2015A&A...575A..12V


Query : 2015A&A...575A..12V

2015A&A...575A..12V - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 575A, 12-12 (2015/3-1)

Uncertainties in asteroseismic grid-based estimates of stellar ages. SCEPtER: Stellar CharactEristics Pisa Estimation gRid.

VALLE G., DELL'OMODARME M., PRADA MORONI P.G. and DEGL'INNOCENTI S.

Abstract (from CDS):

Stellar age determination by means of grid-based techniques that adopt asteroseismic constraints is a well established method nowadays. However some theoretical aspects of the systematic and statistical errors affecting these age estimates still have to be investigated. We study the impact on stellar age determination of the uncertainty in the radiative opacity, in the initial helium abundance, in the mixing-length value, in the convective core overshooting, and in the microscopic diffusion efficiency adopted in stellar model computations. We extended our SCEPtER grid to include stars with mass in the range [0.8; 1.6]M and evolutionary stages from the zero-age main sequence to the central hydrogen depletion. For the age estimation we adopted the same maximum likelihood technique as described in our previous work. To quantify the systematic errors arising from the current uncertainty in model computations, many synthetic grids of stellar models with perturbed input were adopted. We found that the current typical uncertainty in the observations accounts for 1σ statistical relative error in age determination, which on average ranges from about -35% to +42%, depending on the mass. However, owing to the strong dependence on the evolutionary phase, the age's relative error can be higher than 120% for stars near the zero-age main sequence, while it is typically of the order of 20% or lower in the advanced main-sequence phase. The systematic bias on age determination due to a variation of ±1 in the helium-to-metal enrichment ratio ΔY/ΔZ is about one-fourth of the statistical error in the first 30% of the evolution, while it is negligible for more evolved stages. The maximum bias due to the presence of the convective core overshooting is -7% and -13% for mild and strong overshooting scenarios. For all the examined models, the impact of a variation of ±5% in the radiative opacity was found to be negligible. The most important source of bias is the uncertainty in the mixing-length value αml and the neglect of microscopic diffusion. Each of these effects accounts for a bias that is nearly equal to the random error uncertainty. Comparison of the results of our technique with other grid techniques on a set of common stars showed general agreement. However, the adoption of a different grid can account for a variation in the mean estimated age up to 1Gyr.

Abstract Copyright:

Journal keyword(s): methods: statistical - stars: evolution - stars: oscillations - stars: low-mass - stars: fundamental parameters - asteroseismology

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/575/A12): table3.dat table5.dat>

Simbad objects: 75

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 75
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2024
#notes
1 BD+47 2683 * 18 43 42.4230433392 +47 56 16.009897416   9.85 9.26     G0V 76 0
2 HD 173701 PM* 18 44 35.1191008536 +43 49 59.790008892   8.37 7.52     G8V 178 0
3 TYC 3544-1782-1 V* 18 45 47.5024088976 +48 04 56.999846712   10.25 9.81     F5IV-V 21 0
4 BD+46 2555 Ro* 18 47 39.2486448504 +46 41 09.979229364   9.98 9.52     F6IV 49 0
5 BD+47 2703 Er* 18 49 33.6586835784 +47 42 39.607192296   10.16 9.54 9.473   F9IV-V 48 0
6 HD 175226 * 18 52 16.4984285976 +43 42 35.801031636   7.91 7.42     F6IV 71 0
7 TYC 3123-1088-1 PM* 18 54 55.8843889776 +40 46 31.216294848   10.84 10.15     G3V 28 0
8 BD+45 2796 PM* 18 56 21.2642726544 +45 30 53.234154468   9.80 9.29     G0.5IV 93 0
9 HD 176071 Er* 18 56 22.1268370056 +45 30 25.361404632   8.81 8.33     F8IV 84 0
10 HD 176153 Ro* 18 56 36.6514583496 +47 39 23.133492756   9.20 8.68     F9IV-V 84 0
11 HD 176693 Er* 18 59 08.6844743448 +48 25 23.600359776   9.34 8.83 8.996   F8V 123 0
12 TYC 3131-759-1 SB* 18 59 10.4997973752 +44 57 01.677181068   10.62 10.07     G0.5IV 26 0
13 TYC 3120-180-1 * 19 00 42.9751446288 +38 34 24.884003820   10.33 9.84     G0IV 24 0
14 HD 177153 PM* 19 01 39.6780721176 +41 29 24.328113936   7.76 7.21     G0 115 0
15 BD+40 3567 * 19 01 45.0508649856 +41 04 50.082446568   9.77 9.27     G0.5IV 29 0
16 TYC 3541-2345-1 * 19 02 09.8972932896 +45 16 39.357745608   10.90 10.21     G3V 45 0
17 HD 177723 V* 19 03 45.1355799960 +45 36 30.189464856   9.54 9.10     F8IV 60 0
18 BD+43 3152 SB* 19 05 02.5897090128 +43 22 46.587093780   9.94 9.38     F8IV 26 0
19 TYC 3124-850-1 Ro* 19 05 37.8739768272 +39 43 09.853287060   10.36 9.88     F5IV-V 25 0
20 BD+38 3428 PM* 19 05 45.2617733112 +38 31 22.560830328   9.77 9.22     F9IV-V 63 0
21 HD 178509 Ro* 19 06 55.9481056080 +42 40 19.342963020   9.39 8.86     F8IV 52 0
22 BD+42 3247 SB* 19 06 58.3280630808 +42 26 08.260897020   10.32 9.75     G0.5IV 67 0
23 HD 178688 * 19 07 43.5917202168 +41 56 15.730146420   9.48 9.02     F6IV 45 0
24 HD 178971 Ro* 19 09 01.9438328856 +38 53 59.485809012   8.79 8.36     F5IV-V 73 0
25 HD 179070 Er* 19 09 26.8349590368 +38 42 50.455534860   8.767 8.25 8.00   F6IV 164 1
26 HD 179260 V* 19 10 11.6372611944 +38 04 55.831675296   8.94 8.49     F5IV-V 65 0
27 HD 179732 * 19 11 53.4817713600 +42 06 27.748644156   9.19 8.74     F5IV-V 46 0
28 BD+47 2787 * 19 14 54.1714120608 +47 41 48.497060760   10.33 9.77     G0.5IV 21 0
29 HD 180867 * 19 15 54.6866907216 +47 03 40.230679068   8.75 8.24     F6IV 58 0
30 BD+39 3706 SB* 19 16 34.9026130056 +40 02 50.359631244       9.1   G1.5V 80 0
31 HD 234856 Ro* 19 17 45.8018919144 +50 28 48.274775580   9.87 9.32     F9IV-V 80 0
32 HD 181207 PM* 19 17 46.3565007888 +41 24 36.838219932   9.06 8.47     F9IV-V 89 0
33 BD+43 3209 * 19 18 54.1337809824 +43 29 46.691977452   10.14 9.52 9.46   F9IV-V 46 0
34 HD 181777 * 19 19 43.4510255328 +44 22 29.275860360   9.17 8.66     F8IV 27 0
35 BD+41 3315 PM* 19 20 29.3442099120 +41 17 28.510142676   9.92 9.38     F9IV-V 46 0
36 BD+43 3221 * 19 20 47.9392965792 +44 09 18.751522032   10.03 9.50     F9IV-V 77 0
37 BD+48 2882 ** 19 21 24.640392 +48 30 53.31924   10.27 9.45 9.36   G1V 56 0
38 BD+48 2887 V* 19 22 20.2267974168 +48 41 43.496977812   9.43 9.01     F5IV 45 0
39 BD+36 3533 V* 19 23 33.2215229808 +37 05 21.732235080   10.06 9.57     F5IV 22 0
40 BD+43 3228 Er* 19 23 56.4112114464 +43 18 52.537486464   10.830 10.170 10.035   G0V 60 0
41 BD+41 3338 * 19 24 11.1933479232 +42 03 09.726975180   9.97 9.19     G8IV-V 72 0
42 HD 182756 * 19 24 30.3488274144 +40 19 23.671912908   9.01 8.31     G1V 67 0
43 HD 183159 PM* 19 26 19.3088534112 +41 52 12.722677572   9.26 8.58     G1V 43 0
44 HD 183298 PM* 19 26 22.0906256352 +50 59 14.334181836   8.71 8.16     G0.5IV 99 0
45 TYC 3547-478-1 PM* 19 26 29.0625819360 +48 42 43.526835576   11.66 10.95     G5IV-V 34 0
46 TYC 3551-149-1 PM* 19 27 20.4900952416 +48 57 12.010523580   10.59 9.85     G5IV 51 0
47 BD+42 3353 * 19 28 13.1663213520 +42 51 49.134229956   9.61 9.10     F6IV 21 0
48 BD+36 3570 Ro* 19 28 19.8441075024 +37 03 35.403120000   9.40 8.97     F8IV 61 0
49 HD 183727 PM* 19 29 01.5896818536 +43 10 34.086444024   8.91 8.49     F5IV-V 16 0
50 TYC 3138-989-1 * 19 29 48.5312811528 +40 37 53.641429644   10.32 9.82     F8V 18 0
51 TYC 3147-130-1 * 19 30 33.1622120832 +44 22 13.053822384   10.40 9.93     F6IV 17 0
52 TYC 3560-2168-1 * 19 34 00.3539264880 +48 21 59.294540196   10.39 9.88     F8V 19 0
53 BD+46 2726 Er* 19 34 43.0022454096 +46 51 09.938179044   10.36 9.64 9.438   K0V 123 0
54 TYC 3143-53-1 Ro* 19 35 03.7372740120 +42 44 16.724850540   10.31 9.85     F8IV 65 0
55 BD+46 2729 PM* 19 35 05.1660121440 +46 58 29.518389696   10.35 9.81     F6IV 29 0
56 BD+44 3183 PM* 19 35 50.5739000112 +44 52 50.022974316   9.38 8.92     hF6mF2gF5V 60 0
57 TYC 3135-624-1 PM* 19 36 48.8136243480 +38 42 56.789855496   10.35 9.55     G5IV 76 0
58 HD 185457 * 19 37 27.6974454120 +40 35 19.915408284   8.93 8.42     F8IV 43 0
59 BD+44 3197 Er* 19 37 54.5252033200 +44 59 04.630621506   10.287 9.641 9.546   G0IV 73 0
60 TYC 3135-416-1 * 19 38 10.6797868344 +38 31 00.667275996   10.20 9.72     F5IV-V 34 0
61 TYC 3139-213-1 PM* 19 38 52.7297005992 +40 09 13.476692988   10.04 9.53     F8IV 18 0
62 HD 185834 * 19 39 00.6724153968 +46 54 06.984718740   9.26 8.78     F6IV 41 0
63 TYC 3556-3445-1 PM* 19 40 21.2108930904 +45 29 20.963746392   10.48 9.91     G3V 75 0
64 HD 186096 PM* 19 40 27.1755476736 +45 41 45.850613064   9.10 8.69     F5V 27 0
65 HD 186700 PM* 19 43 39.6223173216 +48 55 43.808906244   8.86 8.47     F5IV-V 73 0
66 BD+43 3349 Ro* 19 45 23.9642658792 +44 04 35.865815844   10.01 9.51     F6IV 43 0
67 HD 187160 SB* 19 46 41.3411982432 +44 20 54.601189476   7.650 7.083     F9IV-V 101 0
68 BD+43 3368 * 19 48 14.2913289840 +43 44 48.961091040   9.63 9.17     F8V 45 0
69 HD 187637 PM* 19 49 18.1388793264 +41 34 56.859084552       7.2   F8V 116 0
70 HD 226030 Er* 19 49 38.3876919096 +39 38 47.535753120   9.75 9.264     F5IV-V 22 0
71 BD+47 2934 Ro* 19 50 14.2728443568 +47 28 25.166654760   9.68 9.24     F5IV-V 47 0
72 HD 188325 * 19 52 41.6110326624 +44 36 16.756288776   9.44 8.94     F6IV 18 0
73 HD 188819 Ro* 19 54 54.1810396872 +47 08 42.949406328   9.12 8.66     F8IV 65 0
74 HD 190166 Er* 20 01 51.4248305136 +44 21 14.147515008   10.13 9.581 9.523   F8V 57 0
75 HD 190319 PM* 20 02 33.3210896856 +44 31 58.994152536   10.63 9.91     G2.5V 39 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2015A&A...575A..12V and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu