2017A&A...607A.135W


C.D.S. - SIMBAD4 rel 1.7 - 2021.06.19CEST21:13:37

2017A&A...607A.135W - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 607A, 135-135 (2017/11-1)

Sodium abundances of AGB and RGB stars in Galactic globular clusters. II. Analysis and results of NGC 104, NGC 6121, and NGC 6809.

WANG Y., PRIMAS F., CHARBONNEL C., VAN DER SWAELMEN M., BONO G., CHANTEREAU W. and ZHAO G.

Abstract (from CDS):

Aims. We investigate the Na abundance distribution of asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars in Galactic globular clusters (GCs) and its possible dependence on GC global properties, especially age and metallicity.
Methods. We analyze high-resolution spectra of a large sample of AGB and red giant branch (RGB) stars in the Galactic GCs NGC 104, NGC 6121, and NGC 6809 obtained with FLAMES/GIRAFFE at ESO/VLT, and determine their Na abundances. This is the first time that the AGB stars in NGC 6809 are targeted. Moreover, to investigate the dependence of AGB Na abundance dispersion on GC parameters, we compare the AGB [Na/H] distributions of a total of nine GCs, with five determined by ourselves with homogeneous method and four from literature, covering a wide range of GC parameters.
Results. NGC 104 and NGC 6809 have comparable AGB and RGB Na abundance distributions revealed by the K-S test, while NGC 6121 shows a lack of very Na-rich AGB stars. By analyzing all nine GCs, we find that the Na abundances and multiple populations of AGB stars form complex picture. In some GCs, AGB stars have similar Na abundances and/or second-population fractions as their RGB counterparts, while some GCs do not have Na-rich second-population AGB stars, and various cases exist between the two extremes. In addition, the fitted relations between fractions of the AGB second population and GC global parameters show that the AGB second-population fraction slightly anticorrelates with GC central concentration, while no robust dependency can be confirmed with other GC parameters.
Conclusions. Current data roughly support the prediction of the fast-rotating massive star (FRMS) scenario. However, considering the weak observational and theoretical trends where scatter and exceptions exist, the fraction of second-population AGB stars can be affected by more than one or two factors, and may even be a result of stochasticity.

Abstract Copyright: © ESO, 2017

Journal keyword(s): stars: abundances - globular clusters: general - globular clusters: individual: NGC 104 - globular clusters: individual: NGC 6121 - globular clusters: individual: NGC 6809 - globular clusters: individual: NGC 6809

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/607/A135): table3.dat table5.dat table7.dat>

Nomenclature: Tables 3, 5, 7: [WPC2016] NGC 104 AGBNNNNNN N=50 among (Nos 58283-203707), [WPC2016] NGC 104 RGBNNNNNN N=40 among (Nos 22468-223961), [WPC2016] NGC 6121 RGBNNNNN N=68 among (Nos 18729-92053), [WPC2016] NGC 6121 AGBNNNNN N=19 among (Nos 30561-86612), [WPC2016] NGC 6809 RGBNNNNNN N=78 among (Nos 231278-333033), [WPC2016] NGC 6809 AGBNNNNNN N=23 among (Nos 246868-325273).

Simbad objects: 294

goto Full paper

goto View the reference in ADS

Number of rows : 294

N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2021
#notes
1 2MASS J00214368-7205162 RG* 00 21 43.7005821970 -72 05 16.267502547   14.138 12.892   11.596 ~ 5 0
2 2MASS J00220714-7200328 RG* 00 22 07.1537773447 -72 00 32.822717001 15.2 13.920 12.607   11.244 ~ 15 0
3 2MASS J00225403-7205169 AB* 00 22 54.0612944580 -72 05 16.976767944   13.802 12.579   11.355 ~ 5 0
4 2MASS J00225491-7210523 RG* 00 22 54.9217852878 -72 10 52.362239743   14.775 13.690   12.559 ~ 6 0
5 2MASS J00225899-7205356 RG* 00 22 59.0077394761 -72 05 35.706686444   14.547 13.407   12.246 ~ 3 0
6 2MASS J00225969-7207061 RG* 00 22 59.7205365791 -72 07 06.154700557   14.355 13.166   11.933 ~ 7 0
7 2MASS J00230571-7209098 AB* 00 23 05.7493102508 -72 09 09.791784701   14.152 13.097   12.015 ~ 4 0
8 2MASS J00230630-7211106 RG* 00 23 06.3307862837 -72 11 10.644040244   14.504 13.348   12.144 ~ 6 0
9 2MASS J00230962-7206213 AB* 00 23 09.6505295165 -72 06 21.269172938   14.131 12.999   11.835 ~ 2 0
10 2MASS J00231347-7207181 RG* 00 23 13.47792 -72 07 18.1884   14.983 13.963   12.890 ~ 1 0
11 2MASS J00231566-7153561 AB* 00 23 15.6823476514 -71 53 56.243839530   13.594 12.278   10.926 ~ 4 0
12 2MASS J00231770-7205589 RG* 00 23 17.7318377136 -72 05 58.899150793   14.920 13.920   12.839 ~ 3 0
13 2MASS J00232032-7158595 RG* 00 23 20.3495373418 -71 58 59.431864562   14.907 13.858   12.764 ~ 4 0
14 2MASS J00232094-7205183 RG* 00 23 20.9773725790 -72 05 18.262265664   14.063 12.801   11.518 ~ 9 0
15 2MASS J00232264-7211417 AB* 00 23 22.6744119604 -72 11 41.708005338   14.283 13.206   12.109 ~ 3 0
16 2MASS J00232481-7158287 RG* 00 23 24.8339454590 -71 58 28.663107340   14.315 13.162   11.963 ~ 3 0
17 2MASS J00232564-7209474 RG* 00 23 25.6752935282 -72 09 47.410286626   13.840 12.517   11.161 ~ 4 0
18 2MASS J00232607-7212239 AB* 00 23 26.0947505565 -72 12 23.875484310   14.394 13.397   12.339 ~ 3 0
19 2MASS J00232649-7206166 AB* 00 23 26.5133169677 -72 06 16.635133644   13.631 12.309   10.989 ~ 3 0
20 2MASS J00232825-7207580 RG* 00 23 28.2882610460 -72 07 58.001910518   14.786 13.712   12.604 ~ 5 0
21 2MASS J00233044-7210104 AB* 00 23 30.44064 -72 10 10.4016   14.284 13.218   12.111 ~ 1 0
22 2MASS J00233084-7214058 AB* 00 23 30.8641241917 -72 14 05.852268819   14.219 13.149   12.043 ~ 3 0
23 2MASS J00233098-7208216 AB* 00 23 30.98544 -72 08 21.6636   14.257 13.215   12.121 ~ 1 0
24 2MASS J00233385-7203284 RG* 00 23 33.8733286634 -72 03 28.418991837   13.922 12.600   11.255 ~ 2 0
25 2MASS J00233904-7203471 RG* 00 23 39.04464 -72 03 47.1420   14.407 13.329   12.189 ~ 2 0
26 2MASS J00233953-7204599 AB* 00 23 39.53112 -72 04 59.9268   14.184 13.070   11.921 ~ 1 0
27 2MASS J00234271-7207538 AB* 00 23 42.71616 -72 07 53.8680   14.219 13.173   12.092 ~ 1 0
28 2MASS J00234279-7211314 AB* 00 23 42.79080 -72 11 31.4808   13.773 12.491   11.219 ~ 4 0
29 2MASS J00234534-7201497 RG* 00 23 45.35 -72 01 49.8   14.261 13.069   11.854 ~ 3 0
30 2MASS J00234603-7157373 RG* 00 23 46.0499679429 -71 57 37.222678690   14.154 12.920   11.643 ~ 3 0
31 2MASS J00234700-7205231 AB* 00 23 47.00376 -72 05 23.1360   13.991 12.937   11.848 ~ 1 0
32 2MASS J00234736-7203322 AB* 00 23 47.366 -72 03 32.28   14.115 13.007   11.868 ~ 2 0
33 2MASS J00234947-7205298 AB* 00 23 49.4934018032 -72 05 29.790314206   13.641 12.281   10.886 ~ 3 0
34 2MASS J00234949-7204500 RG* 00 23 49.49760 -72 04 50.0952   13.370 11.766   10.046 ~ 1 0
35 2MASS J00234970-7210127 RG* 00 23 49.70616 -72 10 12.7344   14.914 13.866   12.739 ~ 3 0
36 Cl* NGC 104 R 8 AB* 00 23 50.534 -72 04 21.34   13.305 11.797   10.140 K0II/III 8 0
37 2MASS J00235099-7207177 RG* 00 23 50.99808 -72 07 17.7492   14.773 13.733   12.648 ~ 3 0
38 Cl* NGC 104 R 26 RG* 00 23 53.1649653147 -72 04 15.589568506   13.410 11.724   9.765 M2II/II-III 9 0
39 2MASS J00235348-7206213 AB* 00 23 53.48160 -72 06 21.3912   14.131 13.105   12.044 ~ 3 0
40 2MASS J00235427-7206561 RG* 00 23 54.2945506665 -72 06 56.057202705   14.932 13.897   12.823 ~ 4 0
41 2MASS J00235438-7158357 AB* 00 23 54.4015353200 -71 58 35.591096388   13.553 12.191   10.771 ~ 5 0
42 2MASS J00235484-7210009 AB* 00 23 54.8769511940 -72 10 00.979708150   14.211 13.168   12.096 ~ 3 0
43 2MASS J00235542-7209050 AB* 00 23 55.42392 -72 09 05.0328   13.974 12.802   11.622 ~ 1 0
44 2MASS J00235584-7154178 RG* 00 23 55.8535726533 -71 54 17.635028718   14.462 13.337   12.169 ~ 7 0
45 2MASS J00235632-7210590 AB* 00 23 56.3539649157 -72 10 58.978640772   14.125 13.056   11.968 ~ 5 0
46 2MASS J00235692-7205325 RG* 00 23 56.9335581331 -72 05 32.558886305   13.398 11.775   9.858 ~ 7 0
47 2MASS J00235912-7203597 AB* 00 23 59.12016 -72 03 59.7780   14.268 13.167   12.023 ~ 1 0
48 2MASS J00240181-7204045 RG* 00 24 01.81032 -72 04 04.5012 15.63 13.903 12.695   11.403 ~ 2 0
49 2MASS J00240202-7202293 AB* 00 24 02.02008 -72 02 29.3316   13.521 12.112   10.668 ~ 1 0
50 2MASS J00240336-7155473 AB* 00 24 03.3730449373 -71 55 47.325909819   13.126 11.661   9.986 ~ 6 0
51 2MASS J00240502-7209531 RG* 00 24 05.0428862255 -72 09 53.125402626   14.068 12.832   11.571 ~ 2 0
52 2MASS J00240517-7205525 RG* 00 24 05.17728 -72 05 52.5804   14.348 13.208   12.048 ~ 1 0
53 NGC 104 GlC 00 24 05.359 -72 04 53.20   5.78 4.09     ~ 3649 0
54 2MASS J00241003-7206296 AB* 00 24 10.03128 -72 06 29.6856   14.214 13.164   12.082 ~ 3 0
55 2MASS J00241145-7202384 AB* 00 24 11.45304 -72 02 38.4792   14.147 13.087   11.988 ~ 1 0
56 2MASS J00241161-7203253 AB* 00 24 11.61960 -72 03 25.3908 15.51 13.417 11.961   10.373 ~ 2 0
57 2MASS J00241218-7202587 AB* 00 24 12.18408 -72 02 58.7760   13.832 12.613   11.367 ~ 1 0
58 2MASS J00241299-7203515 AB* 00 24 12.99432 -72 03 51.5628   14.078 12.947   11.771 ~ 1 0
59 2MASS J00241343-7211264 RG* 00 24 13.4450008383 -72 11 26.387821326   13.669 12.261   10.812 ~ 4 0
60 2MASS J00241462-7204018 AB* 00 24 14.621 -72 04 01.86   14.126 13.058   11.961 ~ 2 0
61 2MASS J00241586-7203028 AB* 00 24 15.86688 -72 03 02.8944   13.645 12.297   10.916 ~ 1 0
62 2MASS J00241655-7205521 AB* 00 24 16.55232 -72 05 52.1124   13.913 12.897   11.838 ~ 3 0
63 2MASS J00242074-7206332 AB* 00 24 20.750 -72 06 33.28   14.168 13.125   12.053 ~ 2 0
64 Cl* NGC 104 R 11 AB* 00 24 21.6886395354 -72 04 26.278798819   13.048 11.503   9.722 K4II-III 6 0
65 2MASS J00242435-7204286 AB* 00 24 24.35256 -72 04 28.6968   13.906 12.770   11.620 ~ 3 0
66 2MASS J00242572-7203307 AB* 00 24 25.7300117782 -72 03 30.673441140   13.927 12.755   11.566 ~ 2 0
67 2MASS J00242763-7205213 AB* 00 24 27.6348247595 -72 05 21.316636742   14.077 12.991   11.881 ~ 4 0
68 2MASS J00242846-7205019 AB* 00 24 28.4667551634 -72 05 01.916582191   14.151 13.091   11.996 ~ 4 0
69 2MASS J00242952-7209077 RG* 00 24 29.5545400966 -72 09 07.607583820   13.394 11.717   9.884 ~ 8 0
70 2MASS J00243106-7207311 AB* 00 24 31.0615357353 -72 07 31.108214799   13.933 12.863   11.752 ~ 3 0
71 2MASS J00243338-7203517 AB* 00 24 33.38040 -72 03 51.7284   14.117 13.017   11.892 ~ 1 0
72 2MASS J00243337-7204200 AB* 00 24 33.3908536582 -72 04 20.046297472   14.011 12.943   11.828 ~ 3 0
73 2MASS J00243771-7205100 AB* 00 24 37.7319593763 -72 05 10.004817952   13.719 12.504   11.269 ~ 4 0
74 2MASS J00244100-7158186 RG* 00 24 41.0094664370 -71 58 18.688199895   14.429 13.276   12.083 ~ 7 0
75 2MASS J00244581-7209106 AB* 00 24 45.8174565898 -72 09 10.457503729 14.9 13.780 12.517   11.212 ~ 7 0
76 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 5617 AB* 00 24 46.2463144888 -71 54 56.098050134   14.320 13.221 13.040 12.063 ~ 3 0
77 2MASS J00244731-7201084 RG* 00 24 47.313 -72 01 08.44   14.758 13.691   12.569 ~ 2 0
78 2MASS J00244746-7201520 AB* 00 24 47.46864 -72 01 52.0896   14.272 13.180   12.038 ~ 1 0
79 2MASS J00245189-7200031 AB* 00 24 51.8800820644 -72 00 03.055176424   14.182 13.141   12.052 ~ 4 0
80 2MASS J00250529-7206012 AB* 00 25 05.29056 -72 06 01.2564   14.216 13.203   12.104 ~ 1 0
81 2MASS J00250540-7201432 RG* 00 25 05.409 -72 01 43.30   14.499 13.409   12.261 ~ 4 0
82 2MASS J00250610-7159152 RG* 00 25 06.0955349828 -71 59 15.225676000   14.595 13.498   12.351 ~ 3 0
83 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 8636 RG* 00 25 15.7303642517 -72 12 44.463078434   13.608 12.182   10.688 ~ 8 0
84 2MASS J00252009-7209110 RG* 00 25 20.1039109109 -72 09 10.868828651   14.775 13.708 13.648 12.593 ~ 4 0
85 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 8740 RG* 00 25 22.4640101693 -72 11 55.306497385   13.894 12.554   11.163 ~ 7 0
86 2MASS J00252299-7154365 AB* 00 25 22.99848 -71 54 36.5076   13.770 12.480   11.145 ~ 1 0
87 2MASS J00252327-7202375 RG* 00 25 23.2780322359 -72 02 37.440061542   13.954 12.650 12.385 11.302 ~ 10 0
88 2MASS J00252858-7200394 RG* 00 25 28.5855406564 -72 00 39.353417482   14.599 13.489 13.313 12.316 ~ 10 0
89 2MASS J00252866-7201200 RG* 00 25 28.6614193815 -72 01 19.969277928   14.907 13.872 13.690 12.765 ~ 10 0
90 2MASS J00253012-7203070 RG* 00 25 30.12240 -72 03 07.0956   14.594 13.493   12.327 ~ 1 0
91 2MASS J00253093-7204198 RG* 00 25 30.9390464695 -72 04 19.724428889   14.987 13.958   12.866 ~ 6 0
92 2MASS J00253428-7157352 AB* 00 25 34.2768225302 -71 57 35.216621868   13.849 12.675   11.463 ~ 7 0
93 2MASS J00253618-7202051 RG* 00 25 36.1912747654 -72 02 05.015349440   14.490 13.346   12.156 ~ 5 0
94 2MASS J00255751-7207529 RG* 00 25 57.5178474713 -72 07 52.774136444   14.083 12.789 12.534 11.412 ~ 5 0
95 2MASS J00262889-7204421 RG* 00 26 28.8782771952 -72 04 42.085011062   14.868 13.842   12.709 ~ 6 0
96 NGC 2808 GlC 09 12 03.10 -64 51 48.6           ~ 1294 0
97 M 3 GlC 13 42 11.62 +28 22 38.2     6.39     ~ 2321 0
98 M 5 GlC 15 18 33.22 +02 04 51.7   7.34 5.95     ~ 1824 0
99 NGC 5986 GlC 15 46 03.00 -37 47 11.1     6.92     ~ 325 0
100 2MASS J16225800-2628463 RG* 16 22 58.0043827702 -26 28 46.505492647   14.085 12.809   11.228 ~ 14 0
101 2MASS J16230438-2623429 RG* 16 23 04.3812124278 -26 23 43.072756715   13.303 11.817   10.100 ~ 32 0
102 2MASS J16231204-2630540 RG* 16 23 12.0438006318 -26 30 54.105013380   14.852 13.597   12.071 ~ 7 0
103 2MASS J16231442-2636055 RG* 16 23 14.424 -26 36 05.53 14.64 12.73 10.88 9.80 9.04 ~ 43 0
104 2MASS J16231459-2630469 RG* 16 23 14.5988454138 -26 30 46.990554395 15.05 13.901 12.482   10.813 ~ 16 0
105 2MASS J16231655-2632095 RG* 16 23 16.5622382734 -26 32 09.735015041 14.79 13.236 11.661   9.896 ~ 32 0
106 2MASS J16231672-2634279 AB* 16 23 16.7265238680 -26 34 28.146532660   13.170 11.732   10.093 ~ 25 0
107 2MASS J16231690-2629479 RG* 16 23 16.9015287519 -26 29 47.955132376 15.28 14.389 13.100   11.559 ~ 16 0
108 2MASS J16231868-2623432 RG* 16 23 18.6900153282 -26 23 43.311644128   13.174 11.493   9.608 ~ 25 0
109 2MASS J16232008-2632415 RG* 16 23 20.0868002465 -26 32 41.554308412   14.726 13.492   11.984 ~ 9 0
110 2MASS J16232114-2631598 AB* 16 23 21.1511865239 -26 31 59.912920047   14.125 12.992   11.557 ~ 5 0
111 2MASS J16232139-2631093 RG* 16 23 21.3967350049 -26 31 09.455126687 14.54 13.281 11.801   10.099 ~ 26 0
112 2MASS J16232169-2626468 RG* 16 23 21.6955768169 -26 26 46.944668171 15.61 14.821 13.565   12.031 ~ 12 0
113 2MASS J16232184-2630495 AB* 16 23 21.84552 -26 30 49.5540   13.621 12.414   10.924 ~ 1 0
114 2MASS J16232195-2630320 RG* 16 23 21.9542147671 -26 30 32.054759597 15.63 14.878 13.643   12.148 ~ 10 0
115 2MASS J16232265-2626221 RG* 16 23 22.6532687955 -26 26 22.202040310 15.02 14.032 12.651   11.014 ~ 17 0
116 2MASS J16232305-2633322 RG* 16 23 23.0552208994 -26 33 32.339288945 15.28 14.413 13.112   11.546 ~ 12 0
117 2MASS J16232402-2630005 RG* 16 23 24.0237024788 -26 30 00.550212177 15.17 14.128 12.776   11.162 ~ 13 0
118 2MASS J16232437-2632284 RG* 16 23 24.3734358178 -26 32 28.499322647 15.04 13.866 12.437   10.755 ~ 26 0
119 2MASS J16232465-2631114 RG* 16 23 24.6538606098 -26 31 11.499853273 15.65 14.893 13.630   12.089 ~ 11 0
120 2MASS J16232488-2631474 RG* 16 23 24.8889490632 -26 31 47.413550590 15.23 14.319 13.019   11.451 ~ 7 0
121 2MASS J16232530-2633291 RG* 16 23 25.3050480062 -26 33 29.260431872 15.17 14.157 12.815   11.201 ~ 13 0
122 2MASS J16232674-2632388 RG* 16 23 26.7463330318 -26 32 38.855149088 15.44 14.588 13.290   11.716 ~ 14 0
123 2MASS J16232700-2630444 RG* 16 23 27.0068389864 -26 30 44.470975121 15.38 14.555 13.291   11.764 ~ 13 0
124 2MASS J16232708-2633297 RG* 16 23 27.0854369425 -26 33 29.755728714 15.32 14.630 13.361   11.786 ~ 13 0
125 2MASS J16232845-2632541 RG* 16 23 28.4326929105 -26 32 54.275658927   14.445 13.169   11.578 ~ 6 0
126 2MASS J16232912-2630297 RG* 16 23 29.1250882891 -26 30 29.806484313 14.92 13.354 11.781   9.988 ~ 40 0
127 2MASS J16232982-2623253 RG* 16 23 29.8236343888 -26 23 25.342472486   14.387 13.044   11.448 ~ 9 0
128 2MASS J16232988-2631490 AB* 16 23 29.8821892599 -26 31 49.184892455   13.360 11.990   10.361 ~ 16 0
129 2MASS J16233067-2629390 AB* 16 23 30.6767892487 -26 29 39.143440229   13.724 12.543   11.086 ~ 2 0
130 CD-26 11313 AB* 16 23 30.8921074956 -26 27 04.098950020   12.598 10.808   8.880 K2 38 0
131 2MASS J16233142-2633110 RG* 16 23 31.4246833576 -26 33 11.112841687 14.67 13.259 11.744   9.982 ~ 17 0
132 2MASS J16233144-2630247 RG* 16 23 31.4508526588 -26 30 24.792372566 14.98 13.864 12.471   10.834 ~ 13 0
133 2MASS J16233151-2636183 RG* 16 23 31.5127664652 -26 36 18.511234612 15.38 14.708 13.456   11.910 ~ 13 0
134 2MASS J16233195-2631457 AB* 16 23 31.9614585306 -26 31 45.821044376   13.888 12.793   11.409 ~ 4 0
135 2MASS J16233236-2626205 RG* 16 23 32.3708449450 -26 26 20.601954610 15.23 14.364 13.061   11.489 ~ 15 0
136 2MASS J16233310-2632306 RG* 16 23 33.1028247144 -26 32 30.654821440 15.23 14.377 13.082   11.515 ~ 7 0
137 2MASS J16233337-2633148 RG* 16 23 33.3814162539 -26 33 14.943031899 15.65 14.864 13.612   12.079 ~ 13 0
138 2MASS J16233386-2634198 RG* 16 23 33.86088 -26 34 19.8120   14.189 12.767   11.062 ~ 8 0
139 Cl* NGC 6121 SAW V17 RG* 16 23 34.0236108671 -26 31 07.861614654 15.06 14.188 12.891   11.331 ~ 12 0
140 2MASS J16233418-2632485 RG* 16 23 34.1844049488 -26 32 48.546379290 15.52 14.832 13.595   12.063 ~ 8 0
141 M 4 GlC 16 23 35.22 -26 31 32.7           ~ 1720 0
142 2MASS J16233535-2632225 AB* 16 23 35.3539672267 -26 32 22.663779429   13.216 11.775   10.093 ~ 2 0
143 2MASS J16233594-2631008 RG* 16 23 35.94216 -26 31 00.8976   12.778 10.981   9.012 ~ 1 0
144 2MASS J16233614-2632015 AB* 16 23 36.1462386737 -26 32 01.669910120   13.141 11.765   10.126 ~ 2 0
145 2MASS J16233741-2638238 AB* 16 23 37.4194286925 -26 38 23.993931545   13.492 12.251   10.721 ~ 16 0
146 2MASS J16233795-2628413 RG* 16 23 37.9512719081 -26 28 41.366976312 15.52 14.759 13.521   12.010 ~ 7 0
147 2MASS J16233846-2633192 RG* 16 23 38.4687212711 -26 33 19.295863735   12.818 10.833   8.608 ~ 33 0
148 2MASS J16233846-2629235 AB* 16 23 38.4718128294 -26 29 23.587690192   13.639 12.370   10.840 ~ 4 0
149 2MASS J16233857-2630380 RG* 16 23 38.5697030327 -26 30 38.180309232 15.15 14.227 12.930   11.389 F0 13 0
150 2MASS J16233885-2625427 RG* 16 23 38.8581850439 -26 25 42.784597066 15.26 14.362 13.071   11.528 ~ 17 0
151 2MASS J16233927-2633059 RG* 16 23 39.27432 -26 33 05.9652   12.718 10.776   8.620 ~ 37 0
152 2MASS J16233948-2631114 RG* 16 23 39.4861871856 -26 31 11.468050871 14.82 13.931 12.635   11.070 ~ 13 0
153 2MASS J16234000-2639029 RG* 16 23 40.0066841945 -26 39 03.171504497 16.89 14.668 13.443   11.916 ~ 11 0
154 2MASS J16234010-2631397 RG* 16 23 40.1048244693 -26 31 39.885640319 14.71 13.308 11.804   10.063 ~ 9 0
155 2MASS J16234085-2631215 AB* 16 23 40.8609239449 -26 31 21.674777064   13.496 12.133   10.520 ~ 9 0
156 2MASS J16234091-2637234 RG* 16 23 40.9203802137 -26 37 23.518223109 15.11 14.234 12.934   11.362 ~ 17 0
157 2MASS J16234268-2631209 AB* 16 23 42.6904607658 -26 31 20.929234916   13.770 12.680   11.300 ~ 7 0
158 Cl* NGC 6121 SAW V54 RG* 16 23 42.8012444638 -26 29 27.611902597 17.79 13.98 12.66 11.86 11.06 ~ 17 0
159 2MASS J16234405-2630061 RG* 16 23 44.0648085712 -26 30 06.152307171 14.67 13.262 11.771   10.079 ~ 28 0
160 2MASS J16234632-2632272 RG* 16 23 46.3292363052 -26 32 27.250951966 14.83 13.586 12.145   10.480 ~ 22 0
161 2MASS J16234740-2631463 AB* 16 23 47.3965151190 -26 31 46.380071591   13.153 11.765   10.138 ~ 24 0
162 2MASS J16234764-2631042 RG* 16 23 47.6473092178 -26 31 04.240670962 15.45 14.704 13.484   12.007 ~ 11 0
163 2MASS J16234788-2629482 RG* 16 23 47.8823966696 -26 29 48.285240262 15.50 14.783 13.575   12.106 ~ 17 0
164 2MASS J16234879-2635093 RG* 16 23 48.7980557407 -26 35 09.188087278   13.219 11.691   9.909 ~ 11 0
165 2MASS J16234980-2633589 RG* 16 23 49.8049106820 -26 33 58.873948795   13.177 11.568   9.748 ~ 24 0
166 2MASS J16235026-2629258 RG* 16 23 50.2611732299 -26 29 25.895508872 15.33 14.610 13.408   11.957 ~ 9 0
167 2MASS J16235300-2628065 RG* 16 23 53.005 -26 28 06.57 15.43 14.744 13.520   12.033 ~ 11 0
168 2MASS J16235358-2634151 RG* 16 23 53.5834333280 -26 34 15.161212344 14.93 13.892 12.534   10.908 ~ 24 0
169 NGC 6121 558 AB* 16 23 53.7530573418 -26 34 42.691296638   13.136 11.769   10.155 ~ 21 0
170 2MASS J16235384-2633525 RG* 16 23 53.8474818308 -26 33 52.538417274 15.13 14.193 12.892   11.327 ~ 18 0
171 2MASS J16235440-2625538 RG* 16 23 54.4036024956 -26 25 53.853939863   13.771 12.475   10.938 ~ 9 0
172 2MASS J16235655-2639011 RG* 16 23 56.5534113715 -26 39 01.138112263   13.406 11.990   10.281 ~ 9 0
173 2MASS J16235746-2632247 RG* 16 23 57.4693909036 -26 32 24.861179118 14.99 13.980 12.642   11.055 ~ 17 0
174 2MASS J16235835-2635390 RG* 16 23 58.3526167558 -26 35 39.043143356 14.84 13.918 12.609   11.034 ~ 19 0
175 2MASS J16235872-2639489 AB* 16 23 58.7175352127 -26 39 49.008504347   13.045 11.625   9.934 ~ 25 0
176 2MASS J16235946-2627572 AB* 16 23 59.4618797256 -26 27 57.229008544   12.851 11.284   9.512 ~ 31 0
177 2MASS J16240090-2635531 RG* 16 24 00.9075569462 -26 35 53.138615999 14.95 13.954 12.592   10.948 ~ 9 0
178 2MASS J16240120-2631326 RG* 16 24 01.2084254715 -26 31 32.697586662 15.27 14.592 13.401   11.951 ~ 9 0
179 2MASS J16240301-2624034 AB* 16 24 03.0210769352 -26 24 03.466675848   12.571 10.859   8.967 ~ 42 0
180 2MASS J16240429-2630278 RG* 16 24 04.2920894325 -26 30 27.981216928 14.93 14.231 12.995   11.493 ~ 14 0
181 2MASS J16240578-2640169 RG* 16 24 05.7877927559 -26 40 17.031365208   14.933 13.667   12.107 ~ 3 0
182 2MASS J16240858-2624552 AB* 16 24 08.5889420966 -26 24 55.233617295   13.099 11.845   10.307 ~ 21 0
183 2MASS J16241292-2636190 RG* 16 24 12.9308888828 -26 36 18.989907580   13.454 12.012   10.320 ~ 8 0
184 2MASS J16241470-2627167 RG* 16 24 14.7006556270 -26 27 16.787420543   14.560 13.347   11.883 ~ 7 0
185 2MASS J16241586-2635066 RG* 16 24 15.8703473209 -26 35 06.620140473   13.750 12.418   10.824 ~ 7 0
186 2MASS J16241589-2632274 RG* 16 24 15.8912896725 -26 32 27.470812268 15.02 14.278 13.033   11.540 ~ 12 0
187 2MASS J16241966-2626351 RG* 16 24 19.6661028672 -26 26 35.085383230   14.490 13.299   11.831 ~ 4 0
188 NAME Sco-Oph Cloud ~ 16 30 00 -21 30.0           ~ 15 0
189 M 13 GlC 16 41 41.634 +36 27 40.75     5.8     ~ 2057 0
190 M 62 GlC 17 01 12.60 -30 06 44.5   8.55 7.39     ~ 538 0
191 NGC 6752 GlC 19 10 52.11 -59 59 04.4   6.96 6.28     ~ 1853 0
192 2MASS J19392144-3105081 RG* 19 39 21.44040 -31 05 08.1312   14.305 13.251   12.032 ~ 1 0
193 2MASS J19392427-3058458 RG* 19 39 24.2739996344 -30 58 45.894177418   14.399 13.384   12.203 ~ 3 0
194 2MASS J19392469-3055190 RG* 19 39 24.6892305911 -30 55 19.114643185   14.614 13.621   12.450 ~ 3 0
195 2MASS J19392981-3101401 RG* 19 39 29.8104814506 -31 01 40.117729534   14.253 13.225   12.033 ~ 3 0
196 2MASS J19393021-3059189 RG* 19 39 30.21576 -30 59 18.9384   14.278 13.222   12.007 ~ 1 0
197 2MASS J19393057-3105551 RG* 19 39 30.57960 -31 05 55.1184   14.702 13.735   12.592 ~ 1 0
198 2MASS J19393225-3055264 RG* 19 39 32.2454398345 -30 55 26.432059815   14.620 13.619   12.444 ~ 2 0
199 2MASS J19393225-3055471 RG* 19 39 32.25504 -30 55 47.1144   14.983 14.105   13.019 ~ 1 0
200 2MASS J19393505-3059366 RG* 19 39 35.0510810357 -30 59 36.682936291   13.958 12.860   11.611 ~ 5 0
201 2MASS J19393864-3048329 AB* 19 39 38.64600 -30 48 32.9076   14.582 13.757   12.714 ~ 1 0
202 2MASS J19394180-3054386 RG* 19 39 41.8001924888 -30 54 38.561607344   15.154 14.244   13.152 ~ 3 0
203 2MASS J19394319-3056519 RG* 19 39 43.1922164319 -30 56 51.981685421   13.734 12.591   11.307 ~ 4 0
204 2MASS J19394345-3100529 RG* 19 39 43.4452973190 -31 00 52.972694536   15.107 14.227   13.141 ~ 3 0
205 2MASS J19394382-3055319 RG* 19 39 43.8207683226 -30 55 31.885756649   14.561 13.581   12.413 ~ 3 0
206 2MASS J19394430-3057085 AB* 19 39 44.30232 -30 57 08.5392   14.229 13.359   12.276 ~ 1 0
207 2MASS J19394480-3056020 AB* 19 39 44.80032 -30 56 02.0580   14.036 13.042   11.860 ~ 1 0
208 2MASS J19394490-3101103 AB* 19 39 44.90328 -31 01 10.3548   14.125 13.205   12.067 ~ 1 0
209 2MASS J19394498-3100137 AB* 19 39 44.9753103399 -31 00 13.739321748   13.144 11.874   10.470 ~ 4 0
210 2MASS J19394647-3057463 RG* 19 39 46.4632581503 -30 57 46.300056135   13.749 12.613   11.334 ~ 5 0
211 2MASS J19394693-3056286 RG* 19 39 46.9313971819 -30 56 28.638617736   14.465 13.466   12.302 ~ 3 0
212 2MASS J19394704-3055302 RG* 19 39 47.0472622558 -30 55 30.234994033   14.821 13.897   12.778 ~ 3 0
213 2MASS J19394740-3056109 AB* 19 39 47.40432 -30 56 10.9824   14.482 13.651   12.602 ~ 1 0
214 2MASS J19394754-3054148 RG* 19 39 47.54928 -30 54 14.8860   15.170 14.265   13.175 ~ 1 0
215 2MASS J19394846-3053048 RG* 19 39 48.4652330909 -30 53 04.745852668   15.037 14.128   13.034 ~ 3 0
216 2MASS J19394868-3107441 AB* 19 39 48.68208 -31 07 44.1372   14.466 13.642   12.591 ~ 1 0
217 2MASS J19394888-3058337 RG* 19 39 48.8858388361 -30 58 33.741582084   14.171 13.152   11.949 ~ 3 0
218 2MASS J19395055-3058294 RG* 19 39 50.5524083877 -30 58 29.382558943   15.193 14.321   13.239 ~ 3 0
219 2MASS J19395061-3055421 RG* 19 39 50.6149116960 -30 55 42.113152214   13.659 12.498   11.197 ~ 6 0
220 2MASS J19395251-3055028 RG* 19 39 52.5130942796 -30 55 02.830894567   13.978 12.914   11.686 ~ 5 0
221 2MASS J19395269-3100508 RG* 19 39 52.6901904409 -31 00 50.854969277   14.526 13.585   12.438 ~ 3 0
222 2MASS J19395396-3057390 RG* 19 39 53.9668869602 -30 57 39.078759138   13.047 11.611   10.095 ~ 4 0
223 2MASS J19395442-3058236 RG* 19 39 54.4236766222 -30 58 23.605055727   13.720 12.618   11.352 ~ 3 0
224 2MASS J19395544-3104190 RG* 19 39 55.4373311097 -31 04 19.052016697   14.614 13.665   12.504 ~ 3 0
225 2MASS J19395596-3057033 RG* 19 39 55.9667536575 -30 57 03.336566446   14.075 13.046   11.847 ~ 3 0
226 2MASS J19395601-3055169 RG* 19 39 56.0135540440 -30 55 16.898411339   13.098 11.732   10.285 ~ 4 0
227 2MASS J19395612-3058194 RG* 19 39 56.12136 -30 58 19.4880   14.512 13.563   12.414 ~ 1 0
228 2MASS J19395614-3053324 RG* 19 39 56.14608 -30 53 32.4924   15.095 14.200   13.108 ~ 1 0
229 2MASS J19395634-3057489 AB* 19 39 56.34072 -30 57 48.9816   14.439 13.607   12.553 ~ 1 0
230 2MASS J19395655-3057201 RG* 19 39 56.5462774574 -30 57 20.133906957   14.875 13.978   12.878 ~ 3 0
231 2MASS J19395695-3054097 RG* 19 39 56.95656 -30 54 09.7956   14.914 14.002   12.891 ~ 1 0
232 2MASS J19395738-3058323 RG* 19 39 57.385 -30 58 32.31   14.009 12.973   11.758 ~ 3 0
233 2MASS J19395746-3100130 RG* 19 39 57.46224 -31 00 13.0752   14.632 13.692   12.553 ~ 1 0
234 2MASS J19395755-3056433 RG* 19 39 57.55560 -30 56 43.3392   15.024 14.109   13.025 ~ 1 0
235 2MASS J19395779-3058487 AB* 19 39 57.79080 -30 58 48.7200   14.388 13.536   12.457 ~ 1 0
236 2MASS J19395821-3057185 RG* 19 39 58.21584 -30 57 18.5832   13.729 12.632   11.383 ~ 1 0
237 2MASS J19395856-3056270 RG* 19 39 58.5548659426 -30 56 27.101919137   14.027 13.006   11.804 ~ 3 0
238 2MASS J19395885-3101223 RG* 19 39 58.8578484625 -31 01 22.356203637   14.411 13.435   12.266 ~ 3 0
239 2MASS J19395963-3058238 RG* 19 39 59.6373583174 -30 58 23.681625551   14.144 13.126   11.928 ~ 3 0
240 2MASS J19395964-3055100 RG* 19 39 59.6419720459 -30 55 10.063732260   13.144 11.775   10.315 ~ 4 0
241 M 55 GlC 19 39 59.71 -30 57 53.1     6.49     ~ 783 0
242 2MASS J19395981-3059272 RG* 19 39 59.8104908563 -30 59 27.222138375   13.805 12.694   11.419 ~ 3 0
243 2MASS J19400028-3100343 RG* 19 40 00.2853201157 -31 00 34.388444150   13.341 12.060   10.662 ~ 3 0
244 2MASS J19400052-3059547 RG* 19 40 00.52152 -30 59 54.7872   14.342 13.352   12.165 ~ 1 0
245 2MASS J19400056-3057173 AB* 19 40 00.56976 -30 57 17.3664   13.486 12.469   11.277 ~ 1 0
246 2MASS J19400069-3056093 AB* 19 40 00.69936 -30 56 09.3624   14.158 13.251   12.142 ~ 1 0
247 2MASS J19400147-3055590 RG* 19 40 01.4741880918 -30 55 59.061320255   14.125 13.096   11.902 ~ 3 0
248 2MASS J19400181-3058450 RG* 19 40 01.8126194100 -30 58 44.961338070   13.663 12.523   11.235 ~ 6 0
249 2MASS J19400182-3059008 RG* 19 40 01.8263849568 -30 59 00.834297062   15.067 14.188   13.103 ~ 3 0
250 2MASS J19400238-3058337 AB* 19 40 02.38080 -30 58 33.7584   13.547 12.465   11.215 ~ 1 0
251 2MASS J19400241-3047084 RG* 19 40 02.41296 -30 47 08.4984   13.733 12.621   11.356 ~ 2 0
252 2MASS J19400281-3056537 AB* 19 40 02.8093014593 -30 56 53.726965011   14.594 13.711   12.619 ~ 1 0
253 2MASS J19400294-3057134 RG* 19 40 02.9456489843 -30 57 13.467580228   13.440 12.205   10.854 ~ 3 0
