49 12.1053805848 -35 39 05.058139788 12.19 12.76 11.66 11.15   K7Ve 290 1
78 HD 141569 Y*O 15 49 57.7482550392 -03 55 16.341617064 7.22 7.20 7.12 7.00 7.04 A2VekB9mB9(_lB) 540 0
79 THA 15-12 Or* 15 56 09.2066646912 -37 56 06.126118692   13.12 11.93 11.45   M0e 420 0
80 HD 142666 TT* 15 56 40.0221861696 -22 01 40.005872148 9.41 9.37 8.82 8.31 8.01 F0V_sh 269 0
81 HD 142527 Ae* 15 56 41.8882637904 -42 19 23.248281828   9.04 8.34     F6III 640 1
82 V* RU Lup TT* 15 56 42.3108692112 -37 49 15.473946900 9.27 10.07 9.60     K7/M0e 468 0
83 HD 143006 Or* 15 58 36.9126279888 -22 57 15.220559196   10.92 10.14   8.70 G5IVe 254 0
84 NAME Lupus Complex SFR 16 03 -38.1           ~ 720 0
85 HD 325367 Or* 16 03 05.4915085848 -40 18 25.426727676   11.40 8.50     M0 354 0
86 * bet01 Sco bC* 16 05 26.2319826 -19 48 19.630018 1.68 2.55 2.62 2.60 2.69 B1V 561 0
87 HD 144432 Ae* 16 06 57.9533126832 -27 43 09.760564056 8.47 8.53 8.19 7.82 7.53 A9/F0V 245 1
88 HD 144965 Be* 16 10 10.5557672592 -40 07 43.767402492 6.71 7.206 7.114     B3Vne 64 0
89 V* V866 Sco Or* 16 11 31.345632 -18 38 25.96200   13.98 12.63 12.81   K0e+K5e 281 0
90 Haro 1-1 Or* 16 21 34.7045923320 -26 12 26.913018060   14.59       K5e 60 0
91 Haro 1-4 Or* 16 25 10.508136 -23 19 14.78820       13.15   K4e 73 0
92 EM* SR 4 Or* 16 25 56.1659023848 -24 20 48.240627072     12.80 11.7 10.7 K0:Ve 186 1
93 Haro 1-6 Or* 16 26 03.0276684144 -24 23 36.188140848   14.15 14.01 12.38 10.80 K0 217 2
94 DoAr 24 TT* 16 26 17.0743951968 -24 20 21.594730920   16.06 14.21 14.02 11.57 K7.5V 112 1
95 Elia 2-20 TT* 16 26 18.8775818016 -24 28 19.695035064           ~ 119 1
96 VSSG 30 Y*O 16 26 44.19504 -24 34 48.3492           ~ 135 0
97 WL 22 TT* 16 26 59.16720 -24 34 58.8072           ~ 65 0
98 WL 16 Y*O 16 27 02.33520 -24 37 27.2316           A0-F3 157 0
99 Elia 2-29 Y*O 16 27 09.43032 -24 37 18.7716           ~ 283 1
100 EM* SR 21A TT* 16 27 10.2778380120 -24 19 12.622467720   16.08 14.10     G1 271 1
101 WLY 1-43 Y*O 16 27 11.17992 -24 40 46.6680           ~ 60 0
102 YLW 15 Y*O 16 27 26.906 -24 40 50.81           ~ 268 1
103 YLW 16A Y*O 16 27 28.02744 -24 39 33.5052           K8 194 0
104 IRAS 16245-2423 TT* 16 27 37.1906433768 -24 30 35.025246828       16.66 14.67 B5-F2 307 0
105 YLW 45 Y*O 16 27 39.82824 -24 43 15.0672           ~ 115 0
106 NAME Ophiuchus Molecular Cloud SFR 16 28 06 -24 32.5           ~ 3626 1
107 YLW 58 TT* 16 28 16.5129208176 -24 36 58.054939128   18.5   16.55 14.46 M4 100 0
108 ROXs 43A TT* 16 31 20.1191847456 -24 30 05.057116128   11.89 10.93     G5IVe 48 0
109 DoAr 43 Em* 16 31 30.8820829680 -24 24 39.887863092   16.98 15.23 15.20   K2Ve 58 0
110 Haro 1-16 Or* 16 31 33.4634997336 -24 27 37.158728076   14.02 12.80     K3e 223 0