254 2MASS J19400303-3052192 AB* 19 40 03.03360 -30 52 19.2000   14.509 13.682   12.634 ~ 1 0
255 2MASS J19400321-3101119 RG* 19 40 03.2139956938 -31 01 11.944959068   14.222 13.215   12.014 ~ 2 0
256 2MASS J19400407-3058206 RG* 19 40 04.0770710050 -30 58 20.649564678   12.998 11.439   9.840 ~ 4 0
257 2MASS J19400434-3103459 RG* 19 40 04.3448439609 -31 03 45.965067122   13.694 12.565   11.279 ~ 6 0
258 2MASS J19400449-3058024 AB* 19 40 04.49208 -30 58 02.4204   14.071 13.125   11.977 ~ 1 0
259 2MASS J19400473-3104389 RG* 19 40 04.7282533834 -31 04 38.876501359   13.467 12.287   10.956 ~ 3 0
260 2MASS J19400475-3051026 RG* 19 40 04.75800 -30 51 02.6100   14.706 13.765   12.636 ~ 1 0
261 2MASS J19400509-3057534 RG* 19 40 05.0925732381 -30 57 53.392392821   14.363 13.382   12.213 ~ 3 0
262 2MASS J19400535-3053118 RG* 19 40 05.3526283804 -30 53 11.852736669   14.536 13.579   12.433 ~ 3 0
263 2MASS J19400557-3100342 AB* 19 40 05.5712429572 -31 00 34.215030514   13.486 12.379   11.108 ~ 3 0
264 2MASS J19400601-3105110 AB* 19 40 06.01344 -31 05 11.0508   14.043 13.079   11.918 ~ 1 0
265 2MASS J19400673-3059218 RG* 19 40 06.736 -30 59 21.82   14.951 14.069   12.976 ~ 3 0
266 2MASS J19400734-3057438 AB* 19 40 07.34376 -30 57 43.8516   13.059 11.845   10.501 ~ 1 0
267 2MASS J19400785-3102131 RG* 19 40 07.8596585125 -31 02 13.145236720   14.853 13.942   12.822 ~ 3 0
268 2MASS J19400806-3058162 RG* 19 40 08.0604443765 -30 58 16.208196988   13.097 11.678   10.189 ~ 4 0
269 2MASS J19400814-3057309 RG* 19 40 08.14944 -30 57 30.9708   14.252 13.250   12.065 ~ 1 0
270 2MASS J19400853-3050167 RG* 19 40 08.5286900070 -30 50 16.816021198   14.971 14.073   12.970 ~ 3 0
271 2MASS J19400891-3059139 RG* 19 40 08.9119993717 -30 59 13.864843235   14.992 14.111   13.025 ~ 3 0
272 2MASS J19400987-3100111 RG* 19 40 09.8743173735 -31 00 11.118369353   14.710 13.776   12.643 ~ 3 0
273 2MASS J19401108-3057498 RG* 19 40 11.0820463588 -30 57 49.848654301   14.498 13.538   12.389 ~ 3 0
274 2MASS J19401176-3058103 AB* 19 40 11.76480 -30 58 10.3764   13.723 12.695   11.468 ~ 1 0
275 2MASS J19401265-3100287 AB* 19 40 12.6551542641 -31 00 28.723546581   13.611 12.519   11.262 ~ 5 0
276 2MASS J19401313-3057011 RG* 19 40 13.1352287046 -30 57 01.190722978   15.057 14.166   13.071 ~ 3 0
277 2MASS J19401317-3057390 RG* 19 40 13.179 -30 57 39.07   15.055 14.160   13.066 ~ 3 0
278 2MASS J19401457-3058486 RG* 19 40 14.57136 -30 58 48.6912   15.114 14.214   13.122 ~ 1 0
279 2MASS J19401513-3056496 AB* 19 40 15.13536 -30 56 49.6968   14.202 13.294   12.174 ~ 1 0
280 2MASS J19401549-3057021 RG* 19 40 15.4984859652 -30 57 02.140360096   13.231 11.942   10.540 ~ 3 0
281 2MASS J19401568-3054106 RG* 19 40 15.6821835909 -30 54 10.578604804   15.140 14.262   13.182 ~ 3 0
282 2MASS J19401816-3054272 RG* 19 40 18.1642545674 -30 54 27.246931728   13.827 12.719   11.465 ~ 5 0
283 2MASS J19401854-3056238 RG* 19 40 18.54528 -30 56 23.8704   14.163 13.131   11.924 ~ 1 0
284 2MASS J19402026-3055455 RG* 19 40 20.26584 -30 55 45.5304   14.766 13.833   12.711 ~ 1 0
285 2MASS J19402053-3058140 RG* 19 40 20.53512 -30 58 14.0844   14.016 12.950   11.722 ~ 1 0
286 2MASS J19402107-3055496 RG* 19 40 21.07728 -30 55 49.6956   15.140 14.238   13.149 ~ 1 0
287 2MASS J19402240-3104010 AB* 19 40 22.40016 -31 04 01.0596   14.126 13.191   12.053 ~ 1 0
288 2MASS J19402649-3059162 RG* 19 40 26.491 -30 59 16.28   13.566 12.361   11.029 ~ 3 0
289 2MASS J19402994-3100105 RG* 19 40 29.94912 -31 00 10.5408   15.091 14.191   13.105 ~ 1 0
290 2MASS J19403532-3052421 RG* 19 40 35.3235926939 -30 52 42.118401376   15.056 14.154   13.057 ~ 3 0
291 2MASS J19403632-3050343 AB* 19 40 36.32256 -30 50 34.3680   13.896 12.926   11.772 ~ 1 0
292 2MASS J19404029-3103586 RG* 19 40 40.29912 -31 03 58.6152   14.486 13.513   12.361 ~ 1 0
293 2MASS J19404991-3101425 RG* 19 40 49.91088 -31 01 42.5784   13.820 12.666   11.396 ~ 1 0
294 M 2 GlC 21 33 27.02 -00 49 23.7     6.25     ~ 932 1

    Equat.    Gal    SGal    Ecl

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2017A&A...607A.135W and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu


2021.06.19-21:13:37

© Université de Strasbourg/CNRS

    • Contact