111 IRAS 16285-2355 Y*O 16 31 35.65752 -24 01 29.4708           ~ 137 0
112 V* V1003 Oph TT* 16 34 09.1696133088 -15 48 16.776092124     13.44     G5 98 0
113 HBC 650 TT* 16 34 29.32 -15 47 01.4           K3.0 177 2
114 * zet Oph Be* 16 37 09.5400587698 -10 34 01.509742704 1.73 2.58 2.56 2.46 2.50 O9.2IVnn 1839 0
115 HD 149914 * 16 38 28.6527873384 -18 13 13.713126384   6.967 6.746     B9.5IV 70 0
116 HD 150193 Ae* 16 40 17.9243127240 -23 53 45.193372692 9.69 9.32 8.79 8.41   A2IVe 321 0
117 Wa Oph 4 Or* 16 48 18.0034524096 -14 11 15.801239760   15.40 13.46     K5Ve 30 0
118 Hen 3-1258 Or* 16 48 45.6326070624 -14 16 35.849828856   14.94 13.34 12.84   K6 120 0
119 2MASS J16490082-1417108 TT* 16 49 00.8094451056 -14 17 10.762697436   17.1 15.2     ~ 15 0
120 EM* AS 209 TT* 16 49 15.3034917000 -14 22 08.643317664   12.62 11.28     K4Ve 390 0
121 HD 163296 Ae* 17 56 21.2881851168 -21 57 21.871819008 7.00 6.93 6.85 6.86 6.67 A1Vep 1110 0
122 HD 169142 Ae* 18 24 29.7799891464 -29 46 49.327400568   8.42 8.16     F1VekA3mA3_lB? 448 0
123 V* VV Ser Ae* 18 28 47.8620017808 +00 08 39.923474964 12.99 12.63 11.80 11.01 10.24 A5Ve 249 0
124 NAME Serpens Cloud SFR 18 29 49 +01 14.8           ~ 1100 2
125 IRAS 18274+0112 Y*O 18 29 57.73680 +01 14 05.6940           M4: 139 2
126 2MASS J18295820+0115216 Y*O 18 29 58.2037073472 +01 15 21.610474308           K7.0 40 0
127 EM* LkHA 348 Be* 18 34 12.6529075104 -00 26 21.795198000   15.978 14.323 13.698   Be 34 0
128 WRAY 15-1880 TT* 18 42 57.9813628512 -35 32 42.826760736   12.91 11.77     K2 50 0
129 V* S CrA B * 19 01 08.6478545856 -36 57 20.880059148           ~ 23 0
130 V* TY CrA Ae* 19 01 40.8284458320 -36 52 33.816176040 10.03 9.92 9.39     B9e 285 0
131 [TS84] IRS 2 Y*O 19 01 41.569 -36 58 31.23           K2 85 0
132 HH 100 HH 19 01 49.1 -36 58 16           ~ 81 0
133 V* T CrA Ae* 19 01 58.7902764120 -36 57 50.339720880     11.67     F0 167 0
134 V* VV CrA Or* 19 03 06.7410913704 -37 12 49.686912432   16.45 14.67 14.12 11.62 K7 119 0
135 HD 179218 Ae* 19 11 11.2538919456 +15 47 15.636008472 7.55 7.476 7.39 7.25 7.21 A0Ve 255 0
136 V* WW Vul Ae* 19 25 58.7494120560 +21 12 31.333658616 11.46 10.99 10.25 10.38 10.12 A2IVe 224 0
137 HD 190073 Ae* 20 03 02.5098474264 +05 44 16.660712904 7.91 7.86 7.73   7.65 A2IVe 256 0
138 BD+40 4124 Ae* 20 20 28.2413946720 +41 21 51.529070088 11.11 11.36 10.62 10.510   B2Ve 291 1
139 EM* AS 442 Ae* 20 47 37.4657848584 +43 47 24.975739896 11.90 11.56 10.90 10.18 9.95 B8Ve 92 0
140 EM* MWC 1080 Ae* 23 17 25.5895018656 +60 50 43.444557384   13.24 11.85 11.251   B0eq 323 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2013ApJ...769...21S and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu